User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Page:
 
browns4life
offline
Link
 
Players should NOT be able to circumvent the spirit of the game by putting in their best pass rushing DE in the LDE slot.
To do so they are able to avoid the "blind side ability" of LOT's "Protect" Special Ability and get more sacks than they really should.

Example in a pro league:
Team: http://goallineblitz.com/game/team.pl?team_id=275
player: http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=54068

He has 14 sacks..thats BS

Example #2:
Team: http://goallineblitz.com/game/team.pl?team_id=299
Player: http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=44100

He has 11 sacks..more BS from the LDE slot

Team: http://goallineblitz.com/game/team.pl?team_id=618
Player: http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=89935

He has 10 sacks and they have come from both LDE and RDE position, but this team has a history of abusing pass rushing from the LDE slot. They did it all of last year with this guy in the LDE slot (now they slyly moved him into RDE)
Player: http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=52852


I'm sure I'm going to get bashed by lots of people here saying that this isn't a bug and that its a "matchup" issue. That we SHOULD be able to theoretically run better against a team with their pass rusher in that spot. Unfortunately we all know that doesn't happen.

Bottom line is that you will see ALOT of the best teams play their best pass rushing DE at the LDE spot. The main logic here MUST be to avoid the best passing blocking OT which is OBVIOUSLY the LOT because only an OT in the LOT slot is by definition allowed to make use of the "Protect" Special Ability.

I would very much like Bort to respond to this if possible, but I realize he is very busy.

Other posters. I'd appreciate if you didn't post unless you have experience with THIS very issue. i.e. you are an OT or a DE or a GM/OC who deals with scouting these issues on a game to game basis.

Thank you,
 
Link
 
So you want to take away teams abilities to choose there own lineup?

How do you know all the quarterbacks aren't left handed in which the DE's would lineup on the left side?

 
Krunchy
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by browns4life

Bottom line is that you will see ALOT of the best teams play their best pass rushing DE at the LDE spot. The main logic here MUST be to avoid the best passing blocking OT which is OBVIOUSLY the LOT because only an OT in the LOT slot is by definition allowed to make use of the "Protect" Special Ability.


This is the best part of your post, and I agree that in its current form its an exploit to put pass rushers at the LDE spot. Not that teams should be prevented from doing this, but the Protect special ability should be changed to work on both sides.
 
Tothehouse
offline
Link
 
Please find my responses below your original posting that I quoted

Originally posted by browns4life


Example in a pro league:
Team: http://goallineblitz.com/game/team.pl?team_id=275
player: http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=54068

He has 15 sacks on the SEASON, 11 CAME IN A BLOWOUT. You call this OP'ed?

He has 14 sacks..thats BS. 14 sacks is BS? What are you smoking?

Example #2:
Team: http://goallineblitz.com/game/team.pl?team_id=299
Player: http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=44100

This guy has spread out his sacks all year. In fact, he had his highest sack total in on of the closest games his team had all year.

He has 11 sacks..more BS from the LDE slot. Are you an idiot? So because you are in the LDE spot you shouldnt get sacks? Tell that to Michael Strahan buddy.

Team: http://goallineblitz.com/game/team.pl?team_id=618
Player: http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=89935

He has 10 sacks and they have come from both LDE and RDE position, but this team has a history of abusing pass rushing from the LDE slot. They did it all of last year with this guy in the LDE slot (now they slyly moved him into RDE)
Player: http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=52852


I'm sure I'm going to get bashed by lots of people here saying that this isn't a bug and that its a "matchup" issue. That we SHOULD be able to theoretically run better against a team with their pass rusher in that spot. Unfortunately we all know that doesn't happen.

Bottom line is that you will see ALOT of the best teams play their best pass rushing DE at the LDE spot. The main logic here MUST be to avoid the best passing blocking OT which is OBVIOUSLY the LOT because only an OT in the LOT slot is by definition allowed to make use of the "Protect" Special Ability.

I would very much like Bort to respond to this if possible, but I realize he is very busy.

Other posters. I'd appreciate if you didn't post unless you have experience with THIS very issue. i.e. you are an OT or a DE or a GM/OC who deals with scouting these issues on a game to game basis.

Thank you,


If these are the best examples you have, you are a tool. I hate to say it. Are you being serious? This has to be a joke.

 
PackMan97
offline
Link
 
Maybe the answer to that is to tone down "Protect" a bit and make it work for both sides of the line?

That said, I don't know how the sim code works, but a "blind side" (LOT/RDE) hit on the QB should...
a) result in more sacks than hurries
b) cause more fumbles
c) drop morale more
d) increase chance of injury (when they get in the sim)
...so there is reason to want to protect the blind side with your best OT (or using Protect).

In addition a rush from the other side (ROT/LDE) should...
a) cause more hurries than sacks
b) give the QB a boost to side step
c) less chance of fumble/injury

I don't know how the sim works, but if a "sack" is a "sack" then I say change PROTECT, however if there is a big difference (as described above) between a left (blind) side sack and a right side then I would call this "as designed". Teams are more willing to give up a right side sack because they are less dangerous.
Last edited Aug 13, 2008 09:04:58
 
Urrymonster
offline
Link
 
I have to agree with the OP. The RE spot just does not seem to work right, I had my best pass rusher there for 2 seasons and the moment I switch him to LE he starts making plays. Whether it is pathing or dominant LTs something is a little off with the position.

No need to be an idiot TTH, but a lot of teams follow suit simply because their dominant DE is so much more effective from the LE. Because you have not tried/seen it does not mean the situation is not happening.
 
browns4life
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Urrymonster
I have to agree with the OP. The RE spot just does not seem to work right, I had my best pass rusher there for 2 seasons and the moment I switch him to LE he starts making plays. Whether it is pathing or dominant LTs something is a little off with the position.

