User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > South America AAA Leagues > South America AAA #1 > QB Comparisons South Amercan News Agency (SANA)
Page:
 
redunion
offline
Link
 
I will not release my build as to not allow competitors to GP against me better. But I'd like to compare QB's from other teams.
I'll start of

Position: QB
Name: Lucion McElwain
Height: 6'5" 77 In
Age: 26 ( off of how many season played, considering most collages for basic diplomas end after 4 years)
Career Length: 3 Seasons, currently on his 4th
Strengths: Vision, Throwing
Weaknesses: Agility, confidence
Team: Unnecessary Roughnecks

Career Report:
1st Season: Came in late had a average season as a Rookie. Played a very impressive first playoff game, considering he was a Rookie, but still the team loss.

2nd Season: First year as a full time starter with the Unnecessary Roughnecks
(Quick Fact: Did you know that the Unnecessary Roughnecks were named "The Suicide Car Bombers" It was changed due to ethical questioning by the League) He had a very average year passing for over 2000 yds 11 Touch downs 17 INT. He helped the Roughnecks to another playoff appearance, he had a very good game but untimely the Roughnecks would lose once again.

3rd Season: This is where we see a QB either grow better, or go into obscurity. It looks like Lucion is headed for the latter. While starting out hot, and having some very good first games, it would not last, by the end he was lucky to be still starting as the Back up QB had better numbers than he did in some games. While passing for 2800 yds he threw only 10 TD one less than last year and 31 INT ( we didn't mess this up) Yes 31 INT, 14 more than last year. This will have to change if he wishes to remain a starter, or the team.

4th Season: While showing more control, and better confidence, his control is still a little off. The first game he didn't throw a single INT, and did throw a TD, but they lost against The Miners, in the second game in which the Roughnecks won, he didn't throw a single TD, and threw 2 INT, but it could be worse he could have had a meltdown, and thrown 10. Time will tell if he as learned from last year.

Scouting Report:
Strengths: He has vision and throwing complement each other, in that Lucion usually has high completion percentage. To stop this teams should try to apply pressure.

Weaknesses: He has a bad time at escaping the rush the last couple of seasons. So by getting past the line you can get to him and get a sack. Also by his big meltdown games, it seems that if he starts to struggle, he continues to do even worse.

How to Beat: Apply pressure and make him cause early mistakes.

S.A.N.A
Last edited Aug 6, 2008 00:48:05
 
redunion
offline
Link
 
Position: QB
Name: John Power
Height: 6'2" 74 In
Age: 26
Career Length: 3 Seasons, currently on his 4th
Strengths: Throwing, Vision
Weaknesses: Agility, Strength
Team: Manus Thunder

Career Report:
1st Season:John had an average first season, but really good for a rookie player, over 1000 yards passing.

2nd season: He inspired much confidence in his team, by his play over 4000 yd's passing and almost 40 TD, leading them deep into the playoffs, helping his team into the very competitive League of South American Triple A Division One.

3rd Season: This is where John exploded on the season, over 5000 yards passing and 54 TD's, catching Zeta conference by surprise it seems nobody really had a good game plan against his play. Unfortunately they were unable to advance to the Pro division, allowing his competitors to get a better feel for him, time will tell if he can keep up this production.

4th Season: While winning the first two games games in the season is inspiring, John has been unable to get into the end zone, but has been able to not throw a single INT. It seems teams have a better feel for his style and are ready to play him.

Scouting Report:
Strengths: His vision and throwing ability. He sees the hole in the defensive play and with his throwing ability land the ball perfectly on the spot. A defense has to really be on there toes to defeat these two abilities.

Weaknesses: His Agility and throwing strength. Whenever a player gets into the back field they have a great chance at getting a sack. While John can stretch the field his zip needs work as the time between throw and catch allows the hole left by DB to be made up, which accounts for his INT.

How to beat: Have your CB's play close, or have a fast DB field to catch up if a hole is found. Also rush the line to cause pressure you have a higher chance for a sack.

