User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Discuss GLB Issues With Catch22 > NOT A BUG - CLOSED > Defensive Game Plan Not Being Followed
yello1
Preacher
offline
Link
 
NEW EDIT - I leave this here for study, but thanks to assessments below, this may not be a bug at all.

___

Edited to include ADD Synopsis

I had a total of six Defensive plays set, one for 4th Down, 1 Red Zone, one for each wideout count. The game did not use these defensive plays. Why?

The details of my defenses and sample plays follow:

My game plan set for my last game was as follows top to bottom -

Base Defense 3-4

INPUT Red Zone >900sec, between My 20 & Goal, 1-4, 1 to 20ytg, -100 to 100pts, Any Formation, 0-6 WR: OUTPUT 100% 4-3 Cover 0, Man, Medium, Stack, Center, No Blitz

INPUT Fourth Down >900sec, Any Spot, 4-4, 1 to 100ytg, -100 to 100pts, Any Formation, 0-6 WR: OUTPUT 100% 3-1-7 Cover 0, Zone, Medium, Stack, Weak, Blitz 6 (CB2-5, SS, FS all 100%, others 0%).

INPUT WR5-6 >900sec, between Any Spot & My 20, 1-3, 1 to 100ytg, -100 to 100pts, Any Formation, 5-6 WR: OUTPUT 100% 3-1-7 Cover 0, Man, Medium, Stack, Weak, Blitz 2 (FS SS both 100%, all others 0%).

INPUT WR3 >900sec, between Any Spot & My 20, 1-3, 1 to 100ytg, -100 to 100pts, Any Formation, 3-3 WR: OUTPUT 100% 4-2-5 Cover 0, Man, Medium, Stack, Weak, Blitz 3, FS SS ROLB both 100%, all others 0%.

INPUT WR4 >900sec, between Any Spot & My 20, 1-3, 1 to 100ytg, -100 to 100pts, Any Formation, 4-4 WR: OUTPUT 100% 3-2-6 Cover 0, Man, Medium, Stack, Weak, Blitz 3, FS SS ROLB both 100%, all others 0%.

INPUT WR0-2 >900sec, between Any Spot & My 20, 1-3, 1 to 100ytg, -100 to 100pts, Any Formation, 0-2 WR: OUTPUT 100% 3-4 Cover 0, Man, Medium, Stack, Weak, Blitz 4, FS SS LOLB ROLB both 100%, all others 0%.

Thats the ONLY defenses I have set on this game plan preset. And its the one that was active and was active many hours before game plan.

This is the second play of the game, 2nd and 10, opponent on his 34. 14:22 to go. 3 Wideout Formation. Defense is a 3-3-5, stacked, weak shift, looks to be a cover 2, man to man. MLB may be blitzing.
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=90740&pbp_id=1238690

WTF? I do not have a 3-3-5 in the playbook at all.

Next play, 1st and 10, opp 47, 13:52 to go, 2 wide out set, Defense 3-4 Weak Cover 2 Man to Man, LILB may be blitzing.
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=90740&pbp_id=1238719

Again, not a 3-4 weak in the play book.

How could my plays not have triggered? Any play between 1st and 3rd down outside of my red zone should trigger one of my presets, right?

I havent checked every play, but this seems to go on through out the game.

And yes, the use the Defensive AI is checked off.

What gives with this?
Last edited Aug 4, 2008 20:07:56
 
yello1
Preacher
offline
Link
 
Well?

 
TurboBoxer
offline
Link
 
sum it up, to much to read
 
yello1
Preacher
offline
Link
 
Edited to include brief synopsis.
 
turnit643
offline
Link
 
yello, I looked through what you wrote and don't see what it could be. Maybe when the D Ai tester comes out it'll help to diagnose it. Sorry man, good luck with it.
 
RAPB
offline
Link
 
Found it (I guess):

1.

Defensive AI is enabled? (close it and open it again; if the checkbox isn't set, you forgot to hit "update")

2.

