Originally posted by Sly
So you have a network, but you consider a small network. I guess a small network is still a network, huh?
Suffice it to say that I don't think your version of events as described above is truly honest and accurate. I just don't have time to respond to all the things that I found to be misleading and inaccurate, but just to provide an example, you made this point near the end that your team went from a 4-12 team to a 15-1 team because of your amazing recruiting skills. Those aren't your exact, but that's definitely what you are inferring. In fact, what you lead people to conclude is that you took a scrub roster from S11 and just brought in a completely new roster by S13. But actually, as I am prepared to demonstrate, you already had the core roster that starred in S13 in place in S11 and it wan't your amazing recruiting that caused such a turnaround since you had same key players in the same key positions. Just to show how misleading and incorrect your description is I took the time to break down your big offensive players and the fact is that you had a star-laden team already in S11. You already had a star QB, HB, rushing/receiving FB, blocking FB, top WR, and a whole O-line in place in S11 which were the same players that starred on your team in S13. I don't have time to do the same analysis with your defense but I'm sure the we'll find the same - you had your whole core in place in S11 already including most of your big stars who shined so much in S13. So your "dramatic" turnaround was hardly the recruiting genius that you imply.
QB Darrell Williams (tyante) was the same QB in S13 you had in S11, so no recruiting stroke of genius there. He was the USA Pro MVP in S12 and one of the most prolific QBs in Pro/WL from S11-S14. You had that agent's G Freddy Smalls on your team from S8.
HB Devon Wolfe (raggman) was the same HB in S13 you had in S11, in fact you had him since S2, so again no recruiting stroke of genius there. He was a prolific rusher and receiver. He had well over 1000 yards and 23 TDs in the regular season S13. In S3 he brought his LB Rock McNasty. In S5 he also brought his T Benny Big'un. All these players were on your roster in both S11 and S13.
FB Adam Obelix (Malvado) was the same FB in S13 you had in S11, so again no recruiting stroke of genius. He was a prolific rusher/receiver, especially for a FB. He had about 800 yards rushing in S13.
FB Jake Hayes (sklz711) was the same blocking FB in S13 you had in S11, in fact you had him since S3, so again no recruiting stroke of genius.
WR Joe Monk (jrope) was your same top WR in S13 you had in S11, in fact since S2, so again no recruiting stroke of genius. He had about 1000 yards and won the 1st place receiving TDs award in S13 with 16. You also had his T on your team from S2. You had his DT Tommy Bear Harris from S4. Between S7 and S15 he won 5 awards for leading various leagues in sacks and hurries.
You had an entire O-line intact from S11 to S13. I've already mentioned above a G and two T's. Add to that C Olin Saturday (mpowell) was with you all that time. And jktooley had a G on your team from S10.
So you probably added a few good players, admittedly, but you already had the core in place in S11, so your the way you described this turnaround as being some product of amazing recruiting is just misleading and inaccurate. And if I took the same time I could show many other examples in your dissertation. So you tell yourself whatever you want, but I know better. I was there.
Lol, sly, two important takeaways here.
#1 I truly appreciate your research and the walk down memory lane of our own dots was very fun for me, A+.
#2 I would like to formally apologize. S11 was not the season we went 4-12 in USA, but rather it was the season after our "purge" of sorts. In my defense I didn't think you would go all private investigator when I dealt out the years...
Accurate timeline...
S10: 4-12 in USAPro, Off-season Purge. I honestly am not sure how you were able do your research as I am getting server errors trying to look at those old games? If memory serves about half our roster was replaced (which is INSANE in pre-decline GLB). Of the players you listed I know the QB and oFB joined in S11, The WR and HB were oldschool Hedgehogs (with the WR belonging to my co-owner), not sure when sklz and his bFB joined.
S11: 9-7 in USAPro. 1st round playoff exit.
S12: 15-1 in USAPro, 2nd round playoff exit.
S13: 15-1 in USAPro, Conference championship+WL Promotion.
Keep in mind, from S10 to S11, I was a 4-12 Pro team recruiting for top dots against Pro conference champions and 14+ win teams, and I was able to win in recruiting a remarkable number of them away from much "better" teams. I did that by not just selling the team, but rather selling the vision and the future. The core put in place the off-season before season 11 I agree is the same that promoted to WL in S13, ldo
If that is not impressive recruiting, I'm not sure what impressive recruiting is. The fact that we survived from season 2 to season 35 (no resets) with all of 2 farm teams hitting maturity (out of which less than 50 dots total became Hedgehogs), again points to the rare ability to recruit at a high level.
I have some guys who have liked it here and stuck around with dots (stizz being a big one obviously), but everyone had to be recruited to join the team in the first place, and player retention is not proof of bad recruiting, but rather proof of good ownership. To take the leap and say that people liking the Hedgehogs means I am not a good recruiter is nonsensical, as being liked by others is the very trait that makes quality recruiting possible...
imo fwiw.