S.A.N.A
Last edited Aug 5, 2008 23:44:12
 
Natidawg
offline
Link
 
Hey, HEY! The Manus Thunder do not appreciate in depth analysis of their players without consent...Please continue
 
redunion
offline
Link
 
Position: QB
Name: Willie Beamon
Height: 6'1" 73 In
Age: 26
Career Length: 3 seasons, currently on his 4th
Strengths: Throwing
Weaknesses: Confidence,Vision
Team: USAORG Cartel

Career Report:
1st Season: Signed by the Toronto Raiders, he had a good year for a Rookie, and leads them two games into the playoffs, though losing in the second one, he stays for another year.

2nd Season: Playing for Toronto again, he comes out with an average year, passing for 2,800 yds, 19 TD, 12 INT. He leads the team into the playoffs leaving after just one game.

3rd Season: This year with Toronto was not so gentle on Willie, yes Toronto went into the playoffs, yes he passed for 3,200 yds, Yes he threw 20 TD, the negative, he had problems with ball control 17 INT, 5 more than last year, also there was a large spike in his sacks, but his may have been because of a weaker line. It was his ball control problems that led to another one and done playoff appearance, 0 TD, 4 INT, a lowly 18.4 QB rating.

4th Season: Whether Willie wanted to move into a different direction, or the team wanted to move on, we do not know at this point. What we do know is that the Cartel, decided to see if Willie would be able to get over his ball control problems and lead them to a Championship. Passing for impressively high numbers, 263 yd/game, 3 TD and no INT, has led the Cartel to an early 2-0 start.

Scouting report:
Strength:
His throwing ability, he has a high completion percentage, which allows his team to have a very effective game. To stop this teams should play his receivers aggressively, and apply pressure, It sure worked in his last playoff outing.

Weaknesses: His confidence and vision.
While he doesn't have a lot of meltdowns, he seems to suffer if he has a rough outing, if you get to him early you can effectively ruin his day.
He also seems to have problems finding all the holes, do to his rising INT and small TD increases, means he doesn't see the field well, and only throws if there is a obvious mismatch. His high completion but low YD/T is evidence of this.

How to Beat: Try applying pressure to him and force him to make mistakes early and you can beat him.

S.A.N.A
Last edited Aug 5, 2008 23:45:56
 
redunion
offline
Link
 
Position: QB
Name: Rocketarm D. Bomber
Height: 6’4” 76in
Age: 26
Career Length: 3, currently playing his 4th
Strengths: Vision, Throwing
Weaknesses: Stamina
Team: Brazil Cubs

Career Report:
1st Season: Joining the Brazil Cubs, and playing three games in the regular season, having very mediocre numbers. His production would pick up in the playoffs, in which Brazil made it 3 games in.

2nd Season: Playing in all 16 games he passed for 1,500 yds, 9 TD’s and 8 INT’s This year the Cubs would get into the playoffs but would leave early. It appears Bomber was the back up QB for the season and the playoffs.

3rd Season: Once again playing in all 16 games, his numbers would be better in some areas than others, once again passing for 1,500 yds, he had a higher completion percentage 63.4% as opposed to 57% He had 14 TD , 6 INT, and the cubs would make it 3 games into the playoffs, once again losing the third game. It once again appears that he played in a backup role.

4th Season: In his first 2 games it seems that he hasn’t had to much playtime. Still ok numbers.

Scouting Report:
Strengths: His Vision and Throwing. He has a high completion percentage, and a low amount of INT, so it appears that he has some good attributes in this area.

Weaknesses: Stamina. Apparently the Cubs have him in the #1 position, but he doesn’t stay long in games. So he must have really poor stamina.

How to Beat: We are not sure he is the starting QB, if you want to know how to game plan against the Cubs, you must account for both QB’s We will have a report on the second QB for the Cubs soon.

