User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Discuss GLB Issues With Catch22 > NOT A BUG - CLOSED > Going for it on 4th, apparent bug (or I'm at a loss to explain my own F up)
PP
offline
Link
 
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=78374&pbp_id=741490

The very first input I have is Punt: ball between Own Goal and Opponents 30, Down 4-4, yds to first is blank, score dif is blank and Special Circumstance is Outside FG Range

Output is 100% Punt.

All inputs I have for the 2nd quarter are set to 90 secs or less in the quarter. The play occurred at the 13:44 mark....and yes, I have Enable Offense AI (required for these settings to work) & Follow my AI EXACTLY, even when there is no match (use with caution!) both checked...And I punted every other time I should have, including later in the 2nd quarter.
 
Grimmer
offline
Link
 
What do you have set for your FG Range at the top? If it isn't 52 or more, then it won't consider the 35 as "In FG Range". Since you went for it on 4th, most likely it is slipping thru your inputs and running some default offense play based on your basic settings. That's what happened to us in a scrimmage game.
Last edited Aug 1, 2008 15:00:06
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Is that outside of FG range for your kicker? Might be just inside?

I really need to make it record which input it matched per play so everyone can figure out how it used the AI.
 
ShakeNBake
offline
Link
 
That sir is a terrific idea


Most of these "user" bugs would fix theirselves, giving you an opportunity to see the real bugs in the sim
 
PP
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Is that outside of FG range for your kicker? Might be just inside?


No clue. How does one figure what the FG kickers range is? I'm sure it has something to do with the yardage over lapping his range...I assumed that the "special consideration" would take precedents. I'm wrong on that?
I want the yardage in there because in the future I'd like to include something for going for it around 20 yards out of range or so and less than 5 or so to go on 4th. Do I need to know the exact FG range my K has to pull that off and how would one figure that out?

Thanks for your swift response, btw
 
PP
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort

I really need to make it record which input it matched per play so everyone can figure out how it used the AI.


I think that'd be extremely helpful, but some form of documentation on what takes precedents would also be extremely helpful to have in the guides section. As a matter of fact, it'd be awesome if all the bits of info that appear from you in numerous locations could end up there is some form of an organized structure. As it stands now, a person has to check at least 4 different forums and countless threads to try to find answers. I understand that you're extremely busy right now, but maybe something like that could be assigned to another Admin or a mod? This is offered as a suggestion more than an outright complaint.

Last edited Aug 1, 2008 15:27:45
 
Sigmaforce
offline
Link
 
You can define the kicking range at the top (full FG distance in the box). If you leave it blank, the sim judges based on the kickers stats whether its in his range or not.

Seems like it may be just inside the kickers range, as he's a level 25 so 52 yards isn't too much of a stretch. While its technically inside it may be at the edge, so it skipped your punt input, but the sim decided to go for it, maybe? I know that the sim did go for it on fourth in similar situations sometimes in season 3, where it was a longish field goal, maybe this is what happened.

Thinking out loud I suppose

Its best to set the FG range in the box though, I found. Then you know exactly where 'outside FG range' or 'inside FG range' is in relation to the field.
Last edited Aug 1, 2008 15:30:47
 
Link
 
Originally posted by PP
Originally posted by Bort


I really need to make it record which input it matched per play so everyone can figure out how it used the AI.


I think that'd be extremely helpful, but some form of documentation on what takes precedents would also be extremely helpful to have in the guides section. As a matter of fact, it'd be awesome if all the bits of info that appear from you in numerous locations could end up there is some form of an organized structure. As it stands now, a person has to check at least 4 different forums and countless threads to try to find answers. I understand that you're extremely busy right now, but maybe something like that could be assigned to another Admin or a mod? This is offered as a suggestion more than an outright complaint.



I agreee with PP... We have had the same problem with 4th down fg and punts... I also agree with having another admin do this record... I am not sure what DD and Thorn have been doing since I have not seen either one for quiet a while... Bort I really think you should have/hire someone to help more as it seems you are stuck doing everything... I hope that a thread of a base of how to use the settings/builds is made kinda like how it was the last couple seasons surface soon... As I am not 100% sure what affects what without a admin verifying that its 100% correct...
 
PP
offline
Link
 
I agree with your assessment, Sigma. I'm 99% sure that it skipped the punt section, because it was outside the 30, but inside FG range. At that point it continued to go down the list until it hit my catch all at the end...For this game, when all else failed, pass deep.

I could also see the advantage of defining one's own kicking range. However, with the changes to kicking that Bort promised (a nerf factor to stop the 60 + yders), is one supposed to just guess at the max range? How about after the next lvl up, when new skill pts are assigned. Do you guess again and end up trying FGs that the K couldn't make on his best day with the wind at his back? The problem with that is that we can't see them take pregame kicks or kicks in practice. So, unless I'm missing something, there is no way to judge how far he can kick, particularly with changing build and tweaks to the kicking game. In a nut shell, that's why I allowed the sim to decide. I figured it knew a lot better than I.
Last edited Aug 1, 2008 15:41:37
 
RMiller517
offline
Link
 
Thread locked by moderator.
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.