I sold out my 2nd home playoff game with my sideline ticket prices at 3.25 times the expected. I tried to bump them up to 3.3 times expected for the third game and only sold half of my sideline tickets on the first day. I then moved the tickets back down to 3.25 times the expected price for the second day of sales, but the other half of the tickets didn't sell. Any idea why these tickets didn't sell, despite the fact that I sold out the prior game at the same price?
Forum > Discuss GLB Issues With Catch22 > NOT A BUG - CLOSED > 2nd round playoff tickets worth more than 3rd round?
Dragonis
offline
offline
Does opposition fan support, or for that fact, the strength of the opposition come into the equation at all?
Zöe x
Zöe x
tomcollins
offline
offline
Same thing happened to me. I have 10,000 unsold tickets for the sidelines that sold for that price the game before. Could be that everyone loaded up on the other tickets this time and is out of cash or something. That $2M would have been nice, oh well.
Robbnva
offline
offline
you charged to much the 1st time that your fans couldn't afford the next game.
And before you flame me for this bort used this exact statement back in season 2 so not sure why it would not still apply now.
And before you flame me for this bort used this exact statement back in season 2 so not sure why it would not still apply now.
Xiong Yoshi
offline
offline
Wow, talk about having a pretty high price elasticity. Bort must have a pretty negative view on the true economic implications of Sports in general to set them as having a price elasticity so high.
SCACE
offline
offline
Originally posted by Xiong Yoshi
Wow, talk about having a pretty high price elasticity. Bort must have a pretty negative view on the true economic implications of Sports in general to set them as having a price elasticity so high.
He has said specifically that the economic system relies on a set amount of $$$ the fans have to spend as a whole.
If 3.25 was at or near the max for selling out the game, and the prices were raised so that only part of the stadium filled, it probably needed a drop to 3.2 to sell out.
it has also been WIDELY discussed that you probably shouldn't raise your tickets by the same % unless you are sitting on 100/100/100 fan support.
Min-maxing will lead to unsold seats at times -- it is one of the risks for trying to test the highest possible price. At 100/100/100, I know I can sell out at 3.5-times. To me, it isn't worth the risk of not selling seats to try bumping it up, but others are wiling to take the risk and at times they'll get burned.
Wow, talk about having a pretty high price elasticity. Bort must have a pretty negative view on the true economic implications of Sports in general to set them as having a price elasticity so high.
He has said specifically that the economic system relies on a set amount of $$$ the fans have to spend as a whole.
If 3.25 was at or near the max for selling out the game, and the prices were raised so that only part of the stadium filled, it probably needed a drop to 3.2 to sell out.
it has also been WIDELY discussed that you probably shouldn't raise your tickets by the same % unless you are sitting on 100/100/100 fan support.
Min-maxing will lead to unsold seats at times -- it is one of the risks for trying to test the highest possible price. At 100/100/100, I know I can sell out at 3.5-times. To me, it isn't worth the risk of not selling seats to try bumping it up, but others are wiling to take the risk and at times they'll get burned.
Xiong Yoshi
offline
offline
50% change in Quantity Demanded / 1.5% change in Ticket Price = 33.3333 Or incredibly Elastic. Most studies of sporting prices indicate that Prices are actually inelastic or nearly so.. http://books.google.com/books?id=PGRkblShhU8C&pg=PA705&lpg=PA705&dq=price+elasticity+of+NFL+tickets&source=web&ots=EA8Bwnyd6T&sig=RNfQ6O04MP9tBss3n8SYN9Lj-OY&hl=en&sa=X&oi=book_result&resnum=6&ct=result#PPA701,M1 is a 800 Page book that studies this exact issue. The chart of interest is found on page 701. It gives the Elasticity results of a number of studies of various sporting leagues around the world. In short, there is some variation - but 80% of the results had Elasticities of roughly 0.65. In other words, Ticket pricing is usually inelastic.
There are a number of reasons to add elasticity... and infact there are ways to look at GLB teams as all being perfect substitutes of each other (allowing the prices to become quite elastic for an individual team, because the fans can just as easily go watch a different game for cheaper).... So I suppose when I jumped at Bort's personal views of sports - I missed this interpretation. But in general, if you give something a nearly perfectly elastic Price Elasticity - you are saying that people can easily live without it and that there are many substitutes. When you say this about Sports, you are discounting the passions of Fans by a LOT.
