User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Discuss GLB Issues With Catch22 > NOT A BUG - CLOSED > Steroid RBs… Freak build, BUG or working as intended?
Page:
 
Tracker
offline
Link
 
Ok so DEs were nerfed because they had crazy comic book type numbers. I think they were dialed back a bit too much but that is not what I wanted to talk about. The “reason” they were nerfed was to make them “more realistic.” That is cool I like and can appreciate the intention there.

Along those lines, let’s look at another position. ..RB.
Is it realistic for a HB to bowl over tacklers and hardly even be slowed down that have 60+ strength and 50+ tackling on a regular basis? Is it realistic to have amassed 902.5 yards (7.1 average - 225 Y/G), have 103 broken tackles and 14 rushing TDs in 4 games?

Maybe it is just me but that strikes me as a tad improbable. There are solid backs in the NFL that don’t see those kinds of numbers in a full year let alone in 4 games.

Keep in mind these numbers are not inflated going up against total mismatched teams, these are against good and equally matched opponents.

I do have a player in mind that I took these numbers from but I am not trying to pee in anybody’s cheerios and this is not a sour grapes issue. I just think if there is some freak build out there that is tipping the scale of balance in an unfair way, what is good for the goose is good for the gander.

Bort, if you want a link to examine this phenomenon please PM me and I will provide it. I am not going to publicly single anybody out until I know if this is actually a flaw in the game or not.
 
j10er
offline
Link
 
What?? Tease.
 
DAKING
offline
Link
 
games
3
attempts
110
yards
905.5
yards a game
301.8
average a carry
8.2
TDs
22
broken tackles
32

3 games and tomorrow we play a gutted team
 
DAKING
offline
Link
 
Sonny WIlliams and he is sharing carries with Chilla Thighs
 
Ken1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by DAKING
Sonny WIlliams and he is sharing carries with Chilla Thighs


And how many 60 strength, 50 tackling guys did he break the tackles of? Probably none, as 50 tackling is pretty damn rare.

Also, DLinemen are often still engaged with a blocker when trying to tackle.
 
panther17
offline
Link
 
I'm guessing maybe people should of invested in tackling.
Some teams are giving up less the 100 - 16 yards a game and only have 6 missed tackles in 3 games.

So I would guess, invest in tackling would be the answer your going to get.

Team is giving up 16 yards a game rushing.
http://goallineblitz.com/game/team_stats.pl?league_id=7&conference_id=0&stat=rushing&sort=rushing_yards_allowed/games&playoffs=0

2 teams with 6 missed tackles in 3 games.
http://goallineblitz.com/game/team_stats.pl?league_id=7&conference_id=0&stat=defense&sort=missed_tackles&playoffs=0

Last edited Aug 8, 2008 15:31:02
 
SoCalWhoDat
offline
Link
 
After being tackled consistently for 2 seasons straight by CBs and Safeties set on wrap-up or LBs with 70 speed, it's rather nice for the field to be level for the backs with high strength and carrying.
 
Enkidu98
offline
Link
 
So.. for your first link Panther, I looked at the teams played...

http://goallineblitz.com/game/team.pl?team_id=225
http://goallineblitz.com/game/team.pl?team_id=200
http://goallineblitz.com/game/team.pl?team_id=203

They played only one team that would be considered competitive. They did fairly well against the competitive back, but that can be caused by things other than good tackling etc.

On the whole, RB's are a little out of whack. And what needs to change to stop them is a drastic build change for players that is not accomplishable quickly and this is a big problem for the largest majority of the players who have been building now for 3 or 4 seasons.

If this were truly a beta test game, respecs would be an option. Since people are paying (sometimes significant cash) to play, I don't think it really should be considered a Beta game. So if Bort is going to make season over season changes, he should likely consider respec options for the playerbase.

This would have the added advantage of allowing him to engage some people in more extensive test builds AND it also helps normalise the game so that he can see how builds will play out when everyone is building towards the equilibrium as opposed to people building to the extremes, then people shifting to catch that extreme, then a new extreme being introduced, etc.

 
grooveskipinc
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Enkidu98
So.. for your first link Panther, I looked at the teams played...

http://goallineblitz.com/game/team.pl?team_id=225
http://goallineblitz.com/game/team.pl?team_id=200
http://goallineblitz.com/game/team.pl?team_id=203

They played only one team that would be considered competitive. They did fairly well against the competitive back, but that can be caused by things other than good tackling etc.

On the whole, RB's are a little out of whack. And what needs to change to stop them is a drastic build change for players that is not accomplishable quickly and this is a big problem for the largest majority of the players who have been building now for 3 or 4 seasons.

If this were truly a beta test game, respecs would be an option. Since people are paying (sometimes significant cash) to play, I don't think it really should be considered a Beta game. So if Bort is going to make season over season changes, he should likely consider respec options for the playerbase.

This would have the added advantage of allowing him to engage some people in more extensive test builds AND it also helps normalise the game so that he can see how builds will play out when everyone is building towards the equilibrium as opposed to people building to the extremes, then people shifting to catch that extreme, then a new extreme being introduced, etc.



This post was much too short to be a true Enkidu post...
 
