User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Discuss GLB Issues With Catch22 > NOT A BUG - CLOSED > Punt Bug (ST not blocking) May have Altered Result
Page:
 
DLight03
offline
Link
 
I know people have talked about this bug before, but after this game it's become really apparent to me this can alter games, and should be a high priority fix if it isn't already. I haven't seen any official word, and you can't search the forums right now, so if this has been officially recognized, just ignore it.

This is my own player picking up this fumble and scoring, and it didn't directly decide who won or lost, but I imagine in a 15-10 game it had a lot to do with it. Our team won, partly because of this, so it's not whining.

(keep in mind this is a vastly lower level player, but the player level or build doesn't matter here, it's just a coincidence)
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=91789&pbp_id=1127014
Gunner on the left side

Granted, in this exact situation, the player probably would have been run over anyways, so the result would likely be the same here, but if this player was any other level, which it easily could have been, someone would be disgruntled.

Examples of level/build not mattering
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=91789&pbp_id=1125665
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=91789&pbp_id=1125932

If the ST on the left side had acted normally, there's a chance he could have made the block on Harvey Groves and prevented him from getting down the field so quick to recover the fumble, or in the very least slowed him down.

You'll find this bug arise where one of the two gunner STs wont move at all for the first few seconds. It's always one side, and the player doesn't seem to matter. This can be found in any replay for any team.
Last edited Aug 4, 2008 23:52:40
 
Link
 
its called running the guy over, like a pancake
 
rusdom
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by flamingarmadilo
its called running the guy over, like a pancake


no, it happens in every game to every player. one gunner just runs right through his blocker and the other blocker just kinda shuffles toward the sideline. I brought this up last night and it definitely needs to get fixed
 
Skullkrusher
offline
Link
 
You have a level 24 DE running over a level 2 Center. Are you kidding? That level 2 probably pissed his pants and curled up in the fetal position.

On the other two I definitely agree with you. A level 24 FB should at least get in the way of the level 17.
 
Yellow
offline
Link
 
Oh wow...yeah that doesnt look like it should happen like that.

The left side Gunner is basically running straight through the blocker like he's not even there.
 
DLight03
offline
Link
 
Nah, the levels/builds don't matter. It's just a coincidence in this example that it does. I was just pointing out a situation that occurred, that had the team had a reasonably built/leveled player there, the result would have likely been the same, which is kind of the point of pointing out the problem.

You can find the same thing in every game for every team regardless of levels or builds. Check your own team(s).
Last edited Aug 5, 2008 00:19:59
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
The punting plays aren't very well designed, I'll admit that. It's been that way forever, though. Just never bothered to update it.
 
DLight03
offline
Link
 
Yeah i'm not too concerned with the schemes or anything on that with the punts. I'm sure we'd all much rather you keep doing the important stuff. But a player not responding consistently on one side I think is a big deal. I didn't really consider it too big of a deal until we had this game and I realized it could have altered the outcome (thankfully in this situation, they had a lower-level player that would have been run by regardless).
 
whoshotjr
offline
Link
 
My one comment is that it seems that the effect of the gunners (and others) not being blocked is more prounounced, maybe due to other changes made for this season and/or player progression.

Return averages are way down, and it seems like most of the punt returns in games between evenly matched, fairly high-level teams are like what Dlight posted:

- Run 7 to 11 yards (on an average punt) attempt to cut way too late and get tackled

Now this would happens sometime last year, but there seemed to be more cases of making the 1st guy(s) miss and picking up at least a little bit of extra yardage.

I'd also speculate that this may end up being the source of more fumbles this year, given that the PR is often running into the coverage at full speed causing higher velocity collisions. Last year the PR seemed to make lateral moves earlier, which would: help slow down the coverage a bit and cause overpursuit by players with poor vision or agility.

I know my guy coughed it up in 2 consecutive games with carrying in the mid-30's. So I bumped it up to the upper 40's and promptly fumbled again the next game
Last edited Aug 5, 2008 04:19:22
 
RAPB
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
The punting plays aren't very well designed, I'll admit that. It's been that way forever, though. Just never bothered to update it.


I really like to ask for a quick fix on blocking the gunners. Right now, the left blocker (#9 KRS) doesn't do anything and the right blocker (#10 KRS) just runs 5 yards towards the sideline - this way the gunners have a free shot at the returner (and the lead blocker just can't pick up both). This even happens, if you put really agile and speedy blockers in those KRS spots.

Just a little blocking attempt would be great for now!
 
Gisty
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
The punting plays aren't very well designed, I'll admit that. It's been that way forever, though. Just never bothered to update it.