No need to be an idiot TTH, but a lot of teams follow suit simply because their dominant DE is so much more effective from the LE. Because you have not tried/seen it does not mean the situation is not happening.



Thank you and everyone else who has half a brain to use logic and experience to try to debate this issue..

To the idiot who called me a tool:
I wasn't gonna spend all day long to find the WORSE LDE abusers because I don't need to. When a team has 15 sacks from the LDE spot and 2 from the RDE spot it is FREAKIN OBVIOUS


Maybe someday this issue will be addressed and/or clarified.

thanks for reading,
 
Tothehouse
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Urrymonster
I have to agree with the OP. The RE spot just does not seem to work right, I had my best pass rusher there for 2 seasons and the moment I switch him to LE he starts making plays. Whether it is pathing or dominant LTs something is a little off with the position.

No need to be an idiot TTH, but a lot of teams follow suit simply because their dominant DE is so much more effective from the LE. Because you have not tried/seen it does not mean the situation is not happening.



I understand that it happens. To browns4life. The guy with 15 sacks had 11 in a game they won 100 something to 7. That guy would have gotten sacks whichever spot he was in. Have you seen that players build? Do you know which side hes better suited for? I would guess not. The guy has gotten 4 sacks in games other than the blow out. Tell me how that is overpowered?

You like at the big numbers but dont look at the specifics. If that guy has 5-6 sacks every game against equal or higher level competition, you would have a base to stand on. Right now you do not.

Thanks for reading.
 
Tothehouse
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Urrymonster
I have to agree with the OP. The RE spot just does not seem to work right, I had my best pass rusher there for 2 seasons and the moment I switch him to LE he starts making plays. Whether it is pathing or dominant LTs something is a little off with the position.

No need to be an idiot TTH, but a lot of teams follow suit simply because their dominant DE is so much more effective from the LE. Because you have not tried/seen it does not mean the situation is not happening.


Check out Loch Ness. Our LDE has gotten maybe 1 or 2 sacks. Our starting RDE has 10 sacks and leads the conference. If you built a RDE correctly, he can rush against properly built LOT's.

 
daysend
offline
Link
 
The OP is a Browns fan, no wonder he's not used to seeing players get to the QB.
 
Joebarber
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by browns4life
Originally posted by Urrymonster

I have to agree with the OP. The RE spot just does not seem to work right, I had my best pass rusher there for 2 seasons and the moment I switch him to LE he starts making plays. Whether it is pathing or dominant LTs something is a little off with the position.

No need to be an idiot TTH, but a lot of teams follow suit simply because their dominant DE is so much more effective from the LE. Because you have not tried/seen it does not mean the situation is not happening.



Thank you and everyone else who has half a brain to use logic and experience to try to debate this issue..

To the idiot who called me a tool:
I wasn't gonna spend all day long to find the WORSE LDE abusers because I don't need to. When a team has 15 sacks from the LDE spot and 2 from the RDE spot it is FREAKIN OBVIOUS


Maybe someday this issue will be addressed and/or clarified.

thanks for reading,


Let's try and bring some facts into this situation. Like how about last season that DE was in AAA, this season he is in Pro. Competition improved thus less sacks.

Oh and by the way he had another sack today at RDE.

You are still a joke


 
Sigmaforce
offline
Link
 
On my team level 13 RDE has 4 sacks (and the RDE is more focused on containment than pass rush SAs to boot), level 18 LDE has 0, go figure. Neither are crappy builds.

A lot of inflated stats are more a product of bad o-line then good d-line, imo. Doesn't help that a lot of people put their 'speedy' o-linemen there to help out with pulling and general run blocking. Get your ROT to put a few points into pass blocking if teams are that worried about it. I do agree that protect should perhaps be nerfed somewhat but allowed to be used by the ROT, though.
 
Tothehouse
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Joebarber
Originally posted by browns4life

Originally posted by Urrymonster


I have to agree with the OP. The RE spot just does not seem to work right, I had my best pass rusher there for 2 seasons and the moment I switch him to LE he starts making plays. Whether it is pathing or dominant LTs something is a little off with the position.

No need to be an idiot TTH, but a lot of teams follow suit simply because their dominant DE is so much more effective from the LE. Because you have not tried/seen it does not mean the situation is not happening.



Thank you and everyone else who has half a brain to use logic and experience to try to debate this issue..

To the idiot who called me a tool:
I wasn't gonna spend all day long to find the WORSE LDE abusers because I don't need to. When a team has 15 sacks from the LDE spot and 2 from the RDE spot it is FREAKIN OBVIOUS


Maybe someday this issue will be addressed and/or clarified.

thanks for reading,


Let's try and bring some facts into this situation. Like how about last season that DE was in AAA, this season he is in Pro. Competition improved thus less sacks.

Oh and by the way he had another sack today at RDE.

You are still a joke




Thank god Im not the only guy who thinks the OP is tooling out over nothing.
 
RIP Al Davis
offline
Link
 
NTs generally have to go up against the RG and C instead of just the LG making it much harder to rack up stats. In fact, I'd say it's twice as hard for a DT who's an NT than a DE who's a RDE. I'd rather be a DT than NT, but my owner adamently wants me at NT. What can be done about that?
 
SCACE
offline
Link
 
If the OP had bothered to look at the game log, he's realize 13 of the 15 sacks came in two games vs. gutted opponents.

That means he has achieved a whopping 2 sacks in his 4 real games.

EPIC FAIL OP....EPIC
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.