User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Discuss GLB Issues With Catch22 > NOT A BUG - CLOSED > Outputs that do not total 100% automatically adjusted to 100%.
Page:
 
Sahoj
offline
Link
 
For our last game I defined some situational blitzes
versus long yardage situations on 3rd down. I had
two blitzes with roughly a 20% chance to trigger each
and no other outputs. I expected the Input/Output combo
to trigger about 40% of the time from my settings and
at the other 60% for the Sim to travel down my input
priority list and choose the next applicable.

We blitzed every 3rd and long.

Despite my two blitzes adding up to 40%, does the game
automatically read two blitz plays for the input and
go ahead and total them to 100%? (50/50 each?)

Cheers,
Sahoj
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Yes, it does. If you want it to do something else the other 60% of the time, just add an output with all "use basic settings".
 
northstar09
fist flint
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Yes, it does. If you want it to do something else the other 60% of the time, just add an output with all "use basic settings".


I did not know that. Back to the drawing board...
 
Sahoj
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Yes, it does. If you want it to do something else the other 60% of the time, just add an output with all "use basic settings".


In the instance that I have Follow my AI exactly on and Defensive AI checked on,
will the chosen play continue down my priority list the other 60% of the time or
use my basic settings?

Cheers,
Sahoj
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Sahoj
Originally posted by Bort

Yes, it does. If you want it to do something else the other 60% of the time, just add an output with all "use basic settings".


In the instance that I have Follow my AI exactly on and Defensive AI checked on,
will the chosen play continue down my priority list the other 60% of the time or
use my basic settings?

Cheers,
Sahoj


It will choose one of the outputs that are listed, not continue on. If you only have one output, it will chose that one every time even if it's set to 10%.
 
RAPB
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Sahoj
Originally posted by Bort

Yes, it does. If you want it to do something else the other 60% of the time, just add an output with all "use basic settings".


In the instance that I have Follow my AI exactly on and Defensive AI checked on,
will the chosen play continue down my priority list the other 60% of the time or
use my basic settings?

Cheers,
Sahoj


Set the same play(s) but without blitzing (make new outputs). By setting the percentages of those outputs you choose the percentage of blitzing.

- 40 % output 1 (includes blitzing)
- 60 % output 2 (no blitzing)
 
Mornacale
offline
Link
 
I think what this guy is saying is that he wants the input to not trigger in that 60% of the time, and have the AI continue on to an entire other input. However, OP, this is simply not possible.
 
Sahoj
offline
Link
 
Bort cleared up my misunderstanding pretty well, I should have shown my
gratitude sooner.

Thanks Bort!
 
islander1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by Sahoj

Originally posted by Bort


Yes, it does. If you want it to do something else the other 60% of the time, just add an output with all "use basic settings".


In the instance that I have Follow my AI exactly on and Defensive AI checked on,
will the chosen play continue down my priority list the other 60% of the time or
use my basic settings?

Cheers,
Sahoj


It will choose one of the outputs that are listed, not continue on. If you only have one output, it will chose that one every time even if it's set to 10%.


Wow, that's not particularly good or user friendly.

Once again, Bort, please implement forum search for your posts. People need to KNOW these things.
 
Rexxor
offline
Link
 
Alright - forgive me if I'm not getting this - but I set an input which triggers on a 2 WR show from the opposing offense and 6-100 yards to go to first down.

I then set two outputs, two similar coverage settings, say two 4-3's, we'll call them Alpha and Beta. Alpha runs 60% of the time and Beta 40%. I have a base blitz % on my basic UI set to 30%.

I then set a blitz in Alpha and Beta. Lets say 50% on an MLB in Alpha instance and 100% in the Beta with 1 blitzer. What is the chance of the MLB blitzing in each circumstance? I've been under the impression that the individual blitz numbers override the basic setting and that in this case if the Alpha play goes off there is a 50% chance for the MLB to blitz and if its Beta then the MLB will always blitz. Am I mistaken? If so explain please how the sim is stepping through the blitz determinations.