Special teams are just as important to a game than offense or defense. Why bother having advanced AI when special teams if bugged??
 
Yellow
offline
Link
 
Well, speak of the devil. The original poster was worried about this bug being potentially game-altering. My team lost 27-20 in overtime today. Two of their 3 touchdowns were off of forced fumbles on punt returns, that were recovered and run in for TDs. Our defense gave up 6 points in regulation, but the difference was the 14 points that resulted from horrible blocking AI on special teams.

All of these plays are from today's game:

1. http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=84110&pbp_id=1594045 - the right side gunner moves straight through the blocker (a blocking TE) without even slowing down. On this play, the gunner is a level 28 linebacker, up against a level 22 TE. So on this play, it's a little more understandable. Or at least it would be if it wasnt obviously bugged no matter what the levels of the players were.

2. http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=84110&pbp_id=1594559 - the left side blocker steps toward the sideline and takes himself out of the play, leaving an open lane for the gunner

3. http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=84110&pbp_id=1595576 - right side gunner (level 22 Linebacker) moves directly through the blocker (level 22 TE) with no notable slowdown

4. http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=84110&pbp_id=1596067 - exact same situation as number 3

5. http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=84110&pbp_id=1596517 - the same level 22 LB, now on the left side, immediately sidesteps a level 26 TE, and forces a fumble that is returned for a TD

6. http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=84110&pbp_id=1599088 - wow! a 14 yard return! On this play, the gunner moves directly past his initial blocker, who is moving toward the sideline for no apparent reason. This would have been a 5 yard return, but the deep blocker (level 26 FB) actually makes a block this time

7. http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=84110&pbp_id=1599758 - the same level 22 LB strikes again

8. http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=84110&pbp_id=1600128 - this was a deep punt, so my returner managed a 12 yard return. But who is the first guy there? The level 22 LB, unblocked once again

9. http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=84110&pbp_id=1600536 - The level 22 LB runs directly through our level 24 Center (who has 75+ strength), with no noticeable impact


My returner, who has averaged about 14.8 yards per return for his career (3 seasons) and had a 16 yards per return average last season, fielded 7 punts for 55 yards and a 7.9 yard average in this game.

The Linebacker who i mentioned in almost every one of the above replays, finished this game with 9 tackles and 2 forced fumbles. Of his 9 tackles, 7 of them came on punts, as did both fumbles.

Now, the fumbling is partially my fault. I could prevent that by upping my carrying and strength on my returner, so those fumbles are partially on me. But what i cannot do anything about is my blockers on punt returns allowing gunners to run past them every single time, without even bumping them at the line. This is not an issue of "oh in real life, gunners hardly ever get blocked," because that's just not true. They get forced to the outside or at least otherwise obstructed in some way. What we have here is blockers completely failing to engage defenders, while the defenders are able to run straight through them as if they're not even there.

My game is over, it's week 2 and im sure my team will rebound and be fine for the rest of the season. It's not the only reason we lost this game (we had 3 other turnovers) but it sure did play a part in it. The same stuff was happening to the other team, but that's not a reason to look the other way. It's clearly not supposed to happen like this. For those reasons, i just want to see this fixed so that other teams don't have things like this happen for the rest of the season.

/crying





 
Yellow
offline
Link
 
Help!
 
tigerbait22
offline
Link
 
Not trying to gripe, but there are so many bugs right now its ridiculous... These new changes have hurt the game not helped it... I'm sure that they will all get fixed, but as of right now its hurting the game
 
rusdom
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by whoshotjr
My one comment is that it seems that the effect of the gunners (and others) not being blocked is more prounounced, maybe due to other changes made for this season and/or player progression.

Return averages are way down, and it seems like most of the punt returns in games between evenly matched, fairly high-level teams are like what Dlight posted:

- Run 7 to 11 yards (on an average punt) attempt to cut way too late and get tackled

Now this would happens sometime last year, but there seemed to be more cases of making the 1st guy(s) miss and picking up at least a little bit of extra yardage.

I'd also speculate that this may end up being the source of more fumbles this year, given that the PR is often running into the coverage at full speed causing higher velocity collisions. Last year the PR seemed to make lateral moves earlier, which would: help slow down the coverage a bit and cause overpursuit by players with poor vision or agility.

I know my guy coughed it up in 2 consecutive games with carrying in the mid-30's. So I bumped it up to the upper 40's and promptly fumbled again the next game


i think return averages are down because kick coverage teams are getting faster which means they will get to the ball faster
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.