S.A.N.A
 
und666
offline
Link
 
wow good stuff thats a lot of work! you are a maniac
 
redunion
offline
Link
 
Position: QB
Name: The Great Elway
Height: 6’3” 75in
Age: 25, almost 26
Career Length: 2 Seasons, currently in his 3rd
Strengths: Throwing
Weaknesses: Agility, Vision, Confidence, Throwing strength
Team: Puerto Natales Hitmen

Career Report:
1st Season: Playing backup he put up some ok numbers for a Rookie QB, 1,300 YD passing, 9 TD, and 14 INT.

2nd Season: His first season starting he was able to play all 16 games, and passed for 2,800 yards, and he had 17 TD, but he threw 25 INT and had 20 sacks, losing 5.3 yd’s on average per sack. The team didn’t make the playoffs.

3rd Season: He has come out on fire this season for the first two games, with a QB rating of 104.3 and already throwing 2 td’s it looks like he may be headed for a good season.

Scouting Report:
Strengths: Passing ability. He has a high completion percentage, which means he know how to throw a fairly accurate ball.

Weaknesses: Where to begin, his confidence issues mean he doesn’t trust his arm or his vision and causes him to drop back deep, leading to some bad sacks, his weaker arm forces him to play the middle of the field, this inability to sense when the pocket collapses, or to find the wide open guy causes him to throw INT. His below average agility means defensive players have a good chance at getting a sack when they get in the back field.

How to Beat: Keep the middle of the field flooded with DB, to make him sit back longer, so that the DL can pressure him into either a deep sack, or a INT, which in turns snow balls.

S.A.N.A
 
redunion
offline
Link
 
Position: QB
Name: Gunner Cole
Height: 6’5” 77in
Age: 26
Career Length: 3 seasons, currently playing 4th
Strengths: Passing ability, confidence, stamina
Weaknesses: Vision
Team: Belo Horizonte Miners

Career Report:
1st Season: After the giant and rather rich Cole family bought the team Gunner Cole was handed the starting job. Having a really good year for a rookie QB, passing for 2,500 yards, 17 TDS and 11 INTs, they would go deep into the playoffs but surprisingly lost.

2nd Season: This would be Gunner’s career season, passing at 67.6%, 3,800 yds, 30 TDS, 4 INTS, leading the Miners to the Zeta championship game, only to be beaten. Some people are claiming that the Miners are chokers in the playoffs.

3rd Season: While nothing to be sad about his 3rd season just wasn’t as good as his career season, nearly 3,500 passing yards, 29 TDS, and 10 INTs. Once again the Miners, the anointed Zeta champions by the majority of the Conference, make it only 2 games into the playoffs.

4th Season: Starting out worse than his record shows, he has passed for 323 yards, 0 TD, and 1 INT. Only time will tell if Gunner missed a his Championship opportunity 2 seasons ago.

Scouting Report:
Strengths: Passing Ability, Confidence, Stamina. His high completion percentage, low interception rate, and amount of playing time, are attributes to his great ability, truly a elite QB, as there are many more things that could go here. He even scrambles at times.

Weaknesses: There has to be a weakness to every player and it appears vision is his. He seems to have a problem finding the open man, which leads to him scrambling a lot , and getting sacked at times, also his low Y/A is further evidence he checks down more often.

How to Beat: This is a very solid player, you have to play him safe, but you must attack his comfort zone, middle to short throws, take those away and you have a chance at making him have a bad day.

S.A.N.A
Last edited Aug 6, 2008 00:49:01
 
redunion
offline
Link
 
Position: QB
Name: Magic Henderson
Height: 6’5” 77in
Age: 26
Career Length: 3 seasons currently on his 4th
Strengths: Stamina
Weaknesses: Throwing strength, vision, agility.
Team: Monagas Resistance

Career Report:
1st Season: Playing late in the year he put up impressive numbers as a rookie. 111.6 QB rating, 4 TDS Though it was to late to save Monagas Resistance.

