User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > Problem with Stamina/Substitution/Depth?
Page:
 
bulletbait
offline
Link
 
Alright, so I had been going under the assumption that the % levels you set in substitution tactics were related to overall performance levels - ie. a player at "50%" would perform at a significantly reduced level. However, what I have seen in the Oceania A playoffs this year seems to run contrary to that, and in addition, seems to run contrary to the ideas that a) depth is good and b) stamina is really that important at all.

For example:

The team we faced in the conference championship had an overall rating of 21, our overall rating was 24. The scouting report listed us as better than or equal to their team in all but 1 category (and in some catergories we had a significant advantage (ie 18 vs 24). Now, this team also has very little depth. Ie. 1 player backing up both G spots and 1 player backing up both OT spots, 1 backup LB, etc. My team is 3 deep with quality players in many positions, and has at least 1 direct backup for nearly every position (ie. 2 backups G's, 2 backup T's...). To take advantage of my depth, I have been running with a fairly high sub-out %. Now, the team we faced today seems to be playing the exact opposite, running their starters nearly 100% of the time. And it works perfectly for them.

I had chalked this up initially to them having pumped up their stamina to improve their lasting power, however, one of them responded to my inquiry about their stamina rating, and quite frankly, I'm shocked:

Says one:

My SS has 70 energy left and a stamina attribute of 14.69. --76 Snaps

My LB has 81 energy left and a stamina attribute of 16.43 --46 Snaps

Another:

My lvl 9 cb has 71 energy left with 68 plays and 20.35 stamina.

-----------

Our team:

My lvl 7 LB has 74 energy left after playing 48 plays with stamina 26.6


My players:

My LVL 7 RB has 83 energy left and a stamina attribute of 23.19 -- 43 snaps
My LVL 6 DT has 79 energy left and a stamina attribute of 25 -- 32 snaps

----------


Now, one would think that a SS that played 76 snaps with a stamina rating of just under 15 would have been very ineffective on the field, but this doesn't seem to be the case. Our team was beaten 30-20, while in the previous week the #1 seed (another 24 overall team) was beatean 27-7 by this team, the week before, they beat a team that was equivalent "on paper" by a score of 30-3.

Right now I'm just confused, and a little aggravated, as this all of this seems to fly in the face of common sense.

Game:
http://goallineblitz.com/game/game.pl?game_id=8669

Our team:
http://goallineblitz.com/game/team.pl?team_id=960

Their team:
http://goallineblitz.com/game/team.pl?team_id=962

----------

Originally posted by Bort

Originally posted by buffalobills_tw


Originally posted by Bort



Hey, I have no problem with making energy affect you more, for next season. It used to be, but people got me second guessing myself. I should probably go with my gut more often than letting the internets sway me.


Bort, can we now assume stamina will play a bigger role in season 2 so teams can plan ahead?



Yeah, I'll make some adjustments. Maybe I should increase the effect slowly over the course of the first week or so of the new season, to give people time to adjust? I'll probably do various adjustments over the course of the season, too, just to make sure it gets balanced out properly.

"Power gamers" will bitch and moan about this I assure you, but I guess they bitch and moan about everything anyway.


Last edited Apr 18, 2008 08:46:54
 
NOVASaint
offline
Link
 
Your findings mirror my own. It seems teams that don't use depth are superior to teams that do.

 
aeakers
offline
Link
 
Wow. Were your players 100% going into the game? Are both teams primarily human players?
 
bulletbait
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by aeakers
Wow. Were your players 100% going into the game? Are both teams primarily human players?


Yes, nearly every player was 100% going in, both teams were all human starters (though there may be a few CPU backups).
 
TubbyChooChoo
offline
Link
 
Agreed!
It seems teams are not penalized for lack of depth at positions that really require it in actual football.
It seems way to easy for one player to play an entire game and hardly be tired and perform at a high level the whole time.
I'm confewzled!
 
Link
 
If you would have bought by Golden Tactic, all of these issues would be clearly resolved and you would massively increase team performance.
 
NOVASaint
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by The Strategy Expert
If you would have bought by Golden Tactic, all of these issues would be clearly resolved and you would massively increase team performance.


Oh darn the luck.
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
It depends on FAR more than the number of plays they play. It depends mostly on what they are doing.

Examples:

- If the safety is standing around a lot and doesn't have to chase or tackle people, he won't get tired as fast.
- If a DT is getting double teamed an pancaked all game, he gets tired quicker, or if he outmatches his opponent he gets tired slower.
- If a LB has to constantly tackle the ball carrier pounding it up the middle, he'll get tired quicker. If he's standing around spying a lot, he gets tired slower.
- If a WR runs a ton of deep routes, he gets tired quicker. If he's running short little easy routes, he gets tired slower. Same for the CB covering him.

Etc.
 
bulletbait
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
It depends on FAR more than the number of plays they play. It depends mostly on what they are doing.

Examples:

- If the safety is standing around a lot and doesn't have to chase or tackle people, he won't get tired as fast.
- If a DT is getting double teamed an pancaked all game, he gets tired quicker, or if he outmatches his opponent he gets tired slower.
- If a LB has to constantly tackle the ball carrier pounding it up the middle, he'll get tired quicker. If he's standing around spying a lot, he gets tired slower.
- If a WR runs a ton of deep routes, he gets tired quicker. If he's running short little easy routes, he gets tired slower. Same for the CB covering him.

