Check out this play
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=116450&pbp_id=2144283The WR has 64 catching, 49 jumping, 7 route run, 4 sticky hands
The CB who got the INT has his attributes open:
http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=682697level 5
16 speed, 17 agility, 14 jumping, 22 catching, 13 vision
Please tell me how this could happen? The QB has over 50 vision and 60 throwing.
Not only that but the lvl 5 CB blanketed the lvl 14 WR all game long. It looks like route running SA has never worked, we just thought it did because the WRs were getting their catches when the CBs were backing up.
If Fabian Washington is covering Hines Ward, Wes Welker, TJ Houshmandzadeh even though he is much much faster there is no way he will stop them all game long because they are great route runners.
That play just shows that Route Running SA looks to be broken. Bort wrote this:
Risk calculations did not take the catching ability of the receiver into account as a very big part of the calculation. Being open is the major part. I'm tweaking that a little to be willing to pass to a guy if he's just way better than his defender, even if he's not wide open.If this were true, why wouldn't the WR be targeted more than once in the whole game?