Originally posted by Pong
Originally posted by kr0n
i think people get QB Runs confused with scramble frequency.
scramble to me means that the QB moves around in the pocket much more leading to plays like this:
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?pbp_id=8806008
I see that as Pocket Presence as the DT was right in your face from the get go.
Pocket Presence is a strange ability. It is a little vague (probably intentionally) but the description sounds like it might help negate the penalty to accuracy and pass quality you get for throwing when someone is actively hurrying you. So the plays that start out with "<name here> pass to <name here>, hurried by <name here>" have an increased chance of ending with a completion instead of a deflection, interception, or just plain missed pass.
Some people would say Pocket Presence represents moving around inside the pocket to avoid tacklers. Others would say vision determines your QB deciding to move around inside the pocket if he sees a threat and scrambling frequency represents your willingness to leave the pocket. Personally I think scrambling does represent movement both inside and outside the pocket mostly because I don't think the game recognizes actual boundaries of the pocket (no reason to unless you want to implement intentional grounding and throwing the ball away or want to get really technical about what is and is not a sack when tackling a QB running a sweep when they add QB runs other than draw). To me Pocket Presence is your QB staying calm and making the proper throw even though he knows a defender is about to hit him instead of panicking and throwing a bad pass trying to avoid the hit.
That being said my QB has always been set to "almost never" for scrambling with pretty good pocket presence but no scrambler special abilities and occasionally does produce some similar plays:
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?pbp_id=7188821That play the QB wasn't hurried (no "hurried by so and so" in the play by play) though he does run outside the pocket as the line gets pushed back. If pocket presence is just a bonus to pass quality and accuracy when throwing while a defender is hurrying you then it didn't activate and that play represents either vision leading to QB running outside the pocket, a designed QB bootleg pass play, or was the rare exception inherent in "ALMOST never scramble."
Just a side note about the play, it is strange that all the both TEs and the #1 WR run curl routes then just stand in place and wait around while the #2 WR runs a deep route then stops at about the same time and also just stands still making no move to get open while the QB buys time. The only receiver that keeps moving is the HB that eventually makes the catch. If you can find examples where the receivers all repeat that odd behavior AND the QB rolls out to throw then it is likely it is a designed play, but I don't know if you will find it, it seems a little strange to draw up THAT. My money is on it being the rare exception.