2nd Season: His starting year wasn’t too magical for Henderson. Dropping to a low 51.7 QB rating, throwing almost 2,000 yards, 9 TDS, 16 INTS The Resistance wouldn’t make it into the playoffs

3rd Season: This is Magic’s best season, over 4,100 YDS passing 23 TDS and a matching number of interceptions. He had a high number of sacks 24 to be exact. The Resistance would make it to the playoffs only to be beaten.

4th Season: Currently coming out and trying to improve on what he did wrong last year he has modest numbers so far. Currently the Resistance is 1-1
Scouting Report:
Strengths: Stamina. Last year Henderson chucked a lot of passes, meaning you have to expect to play him a lot and to defend the pass a lot.

Weaknesses: Throwing strength, vision, agility.
He doesn’t really extend the field with his play, it might be a lack of confidence, but he isn’t afraid to make a hard throw, he also tends to have trouble finding a open guy and holds on the ball to long, causing him to have to try and avoid sacks which he doesn’t have the best ability to do.

How to Beat: Attack his comfort zone in the middle of the field, to force him to hold on to long to allow your players to get a sack or INT.

S.A.N.A
 
redunion
offline
Link
 
Position: QB
Name: Shawn Horton
Height: 6’0” 72in
Age: 26
Career Length: 3 seasons currently on his 4th
Strengths: Passing ability
Weaknesses: Confidence, Height
Team: Cleveland DawgPound

Career Report:
1st Season: In his rookie year he would be exchanged between three teams first the Thunder Bay Growlers picked him up, then gave him to the Perrinton Panthers, who gave him to his eventual team, The Cleveland DawgPound. He put up good numbers for a Rookie with 1,800 passing yards, 9 TDS, and 8 INTS he even played for the Pound in there first playoff appearance, which they lost.

2nd Season: Shawn would go through his growing pains during this season, while throwing for 3,000 yards, he also had 23 interceptions. Though his 22 touchdowns helped Cleveland into the playoffs they would once again leave after the first game.

3rd Season: This is where Shawn’s improvement would be seen. He passed for 3,100 yards, 25 touchdowns, but most importantly 14 interceptions, a lot lower than his 23 from last year. Cleveland once again got into the playoffs, but Shawn would have his worst appearance and The Pound would have a early leave again.

4th Season: Coming out he shows that he is still that good QB from last year, he wants another shot at the playoffs and show the leagues he can get by the first game.

Scouting Report:
Strengths: He is an extremely good passer, he will burn you if you leave any separation against a receiver.

Weaknesses: He seems to lack confidence in his arm strength as he doesn’t like to try and pass deep, also he may have trouble seeing over his line, making him to check down more often fearing he is missing a DB.

How to Beat: Make sure you leave no separation for his receiver’s, also crowd you tallest guys at the line to force him to chuck it to where he can’t see.

S.A.N.A
 
redunion
offline
Link
 
Position: QB
Name: Fling Smartley
Height: 6’5” 77in
Age: 25
Career Length: 2 seasons, currently on his 3rd
Strengths: Stamina
Weaknesses: Confidence
Team: San Cristobal 49’ers

Career Report:
1st Season: Coming in as a back up, he put up impressive numbers, 636 yards passing, 10 touch downs, he would even back up the two playoff games the fourth niners played.

2nd Season: Apparently he was impressive enough his rookie season, he was given the chance to start and the 49ers allowed him to go threw his growing pains. Over 700 attempts, almost 3,700 yards. 29 touch downs and 26 interceptions, all this was good enough for the Niners to make it into the playoffs, which they lost on the first game.

3rd Season: Starting off, Fling shows that he is learning from his mistakes, with three touchdowns already. It also seems the team has learned that putting the entire Offense on his shoulders isn’t a good thing.

Scouting Report:
Strengths: Stamina. Fling can certainty chuck quite a few balls, and you should expect to play against his passing attack most of the game.