There are a number of reasons to add elasticity... and infact there are ways to look at GLB teams as all being perfect substitutes of each other (allowing the prices to become quite elastic for an individual team, because the fans can just as easily go watch a different game for cheaper).... So I suppose when I jumped at Bort's personal views of sports - I missed this interpretation. But in general, if you give something a nearly perfectly elastic Price Elasticity - you are saying that people can easily live without it and that there are many substitutes. When you say this about Sports, you are discounting the passions of Fans by a LOT.
sunder B
offline
offline
Originally posted by Robbnva
you charged to much the 1st time that your fans couldn't afford the next game.
And before you flame me for this bort used this exact statement back in season 2 so not sure why it would not still apply now.
you charged to much the 1st time that your fans couldn't afford the next game.
And before you flame me for this bort used this exact statement back in season 2 so not sure why it would not still apply now.
SCACE
offline
offline
I'm not disagreeing re: price elasticity Xiong...I'm just stating what I've heard from Bort more than once -- there is a maximum amount of disposable income available from your fan base.
And if you are already at/near the maximum, then even a slight move in prices can cause serious issues in ticket sales.
Again, there is a risk/reward there. If you can find the absolute max, you are making the max amount of money per game, but to find it you could risk ticket sales unless on the 2nd day (you do have 2 tries) you lower the tickets to a much more reasonable amount.
Or, you find a near-max and stick with it, knowing that you'll sell out every game at no risk, but understanding that you're probably giving up a bit of money here and there.
And if you are already at/near the maximum, then even a slight move in prices can cause serious issues in ticket sales.
Again, there is a risk/reward there. If you can find the absolute max, you are making the max amount of money per game, but to find it you could risk ticket sales unless on the 2nd day (you do have 2 tries) you lower the tickets to a much more reasonable amount.
Or, you find a near-max and stick with it, knowing that you'll sell out every game at no risk, but understanding that you're probably giving up a bit of money here and there.
Last edited Sep 8, 2008 14:04:33
Xiong Yoshi
offline
offline
Originally posted by SCACE
I'm not disagreeing re: price elasticity Xiong...I'm just stating what I've heard from Bort more than once -- there is a maximum amount of disposable income available from your fan base.
And if you are already at/near the maximum, then even a slight move in prices can cause serious issues in ticket sales.
Again, there is a risk/reward there. If you can find the absolute max, you are making the max amount of money per game, but to find it you could risk ticket sales unless on the 2nd day (you do have 2 tries) you lower the tickets to a much more reasonable amount.
Or, you find a near-max and stick with it, knowing that you'll sell out every game at no risk, but understanding that you're probably giving up a bit of money here and there.
Probably an indication that the fan base is too clone like. If a 1.5% increase will put 50% of the fans out of the picture, there needs to be a LOT more differentiation between what the fans have available to spend. I doubt 50% of the poeple in a real audience bring exactly the same amount to spend to a game.
I'm not disagreeing re: price elasticity Xiong...I'm just stating what I've heard from Bort more than once -- there is a maximum amount of disposable income available from your fan base.
And if you are already at/near the maximum, then even a slight move in prices can cause serious issues in ticket sales.
Again, there is a risk/reward there. If you can find the absolute max, you are making the max amount of money per game, but to find it you could risk ticket sales unless on the 2nd day (you do have 2 tries) you lower the tickets to a much more reasonable amount.
Or, you find a near-max and stick with it, knowing that you'll sell out every game at no risk, but understanding that you're probably giving up a bit of money here and there.
Probably an indication that the fan base is too clone like. If a 1.5% increase will put 50% of the fans out of the picture, there needs to be a LOT more differentiation between what the fans have available to spend. I doubt 50% of the poeple in a real audience bring exactly the same amount to spend to a game.
Jose Bagg
offline
offline
Originally posted by Xiong Yoshi
Originally posted by SCACE
I'm not disagreeing re: price elasticity Xiong...I'm just stating what I've heard from Bort more than once -- there is a maximum amount of disposable income available from your fan base.
And if you are already at/near the maximum, then even a slight move in prices can cause serious issues in ticket sales.
Again, there is a risk/reward there. If you can find the absolute max, you are making the max amount of money per game, but to find it you could risk ticket sales unless on the 2nd day (you do have 2 tries) you lower the tickets to a much more reasonable amount.
Or, you find a near-max and stick with it, knowing that you'll sell out every game at no risk, but understanding that you're probably giving up a bit of money here and there.
Probably an indication that the fan base is too clone like. If a 1.5% increase will put 50% of the fans out of the picture, there needs to be a LOT more differentiation between what the fans have available to spend. I doubt 50% of the poeple in a real audience bring exactly the same amount to spend to a game.
