User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > Passing needs to be fixed in this game, very long post with a ton of research, don't discard as another whine post
Page:
 
Ilok
offline
Link
 
Yes, some teams are having success with pass, but there is no incentive to pass. I'm just using my league as an example Oceania #2.

Game 1 http://goallineblitz.com/game/game.pl?game_id=82944

one team completed 51% of the passes, which is great for the league. For a 5.4 yards per attempt. They rushed 4.2 y/r so what real advantage is there to pass, with the high chance of getting no yards and a chance of interceptions?

Game 2 http://goallineblitz.com/game/game.pl?game_id=82960

highest passing team completed 55% of passes for a whopping 5.7 per play. They also rushed for 4.2 per play. Wheres the advantage?

game 3 http://goallineblitz.com/game/game.pl?game_id=82950

65% completion is outstanding. Still only 1.3 yards per play better than rushing

game 4 http://goallineblitz.com/game/game.pl?game_id=82966

41% passes complete but the same team 7.8 yards per rush and 4.4 yards per pass.

game 5 http://goallineblitz.com/game/game.pl?game_id=82956

basically game 4. 45% completion 3.2 yards per attept, 7 yards rushing per attempt

game 6 http://goallineblitz.com/game/game.pl?game_id=82972

60% completion but 4.4 per pass to 3.6 per rush

game 7 http://goallineblitz.com/game/game.pl?game_id=82946

43% comp 3.8 yards per pass .9 rush, not sure what to say here

game 8 http://goallineblitz.com/game/game.pl?game_id=82962

52% comp 5.6 pass 6 run

game 9 http://goallineblitz.com/game/game.pl?game_id=82952

This is the best example of the sim's state. The winning team realized how pointless passing is, only attempted 2 passes and won 63-3. I'm sure the owner is mad that the sim made him pass twice.

game 10

http://goallineblitz.com/game/game.pl?game_id=82968

comp 60% passes 4.6 pass 4.2 r

game 11 http://goallineblitz.com/game/game.pl?game_id=82958

The worst teams in league head to head 28% comp 3.6 pass 1.7 rush

game 12 http://goallineblitz.com/game/game.pl?game_id=82974

59% 5 pass 6 rush

game 13 http://goallineblitz.com/game/game.pl?game_id=82948

60% 5.7 pass 6.8 rush

game 14 http://goallineblitz.com/game/game.pl?game_id=82964

54% 7.5 pass 11.6 rush

game 15 http://goallineblitz.com/game/game.pl?game_id=82954

44% 4 pass 5.4 rush

game 16 http://goallineblitz.com/game/game.pl?game_id=82970

51% 5.6 pass 7.3 rush



I am no football expert, but as a sports writer for a newspaper I watch an extreme amount of football at many different levels. Outside of small conference high school football, I never seen totals so unjust towards pass. In professional football, passing is more effective than rushing. It’s why even the worst NFL team gains more passing yards than rushing yard. College is the same way outside of the spread option schools. But as a league passing greatly out weighs rushing. High school is different, but am I paying money for a high school simulator? Seriously?

Passing is effective for the risk/reward factor, but this sim has no reward for pass. Passing you either advance the ball greatly or non at all or maybe an interception. There is also a reason why teams throw more interceptions than fumbles. It’s harder to pass, but there is a benefit to do so. Where is the benefit here?

I don’t know the schematics of the sim, but to rush you’re basically dependent on the rusher’s build, plus the o-line’s build against the defender’s build. Passing you have to worry about the passer’s build, plus the receiver’s build plus the o-lines build against the defensive build.

Do something to make passing easier or rushing harder. It’s going to be very boring having a complete cookie cutter league that you basically have to run 80% of the time and have all your defensive players play the run. The only difference between teams will be the ones who may use pass as a trick to try to make running more effective, if that is even possible.

