Since many coverage issues have been adressed lately, it might be time for some serious discussion about how coverage should work.
A reasonable balance in the game is needed. CBs shutting down WRs on "close" coverage setting almost all the time are unrealistic i.m.h.o. (that's what season 3 was like). On the other hand, WRs catching the majority of throws even in tight coverage or double coverage are unrealistic too.
So it's time to discuss coverage issues:
- how should receivers get separation?
- how should receivers not based on getting separation (high jumping/catching) get catches too?
- how should coverage work and provide a way to defend both types of receivers?
One idea that came to my mind:
Maybe provide different ways of coverage settings and have each have bonus and penalties?
Right now, there are only 3 Man Coverage Distances:
- close: stick to your man like glue ("problem": you shouldn`t be able to play that without the WR getting open A LOT when facing equal "running" attributes; so that should be only an option to superior CBs)
- medium: stay a couple of yards back so you don't get beat deep (problem: this setting allowes the WR to get open all the time right now and you need to have great agility to deflect the ball even a couple of times - so this setting is not really an reasonable option to defend the pass)
- far: keep about 5 yard cushion between you and your man (a setting for outmatched CBs, just preventing the deep TD pass and giving up everything else)
So maybe have a more precise setting like:
coverage cushion:
5yd
4yd
3yd
2yd
1yd
as close as you can
preferred reaction
bite on every move (the defender will react on every head or body motion the receiver shows, this getting him a great advantage of defending short passes and simple routes)
play it reasonable (the defender will not react on the first head or body motion the receiver shows, this preventing him more of getting faked and getting beaten deep afterwards)
play it safe (the defender will let the receiver make his turn first and follow him after he's sure that it isn't a fake)
in-game adjustment (this requires remembering how the CB played the specific receiver in the game before)
play it safe (the defender will adjust his coverage settings as soon as he's beaten once)
don't mind occasionally problems (the defender will stick to his settings and adjust as he happens to get beaten a couple of times; he will get back to the original settings as he's giving up catches)
stick to the plan (the defender will very slowly adjust to getting beaten)
Such settings would also provide a better way of gameplanning and give the agents of defenders much more to do.
Any ideas welcome!
A reasonable balance in the game is needed. CBs shutting down WRs on "close" coverage setting almost all the time are unrealistic i.m.h.o. (that's what season 3 was like). On the other hand, WRs catching the majority of throws even in tight coverage or double coverage are unrealistic too.
So it's time to discuss coverage issues:
- how should receivers get separation?
- how should receivers not based on getting separation (high jumping/catching) get catches too?
- how should coverage work and provide a way to defend both types of receivers?
One idea that came to my mind:
Maybe provide different ways of coverage settings and have each have bonus and penalties?
Right now, there are only 3 Man Coverage Distances:
- close: stick to your man like glue ("problem": you shouldn`t be able to play that without the WR getting open A LOT when facing equal "running" attributes; so that should be only an option to superior CBs)
- medium: stay a couple of yards back so you don't get beat deep (problem: this setting allowes the WR to get open all the time right now and you need to have great agility to deflect the ball even a couple of times - so this setting is not really an reasonable option to defend the pass)
- far: keep about 5 yard cushion between you and your man (a setting for outmatched CBs, just preventing the deep TD pass and giving up everything else)
So maybe have a more precise setting like:
coverage cushion:
5yd
4yd
3yd
2yd
1yd
as close as you can
preferred reaction
bite on every move (the defender will react on every head or body motion the receiver shows, this getting him a great advantage of defending short passes and simple routes)
play it reasonable (the defender will not react on the first head or body motion the receiver shows, this preventing him more of getting faked and getting beaten deep afterwards)
play it safe (the defender will let the receiver make his turn first and follow him after he's sure that it isn't a fake)
in-game adjustment (this requires remembering how the CB played the specific receiver in the game before)
play it safe (the defender will adjust his coverage settings as soon as he's beaten once)
don't mind occasionally problems (the defender will stick to his settings and adjust as he happens to get beaten a couple of times; he will get back to the original settings as he's giving up catches)
stick to the plan (the defender will very slowly adjust to getting beaten)
Such settings would also provide a better way of gameplanning and give the agents of defenders much more to do.
Any ideas welcome!






























