User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > Indiividual-team chemistry - a step in the right direction to stop gutting from the players' end
kretchfoop
offline
Link
 
The problem: Teams that get new owners have players jumping ship before they give the new owners a chance.

Originally posted by Bort
In my experience, gutting has less to do with the owners and more to do with the players on the team. Most often, when an owner announces they are going to sell the team, the players on the teal all shout in unison "release or trade me!" People have some sort of loyalty to ONLY the guy who signed them, and don't want to play for the next owner no matter how good or bad he may be. It has nothing to do with whether he's a newbie or not.

I don't think there's any way to change that mentality, so I think the only solutions are to come up with ways to work with it.


The solution: So basically, you need an incentive system put in place to encourge teams to stay together on the individual player level. Perhaps chemistry should be reworked...Add in an individual-team chemistry for each player as well as the existing chemistry.

When you join a new team, your individual chemistry is at 0. Every day you are with that team it goes up 1.5. Thus, it will take a whole season to go up 60 and a little over one and a half seasons to go up to 100. Of course, your individual chemistry level effects how well you play.

Individual-team chemistry can only go as high as team chemistry (on whatever side of the ball you play on). Thus, if you are on the defense and half of the defense leaves, you will not play as well (teamwork is crucial to individual perfromance, imo). I am thinking a second bar laid over the current chemistry bar for each player - but this can be worked out later.

The logic: Jumping from team to team is common. When you have thousands of teams to choose from, the only thing holding you to a team is a belief that you have a shot at the title (aside from any comeradery or knowing the owner in real life). Lets be honest, the parity is weak, relegation is slow, and the same teams are never in contention to win...leading to more gutting and less parity. An incentive on the player level is the best fix to this problem. This may not be the best solution, but it is a start.

Now, in real life, if you join a new one it will take some time before you can become an effective part of the team. You will need to learn a lot (playbooks, schemes, etc.) and you need to get that chemistry with the other players. For a WR to jump in and immediately have near perfect chemistry with a QB is unlikely. You need to work at it.

Just another long thought. Comments?
Last edited Sep 3, 2008 12:30:10
 
Krunchy
offline
Link
 
I agree that agents in general need to be a little more patient with teams they're on, and if something can be done to encourage teams to stay together then great.

However, I see an ownership stability problem more than anything. And if team X gets sold back to the league and falls into disarray I agree with those agents who want to run to another team. It doesn't seem fair to have an individuals chemistry be affected by something they didn't cause.
 
Tito716
offline
Link
 
I like it.

May nee dto add some stuff about reduced penalties for offseason acquisitions.

May need to increase the chemistry growth to 5? per day. A player picked up on day 10, will finally be at full chemistry in time for the playoffs. Might even help with deadline trades, as a gamebreaker wouldn't be so gamebreaking at 35 chemistry in the playoffs.
 
Intimnasc
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by kretchfoop
The problem: Teams that get new owners have players jumping ship before they give the new owners a chance.

Originally posted by Bort

In my experience, gutting has less to do with the owners and more to do with the players on the team. Most often, when an owner announces they are going to sell the team, the players on the teal all shout in unison "release or trade me!" People have some sort of loyalty to ONLY the guy who signed them, and don't want to play for the next owner no matter how good or bad he may be. It has nothing to do with whether he's a newbie or not.

I don't think there's any way to change that mentality, so I think the only solutions are to come up with ways to work with it.


The solution: So basically, you need an incentive system put in place to encourge teams to stay together on the individual player level. Perhaps chemistry should be reworked...Add in an individual-team chemistry for each player as well as the existing chemistry.

When you join a new team, your individual chemistry is at 0. Every day you are with that team it goes up 1.5. Thus, it will take a whole season to go up 60 and a little over one and a half seasons to go up to 100. Of course, your individual chemistry level effects how well you play.

Individual-team chemistry can only go as high as team chemistry (on whatever side of the ball you play on). Thus, if you are on the defense and half of the defense leaves, you will not play as well (teamwork is crucial to individual perfromance, imo). I am thinking a second bar laid over the current chemistry bar for each player - but this can be worked out later.

The logic: Jumping from team to team is common. When you have thousands of teams to choose from, the only thing holding you to a team is a belief that you have a shot at the title (aside from any comeradery or knowing the owner in real life). Lets be honest, the parity is weak, relegation is slow, and the same teams are never in contention to win...leading to more gutting and less parity. An incentive on the player level is the best fix to this problem. This may not be the best solution, but it is a start.

Now, in real life, if you join a new one it will take some time before you can become an effective part of the team. You will need to learn a lot (playbooks, schemes, etc.) and you need to get that chemistry with the other players. For a WR to jump in and immediately have near perfect chemistry with a QB is unlikely. You need to work at it.

Just another long thought. Comments?


First Kretch quit changing that avatar it makes it hard for me to recognize people. Next it is not only players that abandon a team befoe it is sold back it is also owners that trade as much of the talent as they can and then the remaining players beg for a day 40 contract. I can't blame them considering people have or are already gone before the owner even gives up the team. Then you have the possibility of the new owner being an ass and now you are even afraid to say anything because you'll be eternally benched with no way out. I actually research owners before I sign and am very picky since they currently have too much control after the contract is signed. This again boils down to contracts and the ability of players to opt out. I sign with the person NOT the team.
 
kretchfoop
offline
Link
 
Yes. It is both owners and players that create this problem.

It might not be realistic, but perhaps if you are traded you would only take a small hit to individual-team chemistry. This way, players will have less incentive to just let their contracts run out at day 40 and move along...perhaps encouraging players to work with a new owner for a trade with the team they want to go to. This would mean that owners would be in better shape with their new team. They could get more cash or another player or two. IDK, this would only work out if there was a trading block. Just throwing it out there.
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.