Warrior General Games

Thanks for your work, gents. Thanks just as much for disseminating the info accordingly


Edit: for a new page...

post was aimed towards Rage and taut, though I know a few others that could easily be included... PP, DB come to mind.

Could we do a test on Mentor and shut up those who thinks it does work? Just run 2 tests back to back:

Game 1) 5 CB with 80 vision and 2 Mentor CB (put them on ST)
Game 2) 5 CB with 100 vision and 0 Mentor

If it is really broken, the CBs in game 2 would play better than CBs in game 1. If not, then 2 CB should perform similarly since they have the same vision (80 vision + 25% bonus = 100 vision)

Originally posted by Iron Maiden
Could we do a test on Mentor and shut up those who thinks it does work? Just run 2 tests back to back:

Game 1) 5 CB with 80 vision and 2 Mentor CB (put them on ST)
Game 2) 5 CB with 100 vision and 0 Mentor

If it is really broken, the CBs in game 2 would play better than CBs in game 1. If not, then 2 CB should perform similarly since they have the same vision (80 vision + 25% bonus = 100 vision)

Not the way to test it. You want the same corners in both games, just with the mentors varrying.

Originally posted by pottsman
Originally posted by Iron Maiden

Could we do a test on Mentor and shut up those who thinks it does work? Just run 2 tests back to back:

Game 1) 5 CB with 80 vision and 2 Mentor CB (put them on ST)
Game 2) 5 CB with 100 vision and 0 Mentor

If it is really broken, the CBs in game 2 would play better than CBs in game 1. If not, then 2 CB should perform similarly since they have the same vision (80 vision + 25% bonus = 100 vision)

Not the way to test it. You want the same corners in both games, just with the mentors varying.

I guess it could work both ways. Mine is if you see a difference, it is broken. Yours is if you don't see a difference, it is broken.

Originally posted by Iron Maiden
Could we do a test on Mentor and shut up those who thinks it does work? Just run 2 tests back to back:

Game 1) 5 CB with 80 vision and 2 Mentor CB (put them on ST)
Game 2) 5 CB with 100 vision and 0 Mentor

If it is really broken, the CBs in game 2 would play better than CBs in game 1. If not, then 2 CB should perform similarly since they have the same vision (80 vision + 25% bonus = 100 vision)

i really think Mentor is broken as well...ive been looking at the end game summaries between when i had a mentor for our QB and when we didnt and i see absolutely zero correlation between the numbers...granted i know end game summary is almost meaningless but i should at least see some sort of difference in the better for our QB...and im just not at all..

at least you guys did not use all my builds

Originally posted by bhall43
i really think Mentor is broken as well...ive been looking at the end game summaries between when i had a mentor for our QB and when we didnt and i see absolutely zero correlation between the numbers...granted i know end game summary is almost meaningless but i should at least see some sort of difference in the better for our QB...and im just not at all..

Mentor is not broken the MoD Qb's had 100 morale after throwing 6 picks combined