Play by Play
| 1st Quarter | ||||
| Black Hand 15:00 | ||||
| 15:00 | Kickoff by Luis Donnelly, 48 yd, fielded by Laviska Shenault Jr. (25 yd return) [tackle: Kelton Helm] | Replay | ||
| 14:57 | 1st & 10 | OWN 47 | Sam Howell rush [TD] to the right (53 yd gain) | Replay |
| 14:47 | Extra point attempted by Jason Myers, made [XP] | Replay | ||
| New York Nightmares 14:47 | ||||
| 14:47 | Kickoff by Jason Myers, 67 yd, fielded by Travon Salas (8.5 yd return) [Monster Hit tackle: Ty Okada] | Replay | ||
| 14:45 | 1st & 10 | OWN 11.5 | Seth Burkhart pass to Sean Hamilton up the left side (incomplete) | Replay |
| 14:40 | 2nd & 10 | OWN 11.5 | Seth Burkhart pass to Ted Switzer, hurried by Byron Murphy II, up the right side, caught (3 yd gain) [tackle: Artie Burns] | Replay |
| 14:09 | 3rd & 7 | OWN 14.5 | Seth Burkhart sacked by William Leonards (4 yd loss) | Replay |
| 13:43 | 4th & 10.5 | OWN 10.5 | Punt by Seth Burkhart, 19 yd, fielded by Laviska Shenault Jr. [missed tackle: Zach Wing] [missed tackle: Frederick Drake] [TD] (30 yd return) | Replay |
| Black Hand 13:34 | ||||
| 13:34 | Extra point attempted by Jason Myers, made [XP] | Replay | ||
| New York Nightmares 13:34 | ||||
| 13:34 | Kickoff by Jason Myers, 65 yd, fielded by Travon Salas (6 yd return) [tackle: Darrell Taylor] | Replay | ||
| 13:32 | 1st & 10 | OWN 11 | Ted Switzer rush up the middle (2 yd gain) [tackle: Drake Thomas] | Replay |
| 13:03 | 2nd & 8 | OWN 13.5 | Elliott Dodge pass to Kelton Helm, hurried by Johnathan Hankins, over the middle [deflected by Mike Jackson.] (incomplete) | Replay |
| 12:58 | 3rd & 8 | OWN 13.5 | Elliott Dodge pass to Julian Floyd, hurried by Leonard Williams, up the left side, caught, knocked loose by Darrell Taylor [deflected by Darrell Taylor] (incomplete) | Replay |
| 12:53 | 4th & 8 | OWN 13.5 | Punt by Seth Burkhart, 22 yd, fielded by Laviska Shenault Jr. (12.5 yd return) [tackle: Glen Murry] | Replay |
| Black Hand 12:46 | ||||
| 12:46 | 1st & 10 | OPP 23 | Sam Howell rush [missed tackle: Frankie Heath (Power Through)] [missed tackle: Jamil Bingham] [TD] to the right (23 yd gain) | Replay |
| 12:39 | Extra point attempted by Jason Myers, made [XP] | Replay | ||
| New York Nightmares 12:39 | ||||
| 12:39 | Kickoff by Jason Myers, 71 yd, fielded by Travon Salas (7 yd return) [Big Hit tackle: Jonathan Sutherland] | Replay | ||
| 12:37 | 1st & 10 | OWN 6.5 | Ted Switzer rush up the middle (1.5 yd loss) [tackle: Leonard Williams] | Replay |
| 12:13 | 2nd & 11.5 | OWN 5 | Ted Switzer rush to the left (1.5 yd loss) [tackle: Myles Adams] | Replay |
| 11:50 | 3rd & 13 | OWN 3.5 | Ted Switzer rush up the middle (1 yd loss) [tackle: Leonard Williams] | Replay |
| 11:18 | 4th & 14.5 | OWN 2 | Punt by Seth Burkhart, 25 yd, fielded by Laviska Shenault Jr. [missed diving tackle: Kelton Helm (Spin)] (13.5 yd return) [tackle: Storm Velasquez] | Replay |
| Black Hand 11:11 | ||||
| 11:11 | 1st & 10 | OPP 13.5 | Sam Howell rush [missed diving tackle: Frankie Heath] [TD] to the right (13.5 yd gain) | Replay |
| 11:05 | Extra point attempted by Jason Myers, made [XP] | Replay | ||
| New York Nightmares 11:05 | ||||
| 11:05 | Kickoff by Jason Myers, 69 yd, fielded by Travon Salas (10.5 yd return) [Big Hit tackle: Jonathan Sutherland] | Replay | ||
| 11:02 | 1st & 10 | OWN 11 | Chandler Snodgrass rush up the middle (1.5 yd loss) [tackle: Leonard Williams] | Replay |
