User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Discuss GLB Issues With Catch22 > NOT A BUG - CLOSED > Make a list: Money plays that need to be taken out of offensive playbooks
xScREaMx
offline
Link
 
ONLY POST IF YOU HAVE PROOF THAT THE PLAY WILL WORK 95% OR UP OF THE TIME AND THAT YOUR PLAYERS WERE EVENLY MATCHED AND THE OPPOSING PLAYER ISN'T BLATANTLY BETTER THEN YOURS.

Sorry about the caps but I wanted to get the point across about how I don't want this thread to be cluttered of replays of a level 20 player completing the same route all day on a CB 10 levels lower then him. Also if you have the player builds then that would be very useful to determine if the plays should be removed as well.

Now onto the list, post plays that are seemingly unstoppable even when two evenly matched CB/WR's face eachother in man coverage. My first addition to the list will be the slot quick slant.

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=83676&pbp_id=8155456

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=83676&pbp_id=8155660

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=83676&pbp_id=8152612

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=83676&pbp_id=8155660

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=83676&pbp_id=8155283

I'm not going to post his build but the WR that got me on the 2 of the plays has substantially less agility and vision then me and that's all that I could see mattering on this play (his build is open). Not sure about the other WR but he's 2 levels lower then Collins so take that however you see it. If you really want me to open my build for me to prove this play is unstoppable then I will.
Last edited Sep 2, 2008 17:47:45
 
otto_g_2k8
offline
Link
 
Can't see the exact builds of the players involved, but the QB has righteous scouting bars and the CB is playing with enough of a cushion that a quick slant is going to work every time. My guess (correct me if I am wrong) is that the CBs tactics are set to "medium" which makes a quick slant one of the easiest plays to complete. In RL football, I have eaten teams alive with that play when the CB plays anything other than an inside out press coverage.
Last edited Sep 2, 2008 18:34:09
 
xScREaMx
offline
Link
 
It's my CB and I never take him off close
 
Malachorn
offline
Link
 
No, no. No need to show me your build... those plays are unstoppable and must be stopped!!!

(I didn't even look at those replays, by the way, as I was so convinced by your passion here).

So... that's more than 95% of the time... what is it exactly? 97% or something? Just curious.
 
5STAR
offline
Link
 
you realize a ROLB or MLB dropping into a zone will stop that play right?
 
Larsonite
offline
Link
 
Some of it is just poor CB play. That last clip he got head faked on the out and hit the slant. ouch. Vision, Confidence or Stamina could easily be the solution.

oh, and yes, dropping a LB in a zone would easily stop that play, in fact, render it useless.

So it's not that 95% of the time that play works, it's that 95% of the time you have the wrong defense. Mix it up a little so the same result from a play can't be used over and over and over and over and over...
 
RAPB
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by 5STAR
you realize a ROLB or MLB dropping into a zone will stop that play right?


...are you sure?

Technically, defending a quick slant needs some support by the LBs (unless the CB plays press coverage and cuts off the inside right from the start - never saw that coverage on GLB so far). But: GLB zone coverage is pretty screwed up - so does a LB dropping into zone really have any effect? What LB shift needed? Will anyone be at least near the path of the TE too?

I actually like to see some defense working properly vs. those plays. Not just a CB lucky enough to make up to the WR after the catch in time and deflect the ball out of the WRs hands.

This issue is really worth discussing i.m.h.o. The answer to slant routes should be zone coverage, but honestly I doubt that zone is doing anything good.

So can anyone please provide an example of a (working or not working) underneath zone coverage)?

 
islander1
offline
Link
 
having 3 players covering a tight end just because it's man to man coverage is the single most retarded defensive implementation in the game.

Hello, Tampa 2 anyone?
 
RMiller517
offline
Link
 
Thread locked by moderator.
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.