Thanks ahead of time for any help.
Last edited Aug 4, 2008 09:55:22
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Rexxor
Alright - forgive me if I'm not getting this - but I set an input which triggers on a 2 WR show from the opposing offense and 6-100 yards to go to first down.

I then set two outputs, two similar coverage settings, say two 4-3's, we'll call them Alpha and Beta. Alpha runs 60% of the time and Beta 40%. I have a base blitz % on my basic UI set to 30%.

I then set a blitz in Alpha and Beta. Lets say 50% on an MLB in Alpha instance and 100% in the Beta with 1 blitzer. What is the chance of the MLB blitzing in each circumstance? I've been under the impression that the individual blitz numbers override the basic setting and that in this case if the Alpha play goes off there is a 50% chance for the MLB to blitz and if its Beta then the MLB will always blitz. Am I mistaken? If so explain please how the sim is stepping through the blitz determinations.

Thanks ahead of time for any help.


That's confusing, but it sounds right. The basic blitz setting only applies if you don't set any blitz numbers.
 
Rexxor
offline
Link
 
And if I set a blitz number - in above scenario I was shooting for ONLY the MLB - I should set all others to 0 to specify that I don't want any other blitzers? I remember reading something about blanks being an issue, unless that was wrong info/fixed.

And, in a related question, if I specify 2 blitzers does it always blitz 2 or can it be 1 or 2? If it does not always blitz 2, do the blitz percentages have to add up to 100% or can I specify like the MLB at 100% and a 50% chance for the LOLB to blitz for example?? i.e. is the percentage a chance to blitz or a percentage for a particular player to blitz
Last edited Aug 4, 2008 11:54:37
 
Jose Bagg
offline
Link
 
It does not have to add up to 100%. Each blitz number is stand alone. If you set the MLB to blitz 50% and the LOLB to 60%, you will blitz the MLB alone 20%, both 30%, LOLB alone 30% and no blitz at all 20%.


The only aspect of your question that I don't have an answer too, is what order are the calculations made. I would like to think that the calculations are done like reading. Left to right then down. The order is important when you are trying to force a certain number of blitzers. For instance, if you want to blitz 1 and only 1 guy, but not the same guy every time, You need to know the order in which the checks are made, or you need to set up multiple outputs.
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Jose Bagg
It does not have to add up to 100%. Each blitz number is stand alone. If you set the MLB to blitz 50% and the LOLB to 60%, you will blitz the MLB alone 20%, both 30%, LOLB alone 30% and no blitz at all 20%.


The only aspect of your question that I don't have an answer too, is what order are the calculations made. I would like to think that the calculations are done like reading. Left to right then down. The order is important when you are trying to force a certain number of blitzers. For instance, if you want to blitz 1 and only 1 guy, but not the same guy every time, You need to know the order in which the checks are made, or you need to set up multiple outputs.


The order is random every time, so each guy gets an equal chance to be the "first" to check for blitzing.
 
Rexxor
offline
Link
 
Alright - I am beginning to get it, but my old fart brain is not recalling basic probability math, lol.

It is not a % to blitz per se i.e. if I say 100% for one and 50% for the other as far as a 2 man blitz as it has to accommodate "no blitz" as a result. Said another way, it is calculating a probability for 4 possible outcomes weighted by the % numbers I'm assigning, i.e. with two man blitz there are 4 outcomes MLB alone, both, LOLB alone, or none.

In your response you provided 20, 30, 30, 20 as the probabilities - but what did you do to get there from my input of 50% and 60%? Is is possible to specify that the MLB blitzes always and the LOLB 50% of the time? If so what would the input numbers be? This is causing a great deal of confusion in my group - we've got 5 folks working on preparing our AIs and we still cannot get the blitzing stuff straightened out input wise as till now we assumed it was a probability on a per player basis, i.e. 100% MLB meant 1 rusher always and 50% meant 50% of the time 2 man, rather than a probability outcome generator.
Last edited Aug 4, 2008 15:31:59
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.