Your missing the point. The fan base only had 10 million dollars in their pockets. They spent almost all of it on the first game. Do what you want with the ticket prices for game 2, the fans are broke because the OP set his game 1 prices so high. The reason the fans bought the tickets for game 1 is because the price is very elastic. why else would they spend all their money on one game.
Originally posted by SCACE
I'm not disagreeing re: price elasticity Xiong...I'm just stating what I've heard from Bort more than once -- there is a maximum amount of disposable income available from your fan base.
And if you are already at/near the maximum, then even a slight move in prices can cause serious issues in ticket sales.
Again, there is a risk/reward there. If you can find the absolute max, you are making the max amount of money per game, but to find it you could risk ticket sales unless on the 2nd day (you do have 2 tries) you lower the tickets to a much more reasonable amount.
Or, you find a near-max and stick with it, knowing that you'll sell out every game at no risk, but understanding that you're probably giving up a bit of money here and there.
Probably an indication that the fan base is too clone like. If a 1.5% increase will put 50% of the fans out of the picture, there needs to be a LOT more differentiation between what the fans have available to spend. I doubt 50% of the poeple in a real audience bring exactly the same amount to spend to a game.
Your missing the point. The fan base only had 10 million dollars in their pockets. They spent almost all of it on the first game. Do what you want with the ticket prices for game 2, the fans are broke because the OP set his game 1 prices so high. The reason the fans bought the tickets for game 1 is because the price is very elastic. why else would they spend all their money on one game.
Xiong Yoshi
offline
offline
Originally posted by Jose Bagg
Originally posted by Xiong Yoshi
Originally posted by SCACE
I'm not disagreeing re: price elasticity Xiong...I'm just stating what I've heard from Bort more than once -- there is a maximum amount of disposable income available from your fan base.
And if you are already at/near the maximum, then even a slight move in prices can cause serious issues in ticket sales.
Again, there is a risk/reward there. If you can find the absolute max, you are making the max amount of money per game, but to find it you could risk ticket sales unless on the 2nd day (you do have 2 tries) you lower the tickets to a much more reasonable amount.
Or, you find a near-max and stick with it, knowing that you'll sell out every game at no risk, but understanding that you're probably giving up a bit of money here and there.
Probably an indication that the fan base is too clone like. If a 1.5% increase will put 50% of the fans out of the picture, there needs to be a LOT more differentiation between what the fans have available to spend. I doubt 50% of the poeple in a real audience bring exactly the same amount to spend to a game.
Your missing the point. The fan base only had 10 million dollars in their pockets. They spent almost all of it on the first game. Do what you want with the ticket prices for game 2, the fans are broke because the OP set his game 1 prices so high. The reason the fans bought the tickets for game 1 is because the price is very elastic. why else would they spend all their money on one game.
Yea, you not only made my point - you exceeded it. Good Job.
I was of the opinion that the fans were each given a certain amount, and that the lack of diversity between those amounts could lead to results such as the OP experienced..... you seem to be indicating that not only do the fans not have any diversity between their pocket money, but that fans all spend out of the exact same pocket.
Originally posted by Xiong Yoshi
Originally posted by SCACE
I'm not disagreeing re: price elasticity Xiong...I'm just stating what I've heard from Bort more than once -- there is a maximum amount of disposable income available from your fan base.
And if you are already at/near the maximum, then even a slight move in prices can cause serious issues in ticket sales.
Again, there is a risk/reward there. If you can find the absolute max, you are making the max amount of money per game, but to find it you could risk ticket sales unless on the 2nd day (you do have 2 tries) you lower the tickets to a much more reasonable amount.
Or, you find a near-max and stick with it, knowing that you'll sell out every game at no risk, but understanding that you're probably giving up a bit of money here and there.
Probably an indication that the fan base is too clone like. If a 1.5% increase will put 50% of the fans out of the picture, there needs to be a LOT more differentiation between what the fans have available to spend. I doubt 50% of the poeple in a real audience bring exactly the same amount to spend to a game.
Your missing the point. The fan base only had 10 million dollars in their pockets. They spent almost all of it on the first game. Do what you want with the ticket prices for game 2, the fans are broke because the OP set his game 1 prices so high. The reason the fans bought the tickets for game 1 is because the price is very elastic. why else would they spend all their money on one game.
Yea, you not only made my point - you exceeded it. Good Job.
I was of the opinion that the fans were each given a certain amount, and that the lack of diversity between those amounts could lead to results such as the OP experienced..... you seem to be indicating that not only do the fans not have any diversity between their pocket money, but that fans all spend out of the exact same pocket.
