Honestly, I don't like this idea and hate all these tournaments that everyone keeps trying to create.
If done as LT56 stated at the end of the seaosn and it was a tournament of champions for some kind of bragging rights, then I could see someone really being interested.
As is, does anyone ever take scrimmages or games that don't count against their record seriously???
As far as you just picking a few teams at random that are willing to do it. Go for it....
If you want to create a dilusional result basing it off any 4 teams that will agree to play, then you will have a very distorted tournament and the winner won't have won anything as they won't have faced the best of each league.
I tell ya, between the ten thousand tournaments being created and some of the lame scrimmages, I wish to God Bort would get a handle on this stuff, but he won't because he makes money off of it.