Play by Play
| 2nd Quarter | ||||
| NY Nightmare 15:00 | ||||
| 15:00 | 1st & 10 | OPP 42.5 | Quincy Frey screen pass to Aiden Eller to the right side, caught (7 yd gain) [diving tackle: Irving Rasmussen] | Replay |
| 14:26 | 2nd & 3 | OPP 36 | Mathew Pickering pass to Luciano Lyons up the right side, caught (1.5 yd gain) [tackle: Alejandro Archer] | Replay |
| 13:47 | 3rd & 1.5 | OPP 34.5 | Quincy Frey pass to Rodolfo Salgado over the middle [deflected by Dalton Justice] (incomplete) | Replay |
| 13:42 | 4th & 1.5 | OPP 34.5 | Punt by Jordan Morris, 14 yd, fielded by Kendal Harms (8 yd return) [diving tackle: Donnell Gee] | Replay |
| Pittsburgh Extreme 13:34 | ||||
| 13:34 | 1st & 10 | OWN 28 | Preacher Favre pass to Dana Manning up the left side, caught (7 yd gain) [tackle: Gonzalo Cardona] | Replay |
| 12:59 | 2nd & 3 | OWN 35.5 | Paulie Hernandez rush up the middle (1 yd gain) [tackle: Destin Tate] | Replay |
| 12:34 | 3rd & 2 | OWN 36.5 | Preacher Favre pass to Dana Manning over the middle, caught (0.5 yd loss) [tackle: Antwon Wall] | Replay |
| 12:07 | 4th & 2.5 | OWN 35.5 | Punt by Efren Henderson, 16 yd, fielded by Giovanny Strange (11.5 yd return) [diving tackle: Wendell Bledsoe] | Replay |
| NY Nightmare 11:58 | ||||
| 11:58 | 1st & 10 | OPP 40 | Quincy Frey screen pass to Rodolfo Salgado to the right side, caught (2.5 yd gain) [diving tackle: Irving Rasmussen] | Replay |
| 11:30 | 2nd & 7.5 | OPP 37.5 | Mathew Pickering sacked by Irving Rasmussen (3 yd loss) | Replay |
| 11:01 | 3rd & 10.5 | OPP 40.5 | Quincy Frey pass to Rey Keyes up the left side, caught (14 yd gain) [tackle: Tyrell Hooper] | Replay |
| 10:26 | 1st & 10 | OPP 26.5 | Aiden Eller rush up the middle (1.5 yd gain) [diving tackle: Garett Fletcher] | Replay |
| 9:49 | 2nd & 8.5 | OPP 25 | Mathew Pickering sacked by Jefferson Wetzel (2.5 yd loss) | Replay |
| 9:11 | 3rd & 10.5 | OPP 27 | Quincy Frey pass to Rey Keyes up the left side, caught (14 yd gain) [diving tackle: Niko Cope] | Replay |
| 8:34 | 1st & 10 | OPP 13 | Aiden Eller rush up the middle (3 yd gain) [tackle: Alexander Schmitt] | Replay |
| 7:51 | 2nd & 7 | OPP 10 | Mathew Pickering sacked by Garett Fletcher (0.5 yd loss) | Replay |
| 7:14 | 3rd & 7.5 | OPP 10.5 | Quincy Frey pass to %^$ + up the right side, caught (10.5 yd gain) [TD] | Replay |
| 7:08 | Extra point attempted by Peter Thomson, made [XP] | Replay | ||
| Pittsburgh Extreme 7:08 | ||||
| 7:08 | Kickoff by Peter Thomson, 48 yd, fielded by Armand Jamison [missed tackle: Peter Thomson] (28 yd return) [tackle: Antwon Wall] | Replay | ||
| 6:59 | 1st & 10 | OWN 49.5 | Preacher Favre pitch to Bobby Keen to the right (2 yd gain) [tackle: Freddy Little] | Replay |
| 6:13 | 2nd & 8 | OPP 48.5 | Jonathan Gilbert pass to Keven Hess up the right side (dropped - incomplete) | Replay |
| 6:09 | 3rd & 8 | OPP 48.5 | Preacher Favre pass to Brenton Field over the middle, caught (12.5 yd gain) [tackle: Colt Price] | Replay |
| 5:27 | 1st & 10 | OPP 35.5 | Jonathan Gilbert pass to Bobby Keen over the middle, caught (5.5 yd gain) [tackle: Ariel Chastain] | Replay |
| 4:44 | 2nd & 4.5 | OPP 30 | Kendal Harms rush [missed diving tackle: Joshua Lipscomb] up the middle (3.5 yd gain) [diving tackle: Colt Price] | Replay |
| 4:12 | 3rd & 1 | OPP 26.5 | Jonathan Gilbert screen pass to Keven Hess to the right side (dropped - incomplete) | Replay |
| 4:07 | 4th & 1 | OPP 26.5 | Paulie Hernandez rush up the middle (4 yd gain) [tackle: Colt Price] | Replay |
| 3:34 | 1st & 10 | OPP 22.5 | Preacher Favre sacked by Antwon Wall (0.5 yd loss) | Replay |
| 2:47 | 2nd & 10.5 | OPP 23 | Jonathan Gilbert pass to Kendal Harms over the middle, caught (2 yd loss) [tackle: Jerrod Black] | Replay |
| 2:19 | 3rd & 12.5 | OPP 25 | Jonathan Gilbert pass to Jerod Bray up the right side, thrown low, caught (14 yd gain) [tackle: Gonzalo Cardona] | Replay |
| 2:00 | 1st & 10 | OPP 11 | Preacher Favre pass to Aric Torres up the left side (dropped - incomplete) | Replay |
| 1:54 | 2nd & 10 | OPP 11 | Paulie Hernandez rush to the right (2 yd gain) [tackle: Dane Chadwick] | Replay |
| 1:49 | 3rd & 8 | OPP 9 | Offensive Timeout Called: Pittsburgh Extreme | Replay |
| 1:49 | 3rd & 8 | OPP 9 | Preacher Favre sacked by Dane Chadwick (1 yd loss) | Replay |
| 1:00 | 4th & 9 | OPP 10 | 27 yd field goal attempted by Ahmed Parris, missed | Replay |
| NY Nightmare 0:56 | ||||
| 0:56 | 1st & 10 | OWN 20 | Rodolfo Salgado rush up the middle (2 yd gain) [diving tackle: Joseph Grove] | Replay |
| 0:23 | 2nd & 8 | OWN 22 | Aiden Eller rush to the right (2 yd gain) [tackle: Irving Rasmussen] | Replay |