User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Page:
 
Derek4jc
offline
Link
 
Offense
QB: Aaron Drew, Devils Advocate, Gunner McGavin
RB: Lightning Fury, Thurman Tomas, "Runnin' for" Miles Patrick
FB: Pron Star, Obadiah Butcher
WR: Walter Harris, Gerry Royce, Aidan Pryde, Cyle Desjardins
TE: Hoches de la Noches, Buddro Budopolis
OT: Harold Tubbs, Sammy Thaiday, Southern Stout
OG: chocolate chip pancake, Ricky Faneca, Corey Peters Jr.
C: Jalen Smurf, BEEF HEAD, Hugo Tubbs

Defense
DE: Robbie Lawler, Adewale Ojomo, Storm Breaker
DT: Max Contract, Ripp Hymen, Old Tree
OLB: Dimitrius Morgan, Harold Ramis, Iron Cross
MLB/ILB: The Mechagodzilla, Dia Beetis
CB: King Ghidorah, Swift-Footed Achilles, Sam Austin
FS: Officer Frank Serpicio, Cookie Buchanon
SS: Asphincter Sayswhat, Arnaud Allard

Special Teams
K: Kaka Caboom
P: Jacob Shaffer
KR/PR: Blue Panther
 
Greg B
offline
Link
 
Kind of suprised not to see Ure in there
 
Staz
offline
Link
 
Looks like the Karnage are going to have to hit the training facility hard this offseason to get some bastards up on that list
 
Derek4jc
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Greg Butler
Kind of suprised not to see Ure in there


I think for people (at least this was the case for myself) when voting, you take into consideration inflated defensive numbers for players on terrible teams. There were a lot of guys who had great numbers, but it was because they were on the field 90-100 plays a game. That's not pro bowl material to me. But I guess I can't speak for the other 3 who voted.
Last edited Sep 8, 2008 21:11:54
 
Greg B
offline
Link
 
Ure only saw around 50 plays a game, not to mention he was consistently playing vs offensive Lineman over double his level.

Not to mention with the way I was training him he was only at 43 energy through 3 quarters of the season
Last edited Sep 8, 2008 21:15:41
 
Derek4jc
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Greg Butler
Ure only saw around 50 plays a game, not to mention he was consistently playing vs offensive Lineman over double his level.

Not to mention with the way I was training him he was only at 43 energy through 3 quarters of the season


Ok, So I may have exagerrated on the number of plays he was in. . He still saw his fair share of 60 plus play games though, and he still played on a defense that more often than not was allowing 600 yards against them per game. I just personally couldn't see myself picking anyone to come off a team like than into the pro bowl. I mean, I give him props for ending up with such a high number of tackles, but if the end result of all of those tackles is giving up over 600 yards most games, I'm gonna place my votes for guys who put up numbers on good defenses first and foremost.

That's just me though. He didn't receive any votes, but I don't know, obviously, why the others didn't vote for him. I'm just explaining why I didn't.
 
Greg B
offline
Link
 
Your way of thinking is your way of think so Im cool with that, but I thought the pro bowl was about players have good seasons and not full teams?

Its fine though no biggy, was just curious why my guy didnt get any love.
 
Derek4jc
offline
Link
 
No doubt it is about players who have good seasons. As long as you put those seasons into perspective. Voting on a statline alone would be foolish.

No doubt he had a great statline though.
 
yomanpopo
offline
Link
 
Wow, no love for my QB. 3600 yrds, 358/507 for 70% (highest in the league), 20 TDs. Led the squad to 14-2 record, oh well.

Surprising only 2 of my teams players made it and we are the #2 team in the conference.
 
Derek4jc
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by yomanpopo
Wow, no love for my QB. 3600 yrds, 358/507 for 70% (highest in the league), 20 TDs. Led the squad to 14-2 record, oh well.

Surprising only 2 of my teams players made it and we are the #2 team in the conference.


He did get my vote, but it was his only vote.
 
Staz
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Derek4jc
No doubt it is about players who have good seasons. As long as you put those seasons into perspective. Voting on a statline alone would be foolish.

No doubt he had a great statline though.


Exactly. Just because a player has a good statistical season doesn't mean he's Pro Bowl quality, just means he had to do his job quite often. Not looking at stats, so I can't really back up this argument with anything other than hypothetical information, but think of it like this.

Aaron Rodgers throws for 3,600yds and 25TDs this season. Wins a few games with final drives, leads the Packers to a 12-4 record, winning the division. Most games were competitive, they played well, etc.

John Kitna throws for 4,000yds and 24 TDs. More yards, about same in TDs, but he had to throw because they were down late often. Didn't really win many games. Didn't have any come from behind victories, didn't really impress anybody with anything.

Who would you vote for?


I think that's what Derek is getting at. Good stats are half the equation. Lol at you having only 43 energy for most of the season though. Why?
 
CarpeDeezNuts
offline
Link
 
http://goallineblitz.com/game/full_player_stats.pl?player_id=769008&playoffs=0

Really?

138 tackles, and 128 MISSED tackles? I thought I was missing something and this was a parody of some sort, but the other FS, cookie buchanon, actually has good stats.

 
keith_dude
offline
Link
 
the tomato got screwed!

a level 19 FB with 66 carries for 250.5 yards....

He blocked for a dominant running game! Not my fault my lousy OCs didn't call a FB run.

11 pancakes? Come on!

Last edited Sep 8, 2008 22:37:32
 
Derek4jc
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by CarpeDeezNuts
http://goallineblitz.com/game/full_player_stats.pl?player_id=769008&playoffs=0

Really?

138 tackles, and 128 MISSED tackles? I thought I was missing something and this was a parody of some sort, but the other FS, cookie buchanon, actually has good stats.



The two guys that got picked were the only 2 who got multiple votes. Neither were on my ballot.

Originally posted by keith_dude
the tomato got screwed!

a level 19 FB with 66 carries for 250.5 yards....

He blocked for a dominant running game! Not my fault my lousy OCs didn't call a FB run.

11 pancakes? Come on!



While we had 4 ballots, one left FBs off the ballot, and another only voted for 1 guy. So it might not be a case of him not being deserving, as much as a lack of effort being put into the voting process at that position.
 
jfbueno
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Derek4jc
Originally posted by Greg Butler

Kind of suprised not to see Ure in there


I think for people (at least this was the case for myself) when voting, you take into consideration inflated defensive numbers for players on terrible teams. There were a lot of guys who had great numbers, but it was because they were on the field 90-100 plays a game. That's not pro bowl material to me. But I guess I can't speak for the other 3 who voted.


This would be true for a LB or CB. But it's still hard for a DT, who has 30 energy a game to come up with thos kind of numbers. Just saying.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.