User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
vlyrock
offline
Link
 
I understand running backwards to "cut off" an opponent...but the play linked below has happened several times.

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=91782&pbp_id=3805217

In it, the WR catches it over the middle. The FS and CB are in a position where if they run straight at him they MIGHT get him. Instead, they run backwards (away from him) allowing him to run untouched into the endzone.

Seems this logic should be tweaked when you're standing in your own end zone.
 
vlyrock
offline
Link
 
And, before the "they wouldn't have made the tackle anyways" responses show up -- I understand that. But in terms of logic, realism and what you expect to see in a football game -- I'm pointing out that this isn't something I'd expect to see.
 
Rezlov
offline
Link
 
Could have very well made that tackle. Looks like the LB missed coverage or something as well.
 
dfitzo53
offline
Link
 
That's kind of funny, because when you want them to take a cutoff angle instead of running straight for the ball, they do it the wrong way.

Sigh. Everybody says coding pathing is hard, but I don't understand why. It seems like basic vector math. (I'm not saying it's easy, I'm just saying I don't understand what makes it hard.)
 
SCACE
offline
Link
 
there needs to be better logic around the endzone, agreed 100%, but I doubt either make that tackle
 
rivergato
offline
Link
 
That would be hard to code with current x/y coordinates methinks...
 
Jose Bagg
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by rivergato
That would be hard to code with current x/y coordinates methinks...


Vector math doesn't rely on X,Y coords. This type of problem would be very cumbersome with X,Y coords.
 
rivergato
offline
Link
 
The visual output is X/Y...The reaction is based off that visual output.
 
SCACE
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by rivergato
The visual output is X/Y...The reaction is based off that visual output.


I'm no math/programming whiz, but I don't think anything is based off of the visual output...the visual output is just there to give you an idea of what happened, so it should not affect what can be coded into the game.
 
rivergato
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by vlyrock
I understand running backwards to "cut off" an opponent...but the play linked below has happened several times.

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=91782&pbp_id=3805217

In it, the WR catches it over the middle. The FS and CB are in a position where if they run straight at him they MIGHT get him. Instead, they run backwards (away from him) allowing him to run untouched into the endzone.

Seems this logic should be tweaked when you're standing in your own end zone.


That was what I meant by reaction based off of...His reaction, what we see.
Last edited Aug 15, 2008 17:12:59
 
RAPB
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SCACE
there needs to be better logic around the endzone, agreed 100%...


The defenders head for a intersection point the calculate based on their own speed and agility and based on the movement of the ball carrier. As they are rather far away, they give themselfes a few extra yards to not get faked out or something. Of course, that's a plain stupid behavior if it comes to defending the endzone.

I suggested a very simple solution a couple of times before:

If the calculated intersection point is in the endzone - just put it on the 0.5 yard line.

So the defender will "gamble" on a chance to stop the ball carrier at the latest possible point. Most of the time you'll see him arrive too late. But a very few times you'd see him getting lucky for the ball carrier adjusts his route towards the defender...

 
GenoBong
offline
Link
 
Looks to me like they figured the LB/SS had the better angle and were accounting for a certain cut, or something.

But I absolutely agree, defensive AI needs to consider things like where the goalline is, where the first down marker is (on 3rd, and particularly, 4th downs) and compensate for this.

Defenses should be "thinking" differently in the red zone, and on 3rd/4th downs.
 
RMiller517
offline
Link
 
Thread locked by moderator.
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.