| 10:20 | 2nd & 11.5 | OWN 9.5 | Elliott Dodge bad pass to Sean Hamilton, hurried by Johnathan Hankins, up the left side [deflected by Drake Thomas] (incomplete - bad throw) | Replay |
| 10:16 | 3rd & 11.5 | OWN 9.5 | Elliott Dodge pass to Khalid Beam up the left side [deflected by Julian Love] (incomplete) | Replay |
| 10:12 | 4th & 11.5 | OWN 9.5 | Punt by Seth Burkhart, 20 yd, fielded by Laviska Shenault Jr. [TD] (30 yd return) | Replay |
| Black Hand 10:03 | ||||
| 10:03 | Extra point attempted by Jason Myers, made [XP] | Replay | ||
| New York Nightmares 10:03 | ||||
| 10:03 | Kickoff by Jason Myers, 77 yd, fielded by Travon Salas, 0 yds (touchback) | Replay | ||
| 10:03 | 1st & 10 | OWN 20 | Elliott Dodge pass to Khalid Beam up the left side intercepted by Devon Witherspoon. (5 yd return) [tackle: Ted Switzer] | Replay |
| Black Hand 9:57 | ||||
| 9:57 | 1st & 10 | OPP 23.5 | Geno Smith. pass to Pharoah Brown over the middle, caught (10 yd gain) [diving tackle: Jamil Bingham] | Replay |
| 9:19 | 2nd & inches | OPP 13.5 | Geno Smith. pass to Jake Bobo up the left side, caught (13.5 yd gain) [TD] | Replay |
| 9:14 | Extra point attempted by Jason Myers, made [XP] | Replay | ||
| New York Nightmares 9:14 | ||||
| 9:14 | Kickoff by Jason Myers, 68 yd, fielded by Travon Salas[Big Hit forced fumble: Jonathan Sutherland], fumbled , recovered by Darrell Taylor (0.5 yd return) [diving tackle: Khalid Beam] | Replay | ||
| Black Hand 9:08 | ||||
| 9:08 | 1st & 10 | OPP 10.5 | Sam Howell rush [missed tackle: Frankie Heath (Power Through)] [TD] to the right (10.5 yd gain) | Replay |
| 9:03 | Extra point attempted by Jason Myers, made [XP] | Replay | ||
| New York Nightmares 9:03 | ||||
| 9:03 | Kickoff by Jason Myers, 79 yd, fielded by Travon Salas, 0 yds (touchback) | Replay | ||
| 9:03 | 1st & 10 | OWN 20 | Elliott Dodge bad pass to Alonso Mills, hurried by Byron Murphy II, up the right side [deflected by Artie Burns] (incomplete - bad throw) | Replay |
| 8:57 | 2nd & 10 | OWN 20 | Elliott Dodge pass to Rey Keyes up the left side, thrown low [deflected by Devon Witherspoon.] (incomplete) | Replay |
| 8:52 | 3rd & 10 | OWN 20 | Elliott Dodge bad pass to Patrick Wright up the left side (incomplete - bad throw) | Replay |
| 8:46 | 4th & 10 | OWN 20 | Punt by Seth Burkhart, 19 yd, fielded by Laviska Shenault Jr. [TD] (39 yd return) | Replay |
| Black Hand 8:36 | ||||
| 8:36 | Extra point attempted by Jason Myers, made [XP] | Replay | ||
| New York Nightmares 8:36 | ||||
| 8:36 | Kickoff by Jason Myers, 72 yd, fielded by Travon Salas[Monster Hit forced fumble: Jonathan Sutherland], fumbled , recovered by Ty Okada (0 yd return) [diving tackle: Travon Salas] | Replay | ||
| Black Hand 8:30 | ||||
| 8:30 | 1st & G | OPP 6.5 | Zach Charbonnet rush up the middle (1.5 yd gain) [diving tackle: Raheem Romano] | Replay |
| 8:04 | 2nd & G | OPP 5 | Kenneth Walker III rush [missed diving tackle: Jamil Bingham (Hurdle)] [missed diving tackle: Travon Bowers (Power Through)] [missed tackle: Dallin Merrill (Power Through)] [TD] up the middle (5 yd gain) | Replay |
| 8:00 | Extra point attempted by Jason Myers, made [XP] | Replay | ||
| New York Nightmares 8:00 | ||||
| 8:00 | Kickoff by Jason Myers, 70 yd, fielded by Travon Salas (11.5 yd return) [tackle: Ty Okada] | Replay | ||
| 7:57 | 1st & 10 | OWN 12 | Elliott Dodge pitch to Ted Switzer to the left (1.5 yd loss) [diving tackle: Dre'Mont Jones.] | Replay |
| 7:30 | 2nd & 11.5 | OWN 10.5 | Elliott Dodge sacked by Byron Murphy II (5.5 yd loss) | Replay |