You could put a penalty in to force teams to at least attempt passes, as ineffective as they are, by giving teams that run 75% of the time a penalty to run blocking or use the AI of opposing defenses to recognize and stop the run more affective after the opposing team runs 25 run plays in a row.

Want to see the stat that pisses me off the most? Out of 16 scrimmage games ran today 21 touchdowns were thrown, 53 rushing touchdowns were scored. Show many any league any where, where they had a week where over 71% of the touchdowns scored were rushing. There is a reason why in the NFL a great running back scores 15 touchdowns a year and a great QB throws 30. Same thing in college.

You can deny there is a bug all you want and show many single game stats of one isolated instance but the fact is passing is broke in this game and you’re not getting another dime from me until its fixed.
Last edited Jul 31, 2008 18:48:12
 
BMB2008
offline
Link
 
I don't think it is broke as bad as you think. In all those games you compared the pass avg with the rush avg.

How about the touchdowns? How about the total yards? How about how many fumbles caused during rushing as opposed to on a passing play? How many of the above rushing touchdowns were typical goal line touchdowns?

There are a lot of other variables that need to be added in. On your 2 pass game, look how many cpu players the losing team had on defense. I'd run it against that horrible ai also. Most of the time if the team is going to take the time to recruit and fill a roster, they are probably worrying about tactics also.

I'm not saying passing isn't broken (both scrim games my qb played in resulted in 10 and 15 dropped passes by my receivers) but I don't think it is as bad as you are making it out to be.
 
Ilok
offline
Link
 
Touchdowns 21 passing to 53 rushing

I'll do rushing yards, but it will take a sec.
 
ericj008
offline
Link
 
Yup i think the CB's need tweaking, they're all over the WR's.
 
GG
offline
Link
 
It doesnt help that speed has been nerfed and 90% of WR builds are now worse than ever. Meaning even more CB domination. CBs dominate also because Man defense is made to be so easy on here. Man is the hardest thing to do and only a small % of pros are even good at it. Yet in this game, every team goes 100% man because CBs pwn WRs, and man is too effective here with the CB builds. To be a good man CB in GLB it should require CB builds to be over 50 in vision, speed, agility and jumping. Just to make it so hard to get to that level of being a great Man defender. Also the Shutdown Coverage SA is too effective and if there was a NERF needed it would be there.

 
dpell
offline
Link
 
http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=721578

Conclusions - It's broken. Too many drops, CB's regularly impeding routes and committing PI to get a deflection, very low level CB's are schooling high level WR's and QB's.

No response from Bort although someone said he'd acknowledged the CB issue in another thread.
Last edited Jul 31, 2008 20:02:28
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
I wonder what the percentage of long/medium/short passes are. That would certainly make a difference as to how many yards you get through the air on average.
 
dpell
offline
Link
 
Bort, here's the breakdown from my team's scrimmage. 9/18 for a lvl 26 QB facing mostly low-teens humans and CPU players. And a lot of the completions were to the HB/FB. It's not like we had our passing game set to 0/50/50 or something. We had mostly short and medium passes and almost all of our completions were short stuff and short medium stuff. Only a couple of completions over 10 yards in the air.

I'll break down all 18 throws my starter had tonight:

1 - comp
2 - comp
3 - drop
4 - drop
5 - inc
6 - comp
7 - comp
8 - comp
9 - deflected (lvl 13 SS)
10 - deflected (lvl 13 SS)
11 - inc
12 - deflected (lvl 13 SS)
13 - drop
14 - comp
15 - comp
16 - comp (TD)
17 - deflected (lvl 18 CB)
18 - comp

Here's the build of the lvl 13 SS who seems to be deflecting so many passes:
http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=404596

Nothing against the SS, but 3 deflections against a lvl 26 QB with 50+ vision? The WR he got a few of those deflections on had 55 catching which is probably in the top 5% for all GLB WR's.

Maybe the problem isn't a nerf to the passing game as much as the fact that defenders are now seemingly super-human.

