User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Buzzkill
offline
Link
 
My team is in USA A8 and we have 2 situations which seem wrong. First, we have 3 teams at the top of the East at 5-1. This is the breakdown of their sub-ranking(note that the team with more losses is ranked higher)...

NOLA: 1-1-0
Vermont: 1-0-0
Rhode Island: 0-1-0

They are ranked in that order, regardless of the fact that Vermont not only beat NOLA already, but NOLA also has a loss and Vermont doesnt.

Then we have 6 teams below them at 4-2 with a sub-ranking as follows(again note that the team with more losses is ranked higher)....

Reamstown: 2-2-0
Nashville: 2-1-0
Crimson: 1-0-0
Manhattan: 1-1-0
New York: 1-2-0
Destin: 0-1-0

We are ranked in this order. Is it for some reason taking total number of results(winds+losses+ties) as the first deciding factor, and if so, shouldn't it place a team with more losses below a team with fewer losses if the wins are tied?

The only possibility i can see other than it being bugged, is that because the number of results isnt equal in all cases, it bypasses the sub-ranking and moves to points scored, but i didnt think that was the case.

Anyone who actually knows how the tiebreaker breaks down care to comment on this and confirm/disprove this as a bug?
 
bigpimpin123
offline
Link
 
Looks weird, but when they all finish playing each other everything will be fine. The standings will probably be different a couple days from now anyways.
 
Buzzkill
offline
Link
 
Yeah im sure its going to change before the end of the season, but it would be really nice to know now that its either a bug, or learn exactly how the tiebreakers work at this point in a season.
 
uncle_wilf
offline
Link
 
I know that these three factors appear in the tie-breaks in this order, but whether any others are a factor, I know not.

Games won in matches between teams
Most points scored
Fewest points conceded
 
sunder B
offline
Link
 
Pretty sure head to head is thrown out if more than 2 teams are tied and it moves right to next tiebreaker which is points scored.
 
Buzzkill
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by sunder B
Pretty sure head to head is thrown out if more than 2 teams are tied and it moves right to next tiebreaker which is points scored.


Nope....ive only seen it work at the end of the season, which is why im unsure what the deal is here....but when more than 2 teams are tied i am 99.9999% positive it takes all the tied teams, and gives them sub-rankings, and only moves to points scored if there isnt a definitive winner in the sub-rankings. That however is at the end of the regular season when everyone has played everyone else, so it may not be how it is done mid-season, why is why im not sure if its a bug, or if its done differently mid-season and would like to know.
 
sunder B
offline
Link
 
why would there be different standards for mid season and end season? It should be consistant, shouldn't it?
 
BWN
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by uncle_wilf
I know that these three factors appear in the tie-breaks in this order, but whether any others are a factor, I know not.

Games won in matches between teams
Most points scored
Fewest points conceded


It looks like that's the case. I think it's just taking H2H wins (not overall H2H record), then moving on to the next tiebreakers.
 
Buzzkill
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by sunder B
why would there be different standards for mid season and end season? It should be consistant, shouldn't it?


I think possibly because all teams dont have an equal number of results(wins+losses+ties), it doesnt do it the same way as the end of the season where everyone is 100% certain to have the same number of results. And yes, i assumed it was consistent, but it doesnt look to be so.
 
Buzzkill
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by IceTBC
You only need to worry about it for the playoffs but here is an answer for ties for the playoffs.

From Game Mechanics FAQ http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=81987

"5. How do playoffs work? How do relegations/promotions work?
-----a. You must be in the top 8 of your conference to make the playoffs. And it is single elimination. The top teams in each conference, through playoff, get promoted to the next league (there are 2 conferences in a league and 16 teams per conference)
-----b. The bottom 2 teams in each conference drop down to the lower league


5(add). How are ties broken in the standing?
-----a. If there are only 2 teams, it's just based upon the head-to-head matchup
-----b. If there are more than 2 teams, then it's based upon these factor in this order:
1. # of head-to-head wins against the other teams with the same record
2. # of points scored
3. # of points allowed."



Just what i was looking for...guess its not a bug, and it only accounts for wins...not losses or ties.
 
RMiller517
offline
Link
 
Thread locked by moderator.
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.