so if my WR or CB is a returner they will pretty much have a advantage over players who dont have the Archetype for returning kicks and punts and therefore a advantage in getting the starting job for being the Returner?
TheNileKing
offline
offline
TrevJo,
Well it's obvious that there are a lot of challenges in building an effective WR. They need so much more than speed and agility to be able to get open, make a solid catch, and hold on to the ball.
Our discussion influenced me to work even harder and come up with new, unconventional ideas for my WR's.. so thank you. That's the kind of builder I am anyway.
I have some basic plans of what I want to do with my season 14 WR's, but it all depends on which archetype I choose. Guess I'll just have to come up with a favorite (or the one I hate least. hahaha). Maybe one of each.
Well it's obvious that there are a lot of challenges in building an effective WR. They need so much more than speed and agility to be able to get open, make a solid catch, and hold on to the ball.
Our discussion influenced me to work even harder and come up with new, unconventional ideas for my WR's.. so thank you. That's the kind of builder I am anyway.
I have some basic plans of what I want to do with my season 14 WR's, but it all depends on which archetype I choose. Guess I'll just have to come up with a favorite (or the one I hate least. hahaha). Maybe one of each.
TrevJo
offline
offline
Originally posted by Raiderfan4Life
so if my WR or CB is a returner they will pretty much have a advantage over players who dont have the Archetype for returning kicks and punts and therefore a advantage in getting the starting job for being the Returner?
Correct.
so if my WR or CB is a returner they will pretty much have a advantage over players who dont have the Archetype for returning kicks and punts and therefore a advantage in getting the starting job for being the Returner?
Correct.
TrevJo
offline
offline
Originally posted by TheNileKing
TrevJo,
Well it's obvious that there are a lot of challenges in building an effective WR. They need so much more than speed and agility to be able to get open, make a solid catch, and hold on to the ball.
I agree. One way to look at that is that this is a reason having slightly less speed and agility ALGs is not so bad.
Originally posted by TheNileKing
Our discussion influenced me to work even harder and come up with new, unconventional ideas for my WR's.. so thank you. That's the kind of builder I am anyway.
Cool man. I like unconventional builds myself.
TrevJo,
Well it's obvious that there are a lot of challenges in building an effective WR. They need so much more than speed and agility to be able to get open, make a solid catch, and hold on to the ball.
I agree. One way to look at that is that this is a reason having slightly less speed and agility ALGs is not so bad.
Originally posted by TheNileKing
Our discussion influenced me to work even harder and come up with new, unconventional ideas for my WR's.. so thank you. That's the kind of builder I am anyway.
Cool man. I like unconventional builds myself.
Edited by TrevJo on Mar 17, 2010 13:06:55
Edited by TrevJo on Mar 17, 2010 13:06:35
Catch22
offline
offline
Originally posted by F8n4tune
So is the 25% reduction in ALG's whether you choose archetype or not ? , thanks.
That already happens.
So is the 25% reduction in ALG's whether you choose archetype or not ? , thanks.
That already happens.
F8n4tune
offline
offline
Originally posted by Catch22
Originally posted by F8n4tune
So is the 25% reduction in ALG's whether you choose archetype or not ? , thanks.
That already happens.
Thanks bro.
Originally posted by F8n4tune
So is the 25% reduction in ALG's whether you choose archetype or not ? , thanks.
That already happens.
Thanks bro.
I'm not sure if this has been said, and I know you said there will be no more changes to the archetypes, but if Zone Specialist is going to become an SA, it really needs to be the bonus SA for the Zone Secondary archetype.
Staz
offline
offline
Originally posted by Longhornfan1024
I'm not sure if this has been said, and I know you said there will be no more changes to the archetypes, but if Zone Specialist is going to become an SA, it really needs to be the bonus SA for the Zone Secondary archetype.
You get to choose it, but I don't think any "extra" SAs should be bonuses/penalty. That would just make a "dumb choice" not to pick that SA if it's a bonus.
I'm not sure if this has been said, and I know you said there will be no more changes to the archetypes, but if Zone Specialist is going to become an SA, it really needs to be the bonus SA for the Zone Secondary archetype.
You get to choose it, but I don't think any "extra" SAs should be bonuses/penalty. That would just make a "dumb choice" not to pick that SA if it's a bonus.
Originally posted by Staz
You get to choose it, but I don't think any "extra" SAs should be bonuses/penalty. That would just make a "dumb choice" not to pick that SA if it's a bonus.
It's already a dumb choice not to take Zone Spec as a bonus SA if you are building a zone CB.