Ken1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Enkidu98
So.. for your first link Panther, I looked at the teams played...

http://goallineblitz.com/game/team.pl?team_id=225
http://goallineblitz.com/game/team.pl?team_id=200
http://goallineblitz.com/game/team.pl?team_id=203

They played only one team that would be considered competitive. They did fairly well against the competitive back, but that can be caused by things other than good tackling etc.

On the whole, RB's are a little out of whack. And what needs to change to stop them is a drastic build change for players that is not accomplishable quickly and this is a big problem for the largest majority of the players who have been building now for 3 or 4 seasons.

If this were truly a beta test game, respecs would be an option. Since people are paying (sometimes significant cash) to play, I don't think it really should be considered a Beta game. So if Bort is going to make season over season changes, he should likely consider respec options for the playerbase.

This would have the added advantage of allowing him to engage some people in more extensive test builds AND it also helps normalise the game so that he can see how builds will play out when everyone is building towards the equilibrium as opposed to people building to the extremes, then people shifting to catch that extreme, then a new extreme being introduced, etc.



If boosting 3 levels for one season can't give your LB enough Tackling, then you didn't make a real LB and I don't mind you suffering.

No full respec, period. Period. I've built some very good players, and you want those who didn't build as well to be able to gain on me? Forget it.

A between season mini-respec of 10 SP's, perhaps, this one time, because of how big the changes are.

But it won't bother me if it doesn't happen, because if you built a realistic player you're fine. If you minmaxed based on imbalances in the game, you're screwed, and I won't feel bad about that. By mid-Season 3 you knew what was coming, and even before that anyone should have known that it wouldn't be allowed to be a "speed conquers all" game for long.
 
Tracker
offline
Link
 
Panther,

I see what you are getting at but when engaging in a conversation with someone for the first time I try to give the benefit of our doubt that they are not completely incompetent.

For clarification it is pretty darn rare for my team give up 100 rushing yards… ever. We have maintained that standard for 3 seasons now. Tackling is not an issue on my squad. Yet one team has one back tandem that is just about impossible to stop and has the crazy numbers to show for it. It is for that reason that I posted this thread. Not for the beifit of my team as we have already beat them this year but to compare data with other teams who may have seen this and if possible to get Bort to look at it a bit closer.

If ends up that RBs are working as intended fine, cool I have no problem with that. But if there is a flaw in the game with a player build, it should be looked at.

To Ken… As to the “rarity” of a high tackling skill for a defensive linemen that are over the level of 20 I could not say for sure. I have no real hard data on that to confirm or deny that claim. I am not sure that anybody outside of Bort would have that info so I am taking that proclamation with a grain of salt.

I would say that if your tacking skill as a defensive linemen is not up there around level 25-26. Well, players should consider re-rolling and starting over.
 
Enkidu98
offline
Link
 
Because its all about you Ken.

My point is, if this is Beta, and Major changes are going to be made, the testing of these changes is not accurate when it is being done under conditions that would not be seen on release.

If this is not beta, because you are paying to play (at a rate higher than an average MMO) then whenever a major systems change is made, announced ahead of time or not, it is good customer service to consider providing an option for players to recoup from them playing the game by the rules that existed previous.

Punishing people for playing by the rules as they exist at a time by changing the rules significantly... not a good idea in any sort of online game experience. It creates customer distrust, erodes customer loyalty and damages your ability to hold customers long term.

Once a game is of release quality, I am completely behind you and I think you should be stuck with what you built with. Especially considering any sort of major game altering changes would not be made. But this is a self-professed beta game. As such, with major changes being made, but people still paying to play, allowances should be made to assure people remain loyal participants, feel like they weren't taken advantage of financially, and continue 'testing' the game in a scenario where the testing could be considered more legitimate. It's only more advantageous for Bort to try to maximise the number of players playing with what builds are 'supposed' to look like as he'll be able to look at the overall data and get a better view of if the sim is playing out as planned. He can then allow a smaller group of alpha/privileged beta testers create crazy builds to try to exploit the balanced system and ensure there aren't any missed quirks.


For the record, most all of my players are more of the balanced builds and I caught flack for it in the first 2.5 seasons I have played. Most of my players are not one stat wonders or built to exploit.

If given a respec, I would make very few changes to my players (if any on the majority of them).

I don't see this as a 'me me me' thing as you evidently do as your best supporting argument was "I've built some very good players, and you want those who didn't build as well to be able to gain on me? Forget it." Instead, I see the option to respec as a methodology for Bort to best test his sim engines, ensured they are balanced and output the most reasonable results that encourage players to build and play his game and ensure a revenue stream.

Once the game shifts to Beta, you remove the ability to respec.

(Long enough Grooves? I did it just for you! )
 
Tracker
offline
Link
 
Hey there Enkidu,

Sounds like you have played a few MMOs and maybe even done some beta here and there.
 
SCACE
offline
Link
 
i said it as soon as the changes were announced - this is the season of the power RB...as long as changes continue in the current format, each season, something will be dominant
 
Tracker
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SCACE
i said it as soon as the changes were announced - this is the season of the power RB...as long as changes continue in the current format, each season, something will be dominant


Yeah but this particular case has carried over from last season as well. I can’t be 100% sure on what build these guys are running but it is effective… maybe a little too effective.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.