User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Discuss GLB Issues With Catch22 > NOT A BUG - CLOSED > Defensive player's running angles to ball carry, is still an issue.
Page:
 
mogs01gt
offline
Link
 
Example:
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=131268&pbp_id=8352543

Anyone have any ideas? The SS has vision at 47 and the LB has vision at 43. There should be no reason they run behind the goalline to stop the ball carrier.

So would be the issue for this?
Mogs
Last edited Sep 3, 2008 10:18:29
 
andrew7taylor
offline
Link
 
Plus the RB runs through the corner without any broken tackles, and the only time he slows down to zigzag is when there are no people around him! lol
 
mogs01gt
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by andrew7taylor
Plus the RB runs through the corner without any broken tackles, and the only time he slows down to zigzag is when there are no people around him! lol

LOL I didnt notice that. I assume the CB flat out missed him.
 
mogs01gt
offline
Link
 
So there isnt any explanation why the defenders didnt try to stop the runner before the goalline?
 
RAPB
offline
Link
 
The SIM doesn't recognize the goalline as such. So you'll see HBs juking/faking right at the 0.5 yard line instead of making that step. And you'll see defenders running for the "normal" calculated intersection point (= intersection point based on speed, agility and direction of the defender and of the ball carrier + some cushion) - even if that point is deep into the endzone.

It's been pointed out several times and I already made the suggestion to put the "calculated intersection point" at the 0.5 yard mark if it's in the endzone.
 
Koncorde
offline
Link
 
Aye, there needs to be a "cushion" to the pathing logic.

There's a similar issue with passing from the 0 or 0.5, with the WR's not realising they're good, and the QB waiting for them to continue running routes that take them off screen (same with defensive men). Results in a lot of TD's against defences who use soft cover systems.
 
Mightyhalo
offline
Link
 
Looks like the nickel defense got burned.
 
mogs01gt
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Mightyhalo
Looks like the nickel defense got burned.


That has nothing to do with defenders trying to stop the ball carrier behind the goalline. It wasnt a pass. The defenders should be programmed to stop the runner before the goalline, they should never take an angle to the ball carrier that would tackle it behind the goalline.
 
RAPB
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by mogs01gt
...That has nothing to do with defenders trying to stop the ball carrier behind the goalline. It wasnt a pass. The defenders should be programmed to stop the runner before the goalline, they should never take an angle to the ball carrier that would tackle it behind the goalline.


About all that needs to be said. Maybe guys with terrible vision could make that mistake, but not everyone.

I hope it gets adressed soon, since it's been around since the very beginning and has been brought up about every season as a bug / suggestion.

 
sickie8305
offline
Link
 
your D might be in medium coverage so they were in zone coverage...
 
Mightyhalo
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by mogs01gt
Originally posted by Mightyhalo

Looks like the nickel defense got burned.


That has nothing to do with defenders trying to stop the ball carrier behind the goalline. It wasnt a pass. The defenders should be programmed to stop the runner before the goalline, they should never take an angle to the ball carrier that would tackle it behind the goalline.


FS got burned on the play and you expected your TE and SS who had to stay with the TE, to make the play but they were too far gone, had too much field to cover the come across the field to make that play when the RB had the "angle" on them.

Even if they had cut straight across the field it still would have been a TD.
 
RAPB
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Mightyhalo
...Even if they had cut straight across the field it still would have been a TD.


That's not the point. Sure it's that way - for if the intersection point (+ little cushion) is in the endzone, it mostly will end up a TD anyway.

But there are plays another defender forces the ball carrier to cut and/or slow down (might be even a missed tackle). So...

- it matters sometimes
- it's more realistic

Therefore it should be adressed soon i.m.h.o.

______________

b.t.w.: the FS didn't get burned, he was forced to take the worst angle ever - just to maintain speed he didn't need for an open field tackle anyway. But that's another issue not related to the endzone.

 
mogs01gt
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Mightyhalo
Originally posted by mogs01gt

Originally posted by Mightyhalo

Looks like the nickel defense got burned.

That has nothing to do with defenders trying to stop the ball carrier behind the goalline. It wasnt a pass. The defenders should be programmed to stop the runner before the goalline, they should never take an angle to the ball carrier that would tackle it behind the goalline.

FS got burned on the play and you expected your TE and SS who had to stay with the TE, to make the play but they were too far gone, had too much field to cover the come across the field to make that play when the RB had the "angle" on them.
Even if they had cut straight across the field it still would have been a TD.

You are still missing the point. Even if the defenders will miss the tackle, they should still take an angle to the ball carrier that would meet them before the goalline on run plays. They shouldnt be trying to pick a point in the end zone to make the tackle.

Last edited Sep 8, 2008 08:52:04
 
SCACE
offline
Link
 
Above = correct. The defender should be running to the point where the ball carrier will meet the goalline.
 
mogs01gt
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SCACE
Above = correct. The defender should be running to the point where the ball carrier will meet the goalline.

Isnt the goalline a touchdown in this game? Wouldnt the defender need to meet the ball carrier at the .5 yard mark?
Last edited Sep 8, 2008 12:10:30
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.