Cruzi
offline
offline
I lost out on a couple thousand tickets sales because of this. Funny that it didn't happen last offseason, and I was pushing the 3.5x scale then too.
Jose Bagg
offline
offline
Originally posted by Xiong Yoshi
Originally posted by Jose Bagg
Originally posted by Xiong Yoshi
Originally posted by SCACE
I'm not disagreeing re: price elasticity Xiong...I'm just stating what I've heard from Bort more than once -- there is a maximum amount of disposable income available from your fan base.
And if you are already at/near the maximum, then even a slight move in prices can cause serious issues in ticket sales.
Again, there is a risk/reward there. If you can find the absolute max, you are making the max amount of money per game, but to find it you could risk ticket sales unless on the 2nd day (you do have 2 tries) you lower the tickets to a much more reasonable amount.
Or, you find a near-max and stick with it, knowing that you'll sell out every game at no risk, but understanding that you're probably giving up a bit of money here and there.
Probably an indication that the fan base is too clone like. If a 1.5% increase will put 50% of the fans out of the picture, there needs to be a LOT more differentiation between what the fans have available to spend. I doubt 50% of the poeple in a real audience bring exactly the same amount to spend to a game.
Your missing the point. The fan base only had 10 million dollars in their pockets. They spent almost all of it on the first game. Do what you want with the ticket prices for game 2, the fans are broke because the OP set his game 1 prices so high. The reason the fans bought the tickets for game 1 is because the price is very elastic. why else would they spend all their money on one game.
Yea, you not only made my point - you exceeded it. Good Job.
I was of the opinion that the fans were each given a certain amount, and that the lack of diversity between those amounts could lead to results such as the OP experienced..... you seem to be indicating that not only do the fans not have any diversity between their pocket money, but that fans all spend out of the exact same pocket.
That may or may not be true. I imagine it would be difficult to code a fan base where each fan has a bank account. It is easier to take a macro approach and give them a pot of money to spend. I believe there are in fact three pots of money to spend. The rich pot, the medium pot, and the low income pot. But no, I don't think there are individual fans with varying amounts of money to spend, simply because the system in place is easier and a fair approximation.
Originally posted by Jose Bagg
Originally posted by Xiong Yoshi
Originally posted by SCACE
I'm not disagreeing re: price elasticity Xiong...I'm just stating what I've heard from Bort more than once -- there is a maximum amount of disposable income available from your fan base.
And if you are already at/near the maximum, then even a slight move in prices can cause serious issues in ticket sales.
Again, there is a risk/reward there. If you can find the absolute max, you are making the max amount of money per game, but to find it you could risk ticket sales unless on the 2nd day (you do have 2 tries) you lower the tickets to a much more reasonable amount.
Or, you find a near-max and stick with it, knowing that you'll sell out every game at no risk, but understanding that you're probably giving up a bit of money here and there.
Probably an indication that the fan base is too clone like. If a 1.5% increase will put 50% of the fans out of the picture, there needs to be a LOT more differentiation between what the fans have available to spend. I doubt 50% of the poeple in a real audience bring exactly the same amount to spend to a game.
Your missing the point. The fan base only had 10 million dollars in their pockets. They spent almost all of it on the first game. Do what you want with the ticket prices for game 2, the fans are broke because the OP set his game 1 prices so high. The reason the fans bought the tickets for game 1 is because the price is very elastic. why else would they spend all their money on one game.
Yea, you not only made my point - you exceeded it. Good Job.
I was of the opinion that the fans were each given a certain amount, and that the lack of diversity between those amounts could lead to results such as the OP experienced..... you seem to be indicating that not only do the fans not have any diversity between their pocket money, but that fans all spend out of the exact same pocket.
That may or may not be true. I imagine it would be difficult to code a fan base where each fan has a bank account. It is easier to take a macro approach and give them a pot of money to spend. I believe there are in fact three pots of money to spend. The rich pot, the medium pot, and the low income pot. But no, I don't think there are individual fans with varying amounts of money to spend, simply because the system in place is easier and a fair approximation.
What we are talking about is being realistic. The way it is programmed for fans to buy tickets now is about as far from realistic as you can get. Most true football fans I know of would come up with the money somehow if their team was in the playoffs and they went to see them all Season long!!!!!!!!
Last edited Sep 9, 2008 10:24:34
You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.






























