People need to be realistic when choosing their player for top position.
IMHO, how does:
Boo Didley MLB (Sydney Sharks) 176 tackles, 50 missed tackles, 0 sacks, 0 hurries, 3 PD, 0 Int, 0 FFum, 0 Fum Rec, 14 games
Gets a vote but:
LOLB Mr. Taylor (Portland Rain)
101 tackles, 12 missed tackles, 0 sacks, 0 hurry, 15 PD, 4 Int, 8 FFum, 12 TFL, 2 Fum Rec, 16 games
Does not?
There are lot's of things to be taken into consideration besides stats. It's easy to get the most tackles on a bad defense.
Getting the most tackles on one of the best defenses gets WAY more props in my book. I know we only get to choose a punter,
(I made it that way so the teams with the WORST records can choose the better awards. That way there is no bias for MVP, coach of the year etc.)
But when we choose our punter we will make sure to look at film and be very critical. I think we all need to do a good job of that.
IMHO, how does:
Boo Didley MLB (Sydney Sharks) 176 tackles, 50 missed tackles, 0 sacks, 0 hurries, 3 PD, 0 Int, 0 FFum, 0 Fum Rec, 14 games
Gets a vote but:
LOLB Mr. Taylor (Portland Rain)
101 tackles, 12 missed tackles, 0 sacks, 0 hurry, 15 PD, 4 Int, 8 FFum, 12 TFL, 2 Fum Rec, 16 games
Does not?
There are lot's of things to be taken into consideration besides stats. It's easy to get the most tackles on a bad defense.
Getting the most tackles on one of the best defenses gets WAY more props in my book. I know we only get to choose a punter,
(I made it that way so the teams with the WORST records can choose the better awards. That way there is no bias for MVP, coach of the year etc.)
But when we choose our punter we will make sure to look at film and be very critical. I think we all need to do a good job of that.
Last edited Sep 5, 2008 12:03:13