User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Page:
 
Vilita
offline
Link
 
http://goallineblitz.com/game/team_offers.pl?team_id=2684

We received a trade offer this morning. We accepted it shortly after receiving it, now it is gone.

We didn't retract it. The only reason it could have possibly been retracted by the other team is because they found a better deal after sending the trade proposal to our team.

The retraction system is not working as it is intended to.

If someone makes a mistake in accepting a trade, they can see it 5 seconds after they make the mistake. Giving people an hour to retract a trade just gives them an hour to try and find a better deal, and people are using this as a trade tool because they can accept an offer for a player, therefore guaranteeing that they get the first dibs on a player for an hour, and can choose to go through with the trade if they don't find anything better, or have a full hour to cancel it if they find a better offer.

Meanwhile, this whole time the other team cannot negotiate with any teams about the player since a trade is pending, and if the other team retracts, all the trade offers that were proposed for the player are gone and the trade process has to start all over again.

If someone is stupid enough to click accept, and confirm an acceptance on a trade they mean to reject, thats their problem. If you're going to give people 60 minutes to decide whether they can find a better deal on a player or not, then at the very least require BOTH teams to retract the deal for it to be cancelled, because this is getting stupid, again.
 
Welsh76
offline
Link
 
This one hour retraction was in response to owners offering their players on a long term trade then quickly renegotiating their contract to end on day 40 then accepting a trade offer which resulted in the other team getting screwed.

The obvious way this should have been sorted is to automatically cancel any trade offers for a player if his contract is renewed, a simple script that would have solved everything.

At the moment the team owner can still offer high level players for trade then renegotiate his players contract and then accept the trade in the hope that the other team don't realise within the hour.
 
Vilita
offline
Link
 
Exactly. This was the wrong way to approach the problem when it was re-introduced as a temporary fix to an issue the night before the trade deadline. It should never have seen the light of day beyond then, yet for some reason it is still in place and is being abused.

This is a perfect example of anything worth fixing is worth fixing right the first time, because the current fix solves NOTHING except the original situation 2 weeks ago, and only brings up more problems and opportunity for abuse.
Last edited Aug 4, 2008 12:03:36
 
Welsh76
offline
Link
 
I agree that this system is backwards and unless you sit at your PC hitting F5 every few seconds to see if a trade goes through you could potentially be on the end of bad situation.

I hardly send out trade offers anymore because I don't sit at my PC for 24 hours a day and I don't want to trade for someone who's gonna leave on day 40 when I'm expecting him for a few seasons, it's bad enough losing max cash on a deal but if you lose a player going in the other direction it's even worse.
 
Vilita
offline
Link
 
Yup, I really don't understand it, it does nothing to prevent what it is designed to prevent and caters to abuse and even more shady dealings then before.
 
Vilita
offline
Link
 
Yup, I really don't understand it, it does nothing to prevent what it is designed to prevent and caters to abuse and even more shady dealings then before.

Simply make a feature such that, if both teams agree to retract a trade, it can be retracted. If a player signs a new contract after a trade is agreed, it is cancelled.

All situations avoided and solved.
 
Link
 
you should trade me :O
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Are you sure the team wasn't sold back to CPU? That would cancel the trade too.
 
Vilita
offline
Link
 
Don't know what team it was now as all the trade offers disappeared when it was accepted then retracted...

It was within an hour after accepting it though. They proposed the offer, 5-10 minutes after they proposed it it was accepted. There would have been no reason for it to be retracted as it was initiated by the team that ended up retracting it, and no contract details were changed.
 
wyrebel
offline
Link
 
i had the same thing happen. but they never traded the guy so were both stuck
 
CRich
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Welsh76
This one hour retraction was in response to owners offering their players on a long term trade then quickly renegotiating their contract to end on day 40 then accepting a trade offer which resulted in the other team getting screwed.

The obvious way this should have been sorted is to automatically cancel any trade offers for a player if his contract is renewed, a simple script that would have solved everything.

At the moment the team owner can still offer high level players for trade then renegotiate his players contract and then accept the trade in the hope that the other team don't realise within the hour.


Can't they just re-negotiate their own contract right before the hour mark, and do the same thing? If they can, contracts should not be allowed to be re-negotiated while a trade is pending.
 
Vilita
offline
Link
 
Thats the whole point. This change fixed absolutely nothing, and only served to open the door for further trade abuse...
 
Vilita
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Twilightbeckoned
you should trade me :O


No, actually, you'll find that player threats and following me around the forum hijacking threads actually makes me less inclined to do what a player wants me to do. Strange thing that....
 
bigpimpin123
offline
Link
 
Everyone has the same advantage. Use the hour to find a better deal yourself. I like the 1 hour retract. I saw a trade accepted and I found a better trade myself so I cancelled one and sent out another. I don't think it is a big deal. Just doing what it best for the team.
 
Link
 
Last edited Aug 5, 2008 01:08:04
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.