"2nd and 10, opponent on his 34. 14:22 to go. 3 Wideout Formation"


INPUT Red Zone >900sec, between My 20 & Goal, 1-4, 1 to 20ytg, -100 to 100pts, Any Formation, 0-6 WR: OUTPUT 100% 4-3 Cover 0, Man, Medium, Stack, Center, No Blitz

- should be my goal to my 20, but doesnt match

INPUT Fourth Down >900sec, Any Spot, 4-4, 1 to 100ytg, -100 to 100pts, Any Formation, 0-6 WR: OUTPUT 100% 3-1-7 Cover 0, Zone, Medium, Stack, Weak, Blitz 6 (CB2-5, SS, FS all 100%, others 0%).

- no match, 2nd down

INPUT WR5-6 >900sec, between Any Spot & My 20, 1-3, 1 to 100ytg, -100 to 100pts, Any Formation, 5-6 WR: OUTPUT 100% 3-1-7 Cover 0, Man, Medium, Stack, Weak, Blitz 2 (FS SS both 100%, all others 0%).

- no match, opponent on his 34; besides that no match because of 3 WR

INPUT WR3 >900sec, between Any Spot & My 20, 1-3, 1 to 100ytg, -100 to 100pts, Any Formation, 3-3 WR: OUTPUT 100% 4-2-5 Cover 0, Man, Medium, Stack, Weak, Blitz 3, FS SS ROLB both 100%, all others 0%.

- no match, opponent on his 34 (problem because of any spot and my 20; should be my 20 and any spot)

INPUT WR4 >900sec, between Any Spot & My 20, 1-3, 1 to 100ytg, -100 to 100pts, Any Formation, 4-4 WR: OUTPUT 100% 3-2-6 Cover 0, Man, Medium, Stack, Weak, Blitz 3, FS SS ROLB both 100%, all others 0%.

- no match, opponent on his 34; besides that no match because of 3 WR (there are no 4 WR sets yet anyway)

INPUT WR0-2 >900sec, between Any Spot & My 20, 1-3, 1 to 100ytg, -100 to 100pts, Any Formation, 0-2 WR: OUTPUT 100% 3-4 Cover 0, Man, Medium, Stack, Weak, Blitz 4, FS SS LOLB ROLB both 100%, all others 0%.

- no match, opponent on his 34; besides that no match because of 3 WR

You basically set up one play that didn't work and a lot of plays for your redzone defense.

Please check out if the AI called the right plays when defending your redzone.

(just my understanding of what's going on)
Last edited Aug 4, 2008 18:19:55
 
turnit643
offline
Link
 
Interesting. I wonder how the sim reads [between "any spot" and "my 20"]. Suppose it could read it from either direction ?? ... but then it would apply to the whole field and shouldn't exclude any spots, no? ... or maybe an "any spot"+"specific spot" combo just causes the input to break down and not match at all.

Wonder if [between "opponent's goal" and "my 20"] or [between "my 20" and "opponent's goal"] would solve it.
 
yello1
Preacher
offline
Link
 
Hmmmmmmmm. Thats interesting.

I was wondering if the "Between" in the wideout limiter was the problem, ie there is no number "between" three and three.

Are there ANY sets with 0 or 6 wide receivers? If so that would suggest Bort wasnt kidding when he said between and did not simply mean "from" instead.

I will change that my spot to opponents goal. I think thats a good idea.

And will also change the wideout counts.

Thanks guys. Maybe its not a bug after all.

BTW, the only play that I know DID work out of these was the Fourth down one. I didn't check red zones. We won 60-0 so he may not have gotten there....

EDIT, yeah they didn't get inside my 35. But I think that its a good bet that if they did, that would have worked.
Last edited Aug 4, 2008 20:06:41
 
yello1
Preacher
offline
Link
 
Wait, nix that bit about "between". Between is used elsewhere and clearly means the same thing as "from". Such as in downs between "1 and 3" used in defaults.

So the yardage thing would seem to be it I guess. The default seems to go from my goal towards theirs, such as using prevent only between "My goal" and "Opponent 10".

 
RMiller517
offline
Link
 
Thread locked by moderator.
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.