User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Discuss GLB Issues With Catch22 > NOT A BUG - CLOSED > Anyone notice that LB shifts in AI aren't working consistently?
BerkeyTerps
offline
Link
 
alright, clearly the AI input works for the situation, see below. this looks to me like a weak side LB shift, which is clearly not an option for my input. i've noticed this sort of thing for other specific inputs i have, that the LB shift sometimes goes the wrong way. has anyone else seen this?

the play: http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=94398&pbp_id=5877592

The test results with the defense AI tester:

Enter Situation
Quarter: 1
Time Remaining: 835
Ball Spot: my 40
Down: 3rd
Yards to go: .5 yards
Score: 0-0

Opponent Formation: Big I formation
Number of Wide Receivers: 2

Matching Input
Input Named: Big I (normal)

Possible Outputs
60% Inside Run (4-3 Cover 1 man): set for no LB shift (stack the box)
20% Right Run (4-3 Cover 1 man): set for strong side LB shift (stack the box)
20% Pass (4-3 Cover 1 man): set for no LB shift (balanced play focus)
 
BerkeyTerps
offline
Link
 
i have several other situations also, where the LB shifts go the completely wrong way, not always but sometimes. strong side is the side with TE if i'm not mistaken right? even in a single back 3 WR set a TE on right of the ROT?
 
cosmoxl
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by BerkeyTerps
i have several other situations also, where the LB shifts go the completely wrong way, not always but sometimes. strong side is the side with TE if i'm not mistaken right? even in a single back 3 WR set a TE on right of the ROT?


yes, strong side is side where TE is. and in this game TE is on right side of OL or left side of defense.
 
BerkeyTerps
offline
Link
 
good what i thought, so why is it shifting weak side then on this specific play, when i have no weak side shift set. and why do i see it in other play situations?
 
BerkeyTerps
offline
Link
 
ne1?
 
Forbin
offline
Link
 
Someone mentioned in another thread that the strong side is actually where the FB lines up in GLB. I didn't really explore that myself...Nor is it particularly helpful considering the FB is lined up directly behind the QB in this formation.


Just thought I'd mention it. I don't know why it'd be relevant, but it may be.
 
BerkeyTerps
offline
Link
 
that could be relevant, but like you said in big I formations, on single back formation, or even 5WR sets wouldn't be much help to decide. thanks buddy.
 
BerkeyTerps
offline
Link
 
maybe a mod has an idea?
 
spindoctor02
offline
Link
 
First off, either your settings are inaccurate, or you incorrectly put them in the original post, since the defense you show in that link is a Cover 2, which isn't any of the options you listed above. Either you messed something up in your AI settings, or the defense called a different play all together.
 
bigpimpin123
offline
Link
 
Strong & Weak side depend on the side of the FB. I'm pretty sure if the FB is on the left on offense it is strong side and on the right it is weak side. Says that on the AI FAQ too.
 
YardRat
offline
Link
 
That's not a Big I, either.
 
Galadan
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by bigpimpin123
Strong & Weak side depend on the side of the FB. I'm pretty sure if the FB is on the left on offense it is strong side and on the right it is weak side. Says that on the AI FAQ too.


This is backwards. When the FB is offset to the side that the TE is on (the right side in GLB) it is a "Strong I" formation. When the FB is offset to the weak side it is a "Weak I" formation.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Formation_(American_football)

also,
Originally posted by YardRat
That's not a Big I, either.


The formation in the OP is a basic I. A "Big I" formation would have 2 TEs and 1 WR.

Last edited Aug 24, 2008 08:58:19
 
BerkeyTerps
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by YardRat
That's not a Big I, either.


this is why, thank you. the true big I formation is 2 TE 1 WR... the play above is just an I formation with 2 WR. thats why the play called is different. its similar to big I but not the same. thanks guys.
 
RMiller517
offline
Link
 
Thread locked by moderator.
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.