Following a hot tip, the Lancaster County Police descend on Farlig's barn and wrestle him to the ground. He twists around wildly, shouting that it wasn't him, he never hated Darren, he would never kill anybody, he's just a simple vanillager who isn't that into the Amish flavor and wants to take night classes at mechanics school.
Ignoring his protests, the police shove him in the back of an internal combustion paddy wagon and haul him away. The community would later learn that Farlig would also be detained indefinitely, pending further investigation.