Etc.


Even so, you can't deny that this team is exceeding the performance of teams that have far superior depth. And the disparity in talent between starters was very small, and in many cases, favored the losing team.

Last edited Apr 17, 2008 22:07:06
 
The Duff Man
offline
Link
 
Disturbing.
 
bulletbait
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
It depends on FAR more than the number of plays they play. It depends mostly on what they are doing.

Examples:

- If the safety is standing around a lot and doesn't have to chase or tackle people, he won't get tired as fast.
- If a DT is getting double teamed an pancaked all game, he gets tired quicker, or if he outmatches his opponent he gets tired slower.
- If a LB has to constantly tackle the ball carrier pounding it up the middle, he'll get tired quicker. If he's standing around spying a lot, he gets tired slower.
- If a WR runs a ton of deep routes, he gets tired quicker. If he's running short little easy routes, he gets tired slower. Same for the CB covering him.

Etc.





By the way:

Their LB that finished with 81 energy on 46 plays had 12 tackles.

Our LB that finished with 74 energy on 48 plays had 1 tackle.
Last edited Apr 17, 2008 22:10:07
 
NOVASaint
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
It depends on FAR more than the number of plays they play. It depends mostly on what they are doing.

Examples:

- If the safety is standing around a lot and doesn't have to chase or tackle people, he won't get tired as fast.
- If a DT is getting double teamed an pancaked all game, he gets tired quicker, or if he outmatches his opponent he gets tired slower.
- If a LB has to constantly tackle the ball carrier pounding it up the middle, he'll get tired quicker. If he's standing around spying a lot, he gets tired slower.
- If a WR runs a ton of deep routes, he gets tired quicker. If he's running short little easy routes, he gets tired slower. Same for the CB covering him.

Etc.


I know that you've said this, and I'll take your word for it. But it really does look like teams with no depth tear the crap out of teams that have something more like proper NFL depth. This may be because those teams with no depth have been running with no depth since day one, they all have high stamina, and all of them are high level, etc. But you'll see them just murder the backup when he subs in (because he's a couple of levels lower than the guy he's backing up) even though the backup is fresh and the other guy isn't. The mismatch between them seems to be so great that the fatigue isn't much of an issue.

It's led me to the (apparent) realization that I can't keep guys for depth unless they are about the same level as the primary guy.

And the fact that many playoff teams started stocking up with backups who were about the same level as their starters somewhat says to me that these owners had the same thought- depth is good only when it's the same level as what you've already got.
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by bulletbait
Originally posted by Bort

It depends on FAR more than the number of plays they play. It depends mostly on what they are doing.

Examples:

- If the safety is standing around a lot and doesn't have to chase or tackle people, he won't get tired as fast.
- If a DT is getting double teamed an pancaked all game, he gets tired quicker, or if he outmatches his opponent he gets tired slower.
- If a LB has to constantly tackle the ball carrier pounding it up the middle, he'll get tired quicker. If he's standing around spying a lot, he gets tired slower.
- If a WR runs a ton of deep routes, he gets tired quicker. If he's running short little easy routes, he gets tired slower. Same for the CB covering him.

Etc.


Even so, you can't deny that this team is exceeding the performance of teams that have far superior depth. And the disparity in talent between starters was very small, and in many cases, favored the losing team.



It's not like being tired = instant incredible suckyness. If you have 10% energy you aren't reduced to 10% effectiveness. Actually, it used to affect players more during Alpha but everybody complained about how stamina was too important because of that + the XP factor, so I reduced the effect some. Meh...I guess maybe I shouldn't listen to people.

There is also the factor of morale and confidence, some luck, etc.
 
bulletbait
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by bulletbait

Originally posted by Bort


It depends on FAR more than the number of plays they play. It depends mostly on what they are doing.

Examples:

- If the safety is standing around a lot and doesn't have to chase or tackle people, he won't get tired as fast.
- If a DT is getting double teamed an pancaked all game, he gets tired quicker, or if he outmatches his opponent he gets tired slower.
- If a LB has to constantly tackle the ball carrier pounding it up the middle, he'll get tired quicker. If he's standing around spying a lot, he gets tired slower.
- If a WR runs a ton of deep routes, he gets tired quicker. If he's running short little easy routes, he gets tired slower. Same for the CB covering him.

Etc.


Even so, you can't deny that this team is exceeding the performance of teams that have far superior depth. And the disparity in talent between starters was very small, and in many cases, favored the losing team.



It's not like being tired = instant incredible suckyness. If you have 10% energy you aren't reduced to 10% effectiveness. Actually, it used to affect players more during Alpha but everybody complained about how stamina was too important because of that + the XP factor, so I reduced the effect some. Meh...I guess maybe I shouldn't listen to people.

There is also the factor of morale and confidence, some luck, etc.


This should have been made MUCH more clear, then. I'm pretty sure I heard the exact opposite from Tim Harper, though I could be remembering the name wrong. Regardless, it hardly seems realistic.
 
flames54
offline
Link
 
That game has nothing to do with depth. It comes down to player builds and them stopping run with probably better tactics.

Without looking at it too detailed there's a few things that stand out. Their Dline is better than yours and they gameplanned to stuff your running game.

Also your depth chart is not put together well at least from my point of view. The other teams depth chart was.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.