User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Oceania AAA Leagues > Oceania AAA #1 > O-AAA #1 GLB Coaches Poll
Page:
 
midlineveer
offline
Link
 
I've had this Ideal for a few seasons and I am ready to give it a shot. Understand, my time is limited so I will do the best I can with what I have. The Beauty of this type of ranking system is you guys pretty much do the work for me. I have never been a fan of unbiased rankings (yea right) or stat polls. If you have ever coached you realize stats can be manipulated according to game planning and what a coach wants to show and what he does not. I personally favor a strength of schedule pole but I do not have the time for that.


The rules:
1- Only owners and GM's may vote
2- You may not vote for your own team.
3- You may only vote for teams in your in conference.
4- You rank your top ***** 3 *****.
5- You send your votes in to me by 04: AM Central US time (early morning after the game).
6- You must identify your team and position on the ballot PM. (Just like the one jdros13 just sent)
7- Please add the conference you are in to the subject line of your PM, Example - "Coaches Poll week 4 (Zeta or Alpha)”, this will be a big help. (If you already PMed me don't worry about it).

I will tally the votes up and post the top 5 on the off day or the morning of game day, we have to see how it goes.

How it works:
1- A 1st place vote is worth 3 points, a 2nd is worth 2, a 3rd is worth 1.
2- I add up all the points and rank a top 5.
3- If less than 5 teams or voted for I go off the league rankings.
4- I will have a top five per conference. I want the men who coach against each other to vote. One out of conference game a season is not enough to make an accurate evaluation

What is the result?
An official coach’s top 5 voted on by you. No super over calculated time consuming, engineers dream computer poll. No unbiased sports writer who never strapped on the pads poll. This is a poll voted on by the men doing all the work and the ones I feel really know the competition in the league, the guys who are actually watching game tape.

I will try to break down the up and coming big games for the teams in or close to Top 5.

Please let me know if this is worth my time.

Thanks

Mid

I still do not like any of you.




Last edited Aug 8, 2008 21:04:04
 
lawdawg95
offline
Link
 
Is this for the Top 5 in AAA #1 overall or are we going to break it down by conferences?
 
jdros13
offline
Link
 
great idea.
 
midlineveer
offline
Link
 
I will have a top five per conference. I want the men who coach against each other to vote. One out of conference game a season is not enough to make an accurate evaluation

Edited on how it works #3
 
jdros13
offline
Link
 
I definitely hope that 100% of the teams get involved in this....and thanks to mid for getting the ball rolling.
 
Avondell
offline
Link
 
k
 
Carpy
offline
Link
 
I'm in
 
MrMoose
offline
Link
 
I'm down. We should restrict this to one vote per team so that you don't have teams with 5 or 6 GMs skewing results.
 
Bad-Company
offline
Link
 
as a non Gm or owner type i just have to say, Yawn.
 
shutd0wn
offline
Link
 
BDC represents.

 
lawdawg95
offline
Link
 
Last edited Aug 8, 2008 20:42:21
 
midlineveer
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by MrMoose
I'm down. We should restrict this to one vote per team so that you don't have teams with 5 or 6 GMs skewing results.


Thus the no vote for your own team clause.

If a guy is putting in the work I think he deserves a vote.
 
MrMoose
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by midlineveer
Originally posted by MrMoose

I'm down. We should restrict this to one vote per team so that you don't have teams with 5 or 6 GMs skewing results.


Thus the no vote for your own team clause.

If a guy is putting in the work I think he deserves a vote.


Yeah, but lets say each one of Samoa's GMs voted. Lets say we all voted for So Cal. Then, lets say Avondell voted. He and his one GM vote for Sth Queensland. So Cal would win simply because there are more Samoans than Avondell guys. Also means Samoa would be ranked lower because we had more guys voting. Whereas, a single vote means every team's vote is worth the same -- a net value of 6 points.

I'd say let whatever vote for a team goes in first be the one that counts, and let the teams themselves figure out how to handle that vote. Alternatively, put some sort of cap on total amount of votes from a team, such as 3. If we implement a one-vote rule, it is something that team leadership (and even the rest of the team) can and should discuss before sending in their vote.

However, that probably makes it way too hard on you. I'm probably overthinking the hell out of this, too.
Last edited Aug 8, 2008 21:14:56
 
midlineveer
offline
Link
 
You may have a point but this week I will follow the guidelines I have already set. If it becomes a cluster frock I may look at limiting the votes to 3, owner or HC, OC & DC.
 
MrMoose
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by midlineveer
You may have a point but this week I will follow the guidelines I have already set. If it becomes a cluster frock I may look at limiting the votes to 3, owner or HC, OC & DC.


Yeah, we gotta see how it goes.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.