Weaknesses: Confidence. While he may not believe he can chuck a deep ball, his confidence issue is more of being over confidant. He seems to think he can force the ball into tight spots.

How to Beat: Keep your DB on his receivers and eventually he will make a mistake that you can take advantage of.

S.A.N.A
 
redunion
offline
Link
 
Position: QB
Name: Dudley Frank
Height: 6’0” 72in
Age: 26
Career Length: 3 seasons, currently on his 4th
Strengths: Vision, Arm strength
Weaknesses: Agility
Team: Mag 7 Hitmen

Career Report:
1st Season: After being picked up from the Hitman, he would help lead them into the playoff, pretty remarkable for a rookie QB, as they almost made it into the championship.

2nd Season: Frank’s second season showed his ability by throwing for almost 3,100 yards, 30 touch downs, 8 interceptions. Taking them two games into the playoffs before being beaten and forced out.

3rd Season: Almost a mirror image of his second season, over 3,100 yards passing, 29 touch downs, 9 interceptions. The only difference he led the Hitmen to the promise land and brought them to S.A. AAA Zeta.

4th Season: starting in a new league, we wonder if Frank can continue his rater impressive career. But he has his work cut out for him.

Scouting Report:
Strengths: Vision, Passing strength. He has a great ability at finding weaknesses down the field. He also has the arm to show it with an average of 6.5 to 7 yards per attempt, excluding his rookie numbers.

Weaknesses: If you get into the backfield with him, you better get him, you better not miss the sack, as he has a poor ability to avoid the sack.

How to Beat: You have to take away his deep pass, either that be threw, having your DB play deeper, or by getting a lot of pressure on him early in the play.

S.A.N.A
 
redunion
offline
Link
 
Position: QB
Name: Mr. T Bag
Height: 6’0” 72in
Age: 25
Career Length: 2 seasons currently on his 3rd
Strengths: Stamina
Weaknesses: Vision, confidence, throwing strength, agility, speed, passing ability
Team: Mandrake’s Beefcakes

Career Report:
1st Season: During his rookie year with the Beefcakes, he had okay numbers for a rookie, almost 2,000 yards passing, 10 touch downs, 13 interceptions, a low yard/attempt though. They didn’t make it into the playoffs.

2nd Season: Going through his growing pains, the Beefcakes had to suffer, he threw for 2,800 yards, but only had 9 touch downs, a whopping 27 interceptions, and a matching amount of sacks. This year was bad for Bag, he also had a low yard/attempt.

3rd season: If Bag doesn’t improve his game this could be his last year starting. He is starting out where he left off. A low yard per attempt, already 4 interceptions, 6 sacks, and zero touchdowns. He has to get better, because his value his is almost gone, poor trade value, his backup is someone the Beefcakes should look at if he continues this trend.

Scouting Report:
Strengths: The only thing we can really say good about Mr. Bag, is he can stay in there a long time.

Weaknesses: Everything important to a QB, (Vision, passing strength, passing ability, confidence, agility, speed) He just doesn’t’ seem to have the tools to be a QB in this league. Already at 44 interceptions, 40 sacks, a 3.9 yard per attempt average. He doesn’t see the field well, his arm doesn’t throw deep, the ball doesn't have enough zip on it, he doesn’t trust himself, holds on the ball to long, can’t escape the rush, much less sense it. He needs to shape up.

How to Beat: Until he proves other wise consider him a asset to your team, rush him, he’ll either take the sack or throw a interception, or a really short pass.

S.A.N.A
 
redunion
offline
Link
 
South American News Agency is signing off, we will finish Zeta QB scouting report later on, and also the Alpha QB scouting report.

S.A.N.A
 
MR. ULLA
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by und666
wow good stuff thats a lot of work! you are a maniac


Mental Note: Change scouting report on Redunion/Roughnecks from Mild Threat to Maniacal Threat.


eta: I like this. its interesting, keep up the good work.
Last edited Aug 6, 2008 07:21:37
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.