User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > The solution!! For retiring players, teams playing 100+ plays per player/penalizing depth, and rewarding team with good defenses/quick scoring offenses
Page:
 
jearly
offline
Link
 
A lot of complaints have been given up surrounding the following issues:

Capping Player development at season 10 with a steady decline afterwards.
Teams with no depth (1 starter at each position) levelling up faster than teams that sign and develop depth.
Good offenses that score too quickly to gain decent xp and defenses that have too many 3 and outs to gain decent xp.

Here's my idea for the solution to all 3.
1st - cap the xp gain at 60 plays vs 90 so there's no incentive to play your starters a ridiculous amount of plays per game.
2nd - instead of capping player development at level 10, cap it a set number of plays before a player stops improving and starts declining. (say 600 plays = 10 seasons at 60 plays per game).

That way if team wants to run the crap out of their starters they have the option to do so - for a short term victory, but a lower long term careerr for the players.

The players that choose to be backups aren't penalized as they can become just as good as the other players, but would do it over a longer period of time, before they start to decline.

Teams that sign and play depth would eventually catch up with the superstarters, but could do so while building a team concept and having fun along the way - it would just take a little while longer...

Also - this has "real world applicability" as player's careers will decline after a period of "wear and tear" on their bodies vs. a set number of years. (you could still implement a max set of years to compensate for age, say 15 years?).

A future enhancement would be to allow players to train "durability" which would allow them to extend careers beyond the set number of plays/year limit (but they would obviously lose the extra skill points along the way, so the trick would be to figure out the right balance). In addition, if players play too much, injuries could shorten thier set number of plays/year limit...

I'm sure some will see some problems with the above, but to me this seems like a great way to allow people to play the game the way they want to (e.g superstarters vs. superdepth) AND allow a competitive game all around...
 
salsendardo
offline
Link
 
I like this. A lot. It is more realistic and less World of Warcraft.
 
Rage Kinard
offline
Link
 
I like it for the most part. However, if a career is limited to a set number of plays, shouldn't players get XP for every play? Shouldn't they level up faster, if they are going to have a shorter career?
 
RUN HARD
offline
Link
 
sounds good
 
jearly
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Rage Kinard
I like it for the most part. However, if a career is limited to a set number of plays, shouldn't players get XP for every play? Shouldn't they level up faster, if they are going to have a shorter career?


definite possibility and up for debate - I was just using the 60 max that many have suggested to give some impetus for not allowing starters to play 150 plays in a game.
 
Skanker irl
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jearly
(say 600 plays = 10 seasons at 60 plays per game)


10 seasons at 60 plays per game would be a lot more, right? 600 plays would be if they played one game a season.
 
Rage Kinard
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jearly


definite possibility and up for debate - I was just using the 60 max that many have suggested to give some impetus for not allowing starters to play 150 plays in a game.


And I was one of the strongest advocates of that under the everyone has 10 years system. However, if #of plays shortens careers, then players deserve XP for every play.
 
jearly
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Skanker irl
Originally posted by jearly

(say 600 plays = 10 seasons at 60 plays per game)


10 seasons at 60 plays per game would be a lot more, right? 600 plays would be if they played one game a season.


you're right, 60 x 16 plays x 10 seasons = 9600 plays (didn't include playoffs as that would be penalizing people for the playoffs - especially since they don't get any xp in the games).
 
Frank Booth
offline
Link
 
An outstanding idea, other than the aforementioned suspect math.
 
Rage Kinard
offline
Link
 
Yeah, it would be 9,600 plays. Just set it at 10,000.
 
oldskool
offline
Link
 
Yeah, a more reasonable number would be like, 10,000 plays. That's just over 10 seasons of 16 games of 60 plays/game.

I actually really like this idea. People who usually play less often, but have longer careers (like backups, special teams guys, kickers/punters) will have realistically longer careers than the 'real' starters. People who want to have one layer of depth will be able to, but have to re-build their team every few years while people with large depth charts can have their team core last a lot longer.
 
jearly
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Frank Booth
An outstanding idea, other than the aforementioned suspect math.


 
redbox13
offline
Link
 
From a team owner, who is trying to build a team with depth I like the idea A LOT.
 
Drukman
offline
Link
 
heh, owners can purposely ruin a player's career by playing them nonstop
 
jprietman
offline
Link
 
Perfect. Magnifico. I'm for it.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.