EDIT: Although this is NGTH, what should really be done is to remove RS from the speedster tree and give it only to returner archetypes. Then move blitz to slot 3, CS to slot 4, and throw Zone Spec in slot 5.
You get to choose it, but I don't think any "extra" SAs should be bonuses/penalty. That would just make a "dumb choice" not to pick that SA if it's a bonus.
It's already a dumb choice not to take Zone Spec as a bonus SA if you are building a zone CB.
EDIT: Although this is NGTH, what should really be done is to remove RS from the speedster tree and give it only to returner archetypes. Then move blitz to slot 3, CS to slot 4, and throw Zone Spec in slot 5.
Edited by Longhornfan1024 on Mar 18, 2010 10:23:59
Phantom_Opera
offline
offline
Originally posted by Longhornfan1024
Originally posted by Staz
You get to choose it, but I don't think any "extra" SAs should be bonuses/penalty. That would just make a "dumb choice" not to pick that SA if it's a bonus.
It's already a dumb choice not to take Zone Spec as a bonus SA if you are building a zone CB.
EDIT: Although this is NGTH, what should really be done is to remove RS from the speedster tree and give it only to returner archetypes. Then move blitz to slot 3, CS to slot 4, and throw Zone Spec in slot 5.
I agree 100%
Originally posted by Staz
You get to choose it, but I don't think any "extra" SAs should be bonuses/penalty. That would just make a "dumb choice" not to pick that SA if it's a bonus.
It's already a dumb choice not to take Zone Spec as a bonus SA if you are building a zone CB.
EDIT: Although this is NGTH, what should really be done is to remove RS from the speedster tree and give it only to returner archetypes. Then move blitz to slot 3, CS to slot 4, and throw Zone Spec in slot 5.
I agree 100%
Catch22
offline
offline
Originally posted by Longhornfan1024
It's already a dumb choice not to take Zone Spec as a bonus SA if you are building a zone CB.
EDIT: Although this is NGTH, what should really be done is to remove RS from the speedster tree and give it only to returner archetypes. Then move blitz to slot 3, CS to slot 4, and throw Zone Spec in slot 5.
Not a terrible idea tbh. I'll try and remember to ask Bort what he thinks about it, especially since we have Returner archetypes now and the extra SA where players can choose RS.
It's already a dumb choice not to take Zone Spec as a bonus SA if you are building a zone CB.
EDIT: Although this is NGTH, what should really be done is to remove RS from the speedster tree and give it only to returner archetypes. Then move blitz to slot 3, CS to slot 4, and throw Zone Spec in slot 5.
Not a terrible idea tbh. I'll try and remember to ask Bort what he thinks about it, especially since we have Returner archetypes now and the extra SA where players can choose RS.
Originally posted by Catch22
Not a terrible idea tbh. I'll try and remember to ask Bort what he thinks about it, especially since we have Returner archetypes now and the extra SA where players can choose RS.
lol. I thought that would get a flat rejection. Well that's good as I think it would be really helpful, and CBs might actually start putting points in the lower tree past CD.
Not a terrible idea tbh. I'll try and remember to ask Bort what he thinks about it, especially since we have Returner archetypes now and the extra SA where players can choose RS.
lol. I thought that would get a flat rejection. Well that's good as I think it would be really helpful, and CBs might actually start putting points in the lower tree past CD.
Staz
offline
offline
Originally posted by Longhornfan1024
It's already a dumb choice not to take Zone Spec as a bonus SA if you are building a zone CB.
EDIT: Although this is NGTH, what should really be done is to remove RS from the speedster tree and give it only to returner archetypes. Then move blitz to slot 3, CS to slot 4, and throw Zone Spec in slot 5.
Not entirely. Could it benefit you? Sure, but what if I want to pick a ZS archtype, but pick Aura as my extra SA? Anybody entering my zone gets a morale hit. What about monster hit? Jack Hammer? Big Hit? Those could easily be beneficial for a zone CB, easily.
It's already a dumb choice not to take Zone Spec as a bonus SA if you are building a zone CB.
EDIT: Although this is NGTH, what should really be done is to remove RS from the speedster tree and give it only to returner archetypes. Then move blitz to slot 3, CS to slot 4, and throw Zone Spec in slot 5.
Not entirely. Could it benefit you? Sure, but what if I want to pick a ZS archtype, but pick Aura as my extra SA? Anybody entering my zone gets a morale hit. What about monster hit? Jack Hammer? Big Hit? Those could easily be beneficial for a zone CB, easily.
You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.






