Deflections:
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=79219&pbp_id=393246 - Looks like it could be pass interference to me. CB is mugging the WR just as the ball gets there. Good play I suppose.

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=79219&pbp_id=393257
The DB just impedes the WR. Should be a penalty or needs to be fixed.

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=79219&pbp_id=393514
And again, it sure looks like the CB is committing pass interference here. His dot is overlapping the WR well before the ball even gets there. This either has to be a penalty or needs to be fixed.
Last edited Jul 31, 2008 20:21:12
 
Alex44
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
I wonder what the percentage of long/medium/short passes are. That would certainly make a difference as to how many yards you get through the air on average.


In theory if he upped the deep ball percentage that would lower the overall completion percentage making passing equally as worthless to him. No?
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Alex44
Originally posted by Bort

I wonder what the percentage of long/medium/short passes are. That would certainly make a difference as to how many yards you get through the air on average.


In theory if he upped the deep ball percentage that would lower the overall completion percentage making passing equally as worthless to him. No?


Maybe, or maybe the QB can make those passes and nobody's really tried because they're afraid it won't work. I wonder if maybe the average distance on all the plays needs to be bumped up a little so they are all about 1-2yds longer routes. Might make a big difference as to averages.
 
LostPeon
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by dpell
Deflections:
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=79219&pbp_id=393246 - Looks like it could be pass interference to me. CB is mugging the WR just as the ball gets there. Good play I suppose.

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=79219&pbp_id=393257
The DB just impedes the WR. Should be a penalty or needs to be fixed.

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=79219&pbp_id=393514
And again, it sure looks like the CB is committing pass interference here. His dot is overlapping the WR well before the ball even gets there. This either has to be a penalty or needs to be fixed.


You can't take the dots at their face value. Sure, there might be something fishy going on, but it's impossible to tell from the replay what really happened. You can't say there should be a penalty...
 
dpell
offline
Link
 
Bort, what about the CB's mugging/violating the WR's? I posted a couple of plays where the CB is obviously coming over the back of the WR to get a deflection. Others have posted replays of CB's bumping and mugging WR's the entire route. Will this be fixed before the start of the regular season? I'm scared if a lvl 13 SS playing CB can deflect 3 passes thrown from a lvl 26 QB to a lvl 26 WR.
 
dpell
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by LostPeon

You can't take the dots at their face value. Sure, there might be something fishy going on, but it's impossible to tell from the replay what really happened. You can't say there should be a penalty...


The CB dot is getting a deflection when the WR dot has position on him, breaks the route back, and by all accounts it appears he's coming over the WR's back to make the deflection well before the ball is there. Something isn't right. Last season we didn't see that in the sims. At least not to that extent.
Last edited Jul 31, 2008 20:29:27
 
Alex44
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by Alex44

Originally posted by Bort


I wonder what the percentage of long/medium/short passes are. That would certainly make a difference as to how many yards you get through the air on average.


In theory if he upped the deep ball percentage that would lower the overall completion percentage making passing equally as worthless to him. No?


Maybe, or maybe the QB can make those passes and nobody's really tried because they're afraid it won't work. I wonder if maybe the average distance on all the plays needs to be bumped up a little so they are all about 1-2yds longer routes. Might make a big difference as to averages.


Obviously I'm not going to argue with the guy who created the sim. I'm sure your yards per attempt would go up, but if the sim mirrors reality in the passing game the percentage would probably go down.

Then again maybe the QB's can make the throws and we just dont know it.
 
Xiong Yoshi
offline
Link
 
Even though this looks interesting.. this "study" is kinda worthless because of one major factor: Tackling.

Right now it is entirely possible that rushes are too successful, relative to passes, because the Defensive players have focused upon speed and Strength and ignored tackling. Once the average tackling level goes up, those Average rush numbers might come down.

Admittedly, my gut feeling is that Passing could use some help - but probably not as much as your numbers suggest.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.