User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
tkt_546
offline
Link
 
just got done playing our fist game, and either the offensive AI wasn't on, or it doesn't work at all...

i have one input for any fist down, and should work for all fist downs. the only two outputs are 70% run(HB only), and 30% pass. our FB ran 4 times on first down, we passed 17 times on first, and our HB only rushed 5 times on first down.

i know some of this can be screwed by being down, but not this badly, and there is no reason the FB should be rushing on first down when i set it to HB only.


and something needs to be done with WR routes. with 6 min we had 4th and G at the 6 and our #1 WR (possession guy perfect for this situation) just runs straight off the screen... and i dont know exactly how deep the Endzone is on this game, but if a player is out of bounds the QB shouldn't even look at him. that way if the guy does run a stupid route then at least the qb wont throw it to him.
 
tkt_546
offline
Link
 
 
Thaak
offline
Link
 
did you have the "Enable AI" check box, checked?

Vision would allow the QB to ignore a player either covered or out of bounds.

In the NFL (and even Division IA BCS division and Division 1AA (forget what its called now)) most teams have "timing patterns" where the QB doesn't even see the WR before throwing to a spot. He just trusts the WR is going to that spot and is open.

So your WR needs speed and agility to get open, and needs vision to run the correct routes.

Your QB needs vision to make sure he won't be throwing into triple coverage.

I think the AI mimics reality fairly well in this light, and that most of the QB's in this game couldn't throw their way out of a paper bag when facing the opening.
Last edited Aug 3, 2008 13:48:49
 
tkt_546
offline
Link
 
yes, the enable AI box was checked. and i haven't updated the page since the game to make sure its set to what the game was till i find the problem.

and the qb has 45 vision. but really the main point is that when the ball is on the opp 6 yd, no wr is going to run a streak into the stands... but if in the case that the sim messes up, it should automatically tell the QB not to throw to the wr sitting in the first row of seats...
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Your "run" output has "use basic settings" instead of run, so it's going to default to your basic settings for 70% of first down plays.
 
tkt_546
offline
Link
 
that would explain the passes. but not the FB rushing

play type, distance, and recievers are set to basic, but it says Rusher is set to HB only

edit: i've had a lack of sleep lately and when i saw basic setting i was thinking about it pulling the percentage of inside and outside runs, but it makes sense that it would pull the percentage of passes to runs. since thats the case is there anyway to set the percentage of inside to outside without having to set up a percentage for each type of run on there?
Last edited Aug 3, 2008 14:04:04
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by tkt_546
that would explain the passes. but not the FB rushing

play type, distance, and recievers are set to basic, but it says Rusher is set to HB only

edit: i've had a lack of sleep lately and when i saw basic setting i was thinking about it pulling the percentage of inside and outside runs, but it makes sense that it would pull the percentage of passes to runs. since thats the case is there anyway to set the percentage of inside to outside without having to set up a percentage for each type of run on there?


I'm not sure about the FB rushing, unless it did some goal line plays or something?

There's an option for "run" and it will pull from your basic settings for running inside/outside. That's what you want.
 
tkt_546
offline
Link
 
ok, i went through and changed from the basic settings. by "run" do you mean "run(random)" just to make sure cause it made me think it was completely random.

as far as the FB rushing, i checked every running output and the only ones that were not HB only were on 2nd or 3rd down. everything else, even the preset ones were set to HB only. maybe since it was pulling out the basic setting for the play in the fist place the other basic settings over rid that? dunno...

i had my basic setting to 50-50 hb-fb for rushing, and i used that on a couple 2nd and 3d down plays, but had HB only on everything else. and the only 4 rushes the FB had were on 1st down.

thanks for the help bort
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by tkt_546
ok, i went through and changed from the basic settings. by "run" do you mean "run(random)" just to make sure cause it made me think it was completely random.

as far as the FB rushing, i checked every running output and the only ones that were not HB only were on 2nd or 3rd down. everything else, even the preset ones were set to HB only. maybe since it was pulling out the basic setting for the play in the fist place the other basic settings over rid that? dunno...

i had my basic setting to 50-50 hb-fb for rushing, and i used that on a couple 2nd and 3d down plays, but had HB only on everything else. and the only 4 rushes the FB had were on 1st down.

thanks for the help bort


Yes, run(random) will do inside/outside.

50-50 hb/fb could net you more FB runs, based on the RNG. If you set it to inside run correctly, it will definitely run.
 
tkt_546
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort

50-50 hb/fb could net you more FB runs, based on the RNG. If you set it to inside run correctly, it will definitely run.




in the game we rushed on 1st down 9 times.
4 FB rushes
5 HB rushes

pretty close to the 50/50, but i had the advance AI set to HB only on 1st down.

if i put HB only in the advanced AI only a HB should rush on that output no matter what my basic settings say because the advanced ai is suppose to override the basic setting, right?
 
bigpimpin123
offline
Link
 
Not exactly. Its like the blitz thing. You can blitz someone 100% on the AI but if the basic settings blitz 20% he will only blitz 1/5 of the time.
 
tkt_546
offline
Link
 
that makes sense, you blitz 20% of the time, but of the 20% the rolb blitz 100% of the time.

but it doesn't make sense to say that 50% of the time the HB will rush, and of that 50%, only the HB will rush...

or lets say you have to outputs for 1st down on the new ai. pass 75% run 25% and you changed everything away from basic settings. but wait you have basic set to run 100%. does that mean you will never pass no matter what you put into the new ai, because basic setting said 100% Run?

if you wanted to pull the basic percentages, you would select basic settings on the drop down.

i don't know why, or how, but this is a bug. what's the point of selecting the rusher if it goes back to basic settings. it would make that entire menu worthless. it was put there for a point, it has to be meant to override the basic settings.

quit trying to tell me it's my settings, some things were my fault, but not this...
 
RMiller517
offline
Link
 
Thread locked by moderator.
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.