| 7:04 | 3rd & 17 | OWN 5 | Elliott Dodge bad pass to Ted Switzer, hurried by Byron Murphy II, over the middle [deflected by Byron Murphy II] (incomplete - bad throw) | Replay |
| 6:59 | 4th & 17 | OWN 5 | Punt by Seth Burkhart, 22 yd, fielded by Laviska Shenault Jr. [missed diving tackle: Seth Burkhart] [TD] (28 yd return) | Replay |
| Black Hand 6:50 | ||||
| 6:50 | Extra point attempted by Jason Myers, made [XP] | Replay | ||
| New York Nightmares 6:50 | ||||
| 6:50 | Kickoff by Jason Myers, 75 yd, fielded by Travon Salas, 0 yds (touchback) | Replay | ||
| 6:50 | 1st & 10 | OWN 20 | Elliott Dodge bad pass to Rey Keyes, hurried by Leonard Williams, up the right side intercepted by Riq Woolen. (0 yd return) [tackle: Rey Keyes] | Replay |
| Black Hand 6:45 | ||||
| 6:45 | 1st & 10 | OPP 31.5 | Zach Charbonnet rush [missed diving tackle: Garret Maxwell (Power Through)] [missed diving tackle: Jamil Bingham (Power Through)] to the right (9.5 yd gain) [diving tackle: Jerald Deleon] | Replay |
| 6:12 | 2nd & 0.5 | OPP 22 | Geno Smith. pass to Jaxon Smith-Njigba over the middle, caught [TD] (22 yd gain) | Replay |
| 6:07 | Extra point attempted by Jason Myers, made [XP] | Replay | ||
| New York Nightmares 6:07 | ||||
| 6:07 | Kickoff by Jason Myers, 69 yd, fielded by Travon Salas (9 yd return) [Monster Hit tackle: Jonathan Sutherland] | Replay | ||
| 6:04 | 1st & 10 | OWN 10.5 | Elliott Dodge rush to the left (2 yd loss) [tackle: Coby Bryant] | Replay |
| 5:28 | 2nd & 12 | OWN 8.5 | Elliott Dodge bad pass to Patrick Wright, hurried by Johnathan Hankins, up the left side, thrown low intercepted by Jerrick Reed II (0 yd return) [tackle: Patrick Wright] | Replay |
| Black Hand 5:23 | ||||
| 5:23 | 1st & 10 | OPP 18.5 | Geno Smith. pass to McIntosh Kenny over the middle [deflected by Travon Salas] (incomplete) | Replay |
| 5:19 | 2nd & 10 | OPP 18.5 | Geno Smith. pass to Noah Fant. over the middle, caught (4 yd gain) [tackle: Adam Inman] | Replay |
| 4:46 | 3rd & 6 | OPP 14 | Geno Smith. pass to Pharoah Brown over the middle, caught [TD] (14 yd gain) | Replay |
| 4:42 | Extra point attempted by Jason Myers, made [XP] | Replay | ||
| New York Nightmares 4:42 | ||||
| 4:42 | Kickoff by Jason Myers, 67 yd, fielded by Travon Salas (10 yd return) [Big Hit tackle: Jonathan Sutherland] | Replay | ||
| 4:39 | 1st & 10 | OWN 12.5 | Elliott Dodge bad pass to Kelton Helm, hurried by Byron Murphy II, up the right side [deflected by Riq Woolen.] (incomplete - bad throw) | Replay |
| 4:34 | 2nd & 10 | OWN 12.5 | Elliott Dodge pass to Edgar Henson, hurried by Leonard Williams, over the middle [deflected by K'Von Wallace.] (incomplete) | Replay |
| 4:30 | 3rd & 10 | OWN 12.5 | Elliott Dodge bad pass to Patrick Wright, hurried by Leonard Williams, up the left side, thrown low [deflected by Julian Love] (incomplete - bad throw) | Replay |
| 4:26 | 4th & 10 | OWN 12.5 | Punt by Seth Burkhart, 9 yd, fielded by Laviska Shenault Jr. (fair catch) | Replay |
| Black Hand 4:22 | ||||
| 4:22 | 1st & 10 | OPP 22 | Zach Charbonnet rush [missed tackle: Jamil Bingham (Power Through)] [missed tackle: Travon Salas] [TD] up the middle (22 yd gain) | Replay |
| 4:16 | Extra point attempted by Jason Myers, made [XP] | Replay | ||
| New York Nightmares 4:16 | ||||
| 4:16 | Kickoff by Jason Myers, 76 yd, fielded by Travon Salas, 0 yds (touchback) | Replay | ||
