User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Discuss GLB Issues With Catch22 > NOT A BUG - CLOSED > This is clearly an exploit and should be addressed ASAP
Page:
 
drifter
offline
Link
 
I'm sure you've all seen it by now. Teams are exploiting the depth charts and getting mismatches vs CBs by doing the following:
Originally posted by

Set the normal WR depth chart like this:
WR#1,WR#2,WR#3,WR#4,WR#5
Set the numbered WR depth chart like this:
WR1-blank, WR2-blank, WR3-WR#1, WR4-WR#2, WR5-WR#3

The way this works is on 3 WR formations the 1&2 positions are empty so it'll take WRs1&2 from the normal depth chart and put them in these spots. On 5 WR formations, WRs 1&2 are in the 4&5 spots, while WRs 4&5 will come in on the 1&2 spots. Unless the opposition set up their CBs the same way we'll get a mismatch in either the 3 or 5 WR setups.



Now, you can counter a team doing this by setting your CBs up the same way but if the other team removes their WR setup, you again now have mismatches.

Some may try and say this guess which hand is holding the pebble BS to be "strategy" but it's an exploit plain and simple. Just because the AI does not have the intelligence to determine that the best CB should always line up on the best WR does not mean that we should relegate the game to guessing which way someone is going to set up this time.

There needs to be a better way to manage the depth chart for multiple WR sets.
 
drifter
offline
Link
 
After thinking on this for a minute, I think the best way is that if you leave a slot position blank but have other slot positions filled in, it will fill in the slot position for you by choosing from WRs from the overall depth chart who are not listed as the #1 in another slot.
 
Robbnva
offline
Link
 
Correct me if I am wrong but I though Bort said that the WR 1-5 spots only work if there is nothing in the normal WR depth chart. If there are WRs listed in the normal WR depth chart then the QR 1-5 won't be activated.
 
drifter
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Robbnva
Correct me if I am wrong but I though Bort said that the WR 1-5 spots only work if there is nothing in the normal WR depth chart. If there are WRs listed in the normal WR depth chart then the QR 1-5 won't be activated.


I believe what he said is that it will default to the normal depth chart if the 1-5s are empty. I haven't seen anything like what you have said.
 
Rezlov
offline
Link
 
Even if the above is true, regular college/pro/HS teams would do the same. You don't HAVE to stick your best WRs in the #1 spot. Go cry because your CBs can't cover their shade.
 
Juan Fiddy
offline
Link
 
The only way around this, at any time, using the 1-5 slots or not, would be to lock the DC at a certain period before the game.

Last season people exploited slot (#3) matchups all the damn time, however the word 'exploit' isn't exactly meshing well with your definition.

You will also 'exploit' matchups once subs start rolling in, should we force something to take care of that?

Matchups on the lines? Surely some will 'exploit' this also.



The scenario discribed in your quote is the reason the DC was changed to what it is now. IE Working as intended. Furthermore, would this still be an 'exploit' if specific formations and sets are introduced?

This isn't the slippery slope you are looking for. There are other coverage problems which are exasperating the passing game.

I'm trying not to come across as an ass here, but the whole point of matchups is to exploit a weakness. If you have a weakness, then you need to do something about it.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Rezlov
Even if the above is true, regular college/pro/HS teams would do the same. You don't HAVE to stick your best WRs in the #1 spot. Go cry because your CBs can't cover their shade.


Did you even read what he wrote?
 
drifter
offline
Link
 
Double post
Last edited Aug 6, 2008 11:54:34
 
drifter
offline
Link
 
The reason it is an exploit is because it's intentionally using the inability of the AI to dynamically determine best CB vs best WR matchup as a human could easily do in real life.

Last season, if you put the #1 3rd at the depth chart, you were sacrificing his ability to play the majority of the snaps in his proper position - a fair tradeoff
 
drifter
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Rezlov
Even if the above is true, regular college/pro/HS teams would do the same. You don't HAVE to stick your best WRs in the #1 spot. Go cry because your CBs can't cover their shade.


Please reply only if you have an IQ above 100. TIA
Last edited Aug 6, 2008 11:55:13
 
ste
offline
Link
 
Damn, these these things spread like wildfire. I wrote that earlier today.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Juan Fiddy

I'm trying not to come across as an ass here, but the whole point of matchups is to exploit a weakness. If you have a weakness, then you need to do something about it.


But that's not the issue. Find a mismatch? Go ahead and have your QB attack it, but having a design "flaw" that allows teams to wait until near gametime and pick WR charts, while the defense is left no time to react is obviously an issue.

In the NFL they had a similar issue with the Colts and changed the rules to fix this because it's obviously not fair.
 
keedon
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Rezlov
Even if the above is true, regular college/pro/HS teams would do the same. You don't HAVE to stick your best WRs in the #1 spot. Go cry because your CBs can't cover their shade.


The point he's making is that he wants his number 1 CB on their number 1 WR at all times. Can't really do that here can we now?
 
Robbnva
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by ste
Damn, these these things spread like wildfire. I wrote that earlier today.


you post it on 1 team and everyone posts it on every team they are on and so on and so on, I can say this is posted on one of my team's forums.
 
drifter
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Vanilla Thunder
Originally posted by Juan Fiddy


I'm trying not to come across as an ass here, but the whole point of matchups is to exploit a weakness. If you have a weakness, then you need to do something about it.


But that's not the issue. Find a mismatch? Go ahead and have your QB attack it, but having a design "flaw" that allows teams to wait until near gametime and pick WR charts, while the defense is left no time to react is obviously an issue.

In the NFL they had a similar issue with the Colts and changed the rules to fix this because it's obviously not fair.



Exactly - for the 3rd time, it's an exploit because the AI cannot dynamically react to the change the way a human could in a real game. DO you think that when the best WR lines up in the slot during the game, the defense suddenly doesn't know where he is?
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.