User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Discuss GLB Issues With Catch22 > NOT A BUG - CLOSED > Is the Comp Internally Favoring a Receiver?
TxSteve
Not A Mod
offline
Link
 
In my 2 pre-season games; receivers got the following passes thrown their way

WR Gunner O'Hare 12 (in 72)
WR david bodein 3 (in 72)
WR John Bledsoe 7 (in 33)
WR F. Gump 0 (in 26)


In the 2nd game -

WR david bodein 14 (in 80 plays)
WR Gunner O'Hare 1 (in 80 plays)
WR John Bledsoe 5 (in 32 plays)
WR F. Gump 0 (in 26)

Now - in game 1; gunner was #1; but he was moved to #2 in game 2 and Bodein replaced him at 1

Last season - we never saw this kind of disparity - we would typically see 3 WR's within 1 target of one another. Or see the #3 WR getting the most pass attempts (i figured it was due to being in the slot and getting the best match up)

So - I'm wondering if something is going on with the new depth chart (which I hate because it doesn't seem to work right) that is causing some kind of a 'favored target'

Also - my #4 WR has yet to be targetted in our 2 pre season games.

So I can't help but wonder if something has gone wrong with how the QB chooses where to throw the ball.



on a side note - Bort - can you please tell us how to get an even distribution of snaps for CB's and WR's? I tried Tim Harper's suggestion - but it didn't work in my game yesterday.
Last edited Aug 1, 2008 06:38:51
 
Robbnva
offline
Link
 
I have had a problem with my # 2 WR not getting passes thrown his way.
 
j10er
offline
Link
 
Interesting. I saw something similar in my first scrimmage, but I didn't think much of it. I'll keep an eye on it for my second scrimmage today.
 
TxSteve
Not A Mod
offline
Link
 
well - just quickly jotting down data from some of my other games -

Black Dragons
WR 1 - 10 targets
WR 2 - 0
wr 3 - 2


Spartans
WR 1 - 18
WR 2 - 5
WR 3 - 3
WR 4 - 0

Infection
WR 1 - 20
WR 2 - 14
WR 3 - 5
WR 4 - 0

Reapers
WR 1 - 10
WR 2 - 3
WR 3 - 2
WR 4 - 1
WR 5 - 2


If the QB is favoring a specific receiver - this could also explain some people having bad QB numbers - as the QB is forcing the ball
 
Robbnva
offline
Link
 
looks like WR1 is getting a ton of balls, anyone try setting QB target to WR 2 & 3 to see if that helps
 
missnlife
offline
Link
 
A few of my games, for stats:

DeathDealers
Game1(#3 WR was Favorite Primary Target No.1, no No.2) - Total Attempts, 25:
WR#1 - 11
WR#2 - 4
WR#3 - 13
WR#4 - 0(Depth chart "bug")
TE#1 - 7

Game2(No Primary Favorite Targets set) - Total Attempts, 43:
WR#1 - 5
WR#2 - 3
WR#3 - 3
WR#4 - 2
TE#1 - 9


Dragons - This is a slow-build team with all level 4s right now, so energy is set to sub at 98/99
Game1(No Favorite Targets) - Total Attempts, 38:
WR#1 - 10
WR#2 - 8
WR#3 - 1
WR#4 - 0
HB/FB/TE - 18
 
andrwt
offline
Link
 
look at the other teams cb,fs, ss and stuff. sometimes the sim likes to pass to a certain player 12 times in a row no matter what the setting is. so if your dealing with a lower level secondary that makes a difference.
 
TxSteve
Not A Mod
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by andrwt
look at the other teams cb,fs, ss and stuff. sometimes the sim likes to pass to a certain player 12 times in a row no matter what the setting is. so if your dealing with a lower level secondary that makes a difference.


that makes sense - but i still think something is going on - and in my opinion - some of the other data listed here seems to support a bug too (to me at least)
 
Sigmaforce
offline
Link
 
I haven't noticed anything crazy. The only time I've seen one WR getting a lot of targets (in my games) are when he appears to be open. If the WR1 is determined to be open by the QB, then he'll throw it there first before checking down to the other receivers in a lot of cases.

Not saying there necessarily is a problem, but I haven't seen much out of the ordinary in my games.

Last edited Aug 1, 2008 10:49:05
 
neverdodge
offline
Link
 
as i said in another post :

keep in mind most people are confused with the new Depht chart. Most of the time, CB1 will cover WR2, and as long as team put their best CB at CB1 that mean your WR2 is facing the best CB there
 
randomguymike
offline
Link
 
Yeah, my top WR's are getting HUGE differences:

versus New Brunswick Sentinels:
Jamie Hartshocke: 15
Matt Reeves: 3
Super Duper Clayton: 2



versus New Orleans Voodoo:
Matt Reeves: 12
Jamie Hartshocke: 7
Super Duper Clayton: 6
T.D. Catcher: 1

So, my top two WR have gotten 37 attempts, my 3&4 have gotten 9. There were MANY times in both games where passes were forced into double coverage instead of going for the open guy who was a #3/4.

I'd love to know how to create more balance. I had the Harper DC and a 98/99 sub rate.
 
dfitzo53
offline
Link
 
I've had receptions spread pretty evenly. How are all your depth charts set up?
 
TxSteve
Not A Mod
offline
Link
 
my 1st game - i only used the OLD DC with the exact same settings as the last 2 seasons...

my 2nd game - used tim harper's method
 
Eagles_84
offline
Link
 
My WR is #4. In the second scrimmage, he had 31 plays, and wasn't targeted once. A couple times, I was open, yet the QB threw it into double coverage to the #1 or 2 WR. This needs to be fixxed. I didn't have any catches or drops in the first scrimmage either (didn't watch to see if I was targeted.
 
RMiller517
offline
Link
 
Thread locked by moderator.
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.