| 4:16 | 1st & 10 | OWN 20 | Elliott Dodge bad pass to Julian Floyd, hurried by Leonard Williams, up the left side (incomplete - bad throw) | Replay |
| 4:11 | 2nd & 10 | OWN 20 | Elliott Dodge pass to Ted Switzer, hurried by Tyrel Dodson, over the middle, jumping catch attempt, caught (2 yd loss) [diving tackle: Tyrel Dodson] | Replay |
| 3:44 | 3rd & 12 | OWN 18 | Elliott Dodge pass to Rey Keyes up the right side, caught (5.5 yd gain) [tackle: Artie Burns] | Replay |
| 3:15 | 4th & 6.5 | OWN 23.5 | Punt by Seth Burkhart, 13 yd, fielded by Laviska Shenault Jr. (fair catch) | Replay |
| Black Hand 3:10 | ||||
| 3:10 | 1st & 10 | OPP 36 | Zach Charbonnet rush up the middle (3 yd gain) [tackle: Westley Garrison] | Replay |
| 2:37 | 2nd & 7 | OPP 33 | Geno Smith. pitch to Kenny McIntosh [TD] to the left (33 yd gain) | Replay |
| 2:30 | Extra point attempted by Jason Myers, made [XP] | Replay | ||
| New York Nightmares 2:30 | ||||
| 2:30 | Kickoff by Jason Myers, 80 yds (touchback) | Replay | ||
| 2:30 | 1st & 10 | OWN 20 | Chandler Snodgrass rush[forced fumble: Byron Murphy II], fumbled , recovered by Riq Woolen. (1 yd return) [diving tackle: Luis Donnelly] | Replay |
| Black Hand 2:25 | ||||
| 2:25 | 1st & 10 | OPP 16 | Sam Howell rush [TD] to the right (16 yd gain) | Replay |
| 2:19 | Extra point attempted by Jason Myers, made [XP] | Replay | ||
| New York Nightmares 2:19 | ||||
| 2:19 | Kickoff by Jason Myers, 62 yd, fielded by Travon Salas[Monster Hit forced fumble: Jonathan Sutherland], fumbled , recovered by Patrick O'Connell (2 yd return) [tackle: Randolph Short] | Replay | ||
| Black Hand 2:15 | ||||
| 2:15 | 1st & 10 | OPP 17.5 | Kenneth Walker III rush [missed diving tackle: Jamil Bingham] [missed tackle: Elliott Crowder] [TD] up the middle (17.5 yd gain) | Replay |
| 2:09 | Extra point attempted by Jason Myers, made [XP] | Replay | ||
| New York Nightmares 2:09 | ||||
| 2:09 | Kickoff by Jason Myers, 74 yd, fielded by Travon Salas, 0 yds (touchback) | Replay | ||
| 2:09 | 1st & 10 | OWN 20 | Chandler Snodgrass rush up the middle (2 yd loss) [Big Hit tackle: Byron Murphy II] | Replay |
| 1:40 | 2nd & 12 | OWN 18 | Elliott Dodge pass to Khalid Beam, hurried by Johnathan Hankins, up the right side, caught (7.5 yd gain) [tackle: Tre Brown.] | Replay |
| 0:59 | 3rd & 4.5 | OWN 25.5 | Elliott Dodge pass to Rey Keyes up the right side [deflected by Rayshawn Jenkins] (incomplete) | Replay |
| 0:56 | 4th & 4.5 | OWN 25.5 | Punt by Seth Burkhart, 23 yd, fielded by Laviska Shenault Jr. [TD] (49.5 yd return) | Replay |
| Black Hand 0:45 | ||||
| 0:45 | Extra point attempted by Jason Myers, made [XP] | Replay | ||
| New York Nightmares 0:45 | ||||
| 0:45 | Kickoff by Jason Myers, 77 yd, fielded by Travon Salas, 0 yds (touchback) | Replay | ||
| 0:45 | 1st & 10 | OWN 20 | Elliott Dodge pass to Patrick Wright up the left side intercepted by Jerrick Reed II (1 yd return) [tackle: Patrick Wright] | Replay |
| Black Hand 0:39 | ||||
| 0:39 | 1st & 10 | OPP 42 | Sam Howell rush [TD] to the right (42 yd gain) | Replay |
| 0:30 | Extra point attempted by Jason Myers, made [XP] | Replay | ||
| New York Nightmares 0:30 | ||||
| 0:30 | Kickoff by Jason Myers, 64 yd, fielded by Travon Salas (9.5 yd return) [Monster Hit tackle: Jonathan Sutherland] | Replay | ||
| 0:27 | 1st & 10 | OWN 15 | Chandler Snodgrass rush up the middle (2.5 yd loss) [tackle: Jerome Baker] | Replay |
| 0:04 | 2nd & 12.5 | OWN 12.5 | Elliott Dodge sacked by Myles Adams (6 yd loss) | Replay |





