User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Page:
 
hookem888
offline
Link
 
All advanced run settings are set to: run (random)
Global run set to: 98 HB/2 FB
Run/Pass % is irrlevant but it was 60/40 (pass/run)
Rusher: Basic settings


FBs got 25% of carries.

How does this work?

I thought if you set this to random it will default to the global settings, and if my global settings dictate that FBs should only get 2% of carries, how does the sim manage to give the FB 10 carries (out of 40 total runs)?

Anyone else have this problem?

Thanks in advance.
Last edited Aug 18, 2008 22:34:15
 
Zoblefu
offline
Link
 
I believe the default settings give the ball to the FB in many short-yardage situations (goal line, 3rd and 1, etc) unless you specifically tell it to do something different in the advanced AI.

I believe if you say 0% FB it will also not use these plays, but because the FB % is greater than 0, those plays are available to select from and it determines those are the best for the short yardage situation.

That's my interpretation. If he was getting carries in other situations then... I dunno
 
hookem888
offline
Link
 
Thanks for the reply. But I don't want the FB to get 0 carries. My intent was to minimize the FB carries to 1-5 plays a game. However, on a high % of my 1st downs, the FB got the ball. Granted they were all up the middle runs, but the fact that I only chose 2% FB runs should mean that if I run the ball 100x, the FB might get 2 carries. I ran the ball 40x...and FBs got 10 of them.

1st down runs by FB:
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=91951&pbp_id=4561033
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=91951&pbp_id=4561635
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=91951&pbp_id=4562463
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=91951&pbp_id=4563818
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=91951&pbp_id=4563892
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=91951&pbp_id=4565066
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=91951&pbp_id=4565168
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=91951&pbp_id=4566286
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=91951&pbp_id=4566366

2nd and 2 run by FB (this one I can understand):
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=91951&pbp_id=4564816

Something isn't right IMO. I've actually done this 3x already, dropping FB % down from 10% to 5%, finally to 2%...each time having alot more FB carries then I expected.
 
Link
 
Check your AI. Select HB for Primary rusher for most of the plays, and Basic for others.. This SHOULD help out a bit..
 
hookem888
offline
Link
 
Yes, I agree that would fix it. But isn't this still a bug? Or is this the intent of the AI?

If certain runs that are randomized are FB ONLY runs, then that was not explained in any training guides, so I'm just trying to get confirmation of how it's supposed to work.

The workaround will work, but lets say I have 10 runs entered in the AI...and I wanted to have a 90/10 split of HB/FB carries. That would mean that I would have to go into each run output and set a runner (so in essence 20 outputs)...which goes against the whole concept of setting the runner as "basic settings" so that it can be handled with 1 global setting.

Again...I'm just looking for confirmation one way or another. I've already remedied my gameplans accordingly, but I think either this is broken or all the explanations are incorrect...so something needs to be updated to reflect the correct workings.
 
Hanz
offline
Link
 
actually same thing happened to me last game

my FB carry is 30% but still seemed like last game my Fb was getting alot more 1st down rushes than in the past.
 
Intimnasc
offline
Link
 
There is a function in the AI and I don't game plan so bear with me as I try to explain this. In the AI if you let the AI help with game planning at all then if it thinks plays aren't working it will change your settings. There is a way to set it to run your game plan only 100% and not deviate. I read this somewhere from Bort only he is m ore clear in his answer than me (go figure huh). I do know he made it clear the AI will take over if lt thinks your plays aren't working.
 
markhehe
offline
Link
 
nah, ive got FB set to 0% and he still gets carries. AI does what it wants
 
Intimnasc
offline
Link
 
OK sorry for the second post went to look at the tactics screen and saw what I needed. It is the set the AI to never deviate and then the box below gives a persentage it can deviate set that to 0 and it should follow your game plan better.
 
hookem888
offline
Link
 
Mine's already at 0 and always has been.

For my next game, I've got my FB carry to 0% this game at the global setting. And the advanced AI set as before with all runs = run(random) and runner = basic settings.

So in theory...my HBs should get all carries.

Now, this still doesn't mean my previous issue still isn't a bug though. Because even if 0% FB runs work as intended, that doesn't mean 2% FB runs should = 25%.

I'll post the results later after my game today.
 
hookem888
offline
Link
 
Update from my game:

Settings were as noted above.

Still getting FB runs and at a fairly high clip. Definite bug (or miscommunication as to how the settings work) since global FB carries were set to 0%.

My thinking is that one of the runs have designated a FB ALWAYS gets the ball.

In the PLAY TYPE drop down there are 5 options to select from:
1) Inside run
2) Outside run
3) Outside run (off-tackle)
4) Oustide run (pitch/sweep)
5) Run (random)

So it would seem that "Inside Run" = FB run ONLY. Unless you pick a HB in the runner drop down.

54 total runs
10 FB runs
All 10 FB runs were on 1st downs

The % from my previous game(s) and this one would lend itself to this as well, as it's always around 20-25% of the runs.

The training guides I've seen posted in the forums, state that if you select basic settings in the runner dropdown, your global settings will dictate who runs if no runner is selected. But apparently something is forcing FBs to always run on a specific run play.

So again, either this is a bug, or it's working as intended, but then the training guides aren't correct...and should be updated to reflect this.

How do we get Bort or another admin to chime in on this for confirmation?


 
Intimnasc
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by hookem888


How do we get Bort or another admin to chime in on this for confirmation?




Have those two gals from your avatar go ask him that'd get me on a plane. heh heh

 
Nixx
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by hookem888
runner = basic settings.


Why not try setting the runner to be the HB? Set the advanced AI to follow your settings exactly.

Yes, maybe there is a bug here, but there also might be a way to work around it.
 
pestface
offline
Link
 
I've also had problems with the FB running outside on specific inside run plays where I left the rusher blank.

For some reason giving the output "inside run" ignores all tactics and runs mostly randomly, and you have to specify the rusher for all plays.
 
hookem888
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Nixx
Originally posted by hookem888

runner = basic settings.


Why not try setting the runner to be the HB? Set the advanced AI to follow your settings exactly.

Yes, maybe there is a bug here, but there also might be a way to work around it.


Again...I know the workaround will work. However, this doesn't mean that this isn't a bug and shouldn't be addressed.

I'm just trying to get confirmation one way or another of how it's supposed to work. If you have to always enter a rusher, then so be it...but the guides need to be updated to not mislead ppl or have verbiage/edits in place in the AI explaining.

It's really not that big a deal, now that I know it's quirky...I really just wanted to bring this to someone's attention so someone can validate it as a bug or working as intended.




 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.