User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > South America AA Leagues > South America AA #1 > ~~~~SEASON 4 ALL-LEAGUE SUGGESTIONS~~~~
Page:
 
Jmac0585
offline
Link
 
Never too early for this is it?

Option 1: Every player fills out their own
ballot and votes without regard to any rules, ie, everyone
votes for their own teammates, and the team that gets the
most of its own players to vote, fills the roster.

Option 2: A single person takes it upon
themselves to come up with some rules, then every player
creates their own ballots while following the rules (season 2 method)

Option 3: A single person takes it upon
themselves to come up with some rules, then a person
nominates the players they feel are deserving of
consideration (season 4 method)

Option 4: A single person takes it upon
themselves to come up with some rules, and a mathematical
formula to determine the candidates or winners.

Option 5: The group at-large here agrees on
how the formula should be created, then the formula is
applied to all players in the league, and the winners
announced.

Option 6: We name Wolverine the MVP again,
and everyone else "buggers off."

Obviously I don't know anything about picking an ALL-LEAGUE
team. So, if options 2, 3, or 4 are chosen, someone much
more brilliant than I will have to step in and do the job.
I don't need to hear anymore whining that I already do. I
am married and have two little kids. I get my full, USDA
recommended daily does of that vitamin W everyday.
I will show you what I had in mind for the numbers to do
the equation, but will not take sole responsibility for it.
Team owners/GMs, if this is something that you think your
players might care about enough to wine about it, you might
want to get their feedback, or send them here. Newbies,
this is a big deal around here, and one of the reasons this
league is one of the better in the game.

If you are new to the league, this is for your reference:
http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=627667

and

http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=286604


Here's a suggestion for option 5:
Stats to consider for Defense:

Tackles, Missed Tackles, Hurry, Sack, Tackles For Loss, Passes Defended,
Interceptions, Defensive TDs, Forced Fumbles, Fumble Recovery, Safety

The issue is the values for stats. For example, should the values for tackles be
different for Linebackers than it is for Corners? Ideally you don't want a CB with a
lot of tackles, but if your CB is making a lot of tackles, he might be the only
thing keeping the rest of the defense hanging themselves.
Or, should all of the numbers (i.e. a value for a sack) be the same and let the
numbers work themselves out? A pick is a pick, regardless of if the DE got it, or
the FS. I am more than fine with option number five.
Last edited Aug 5, 2008 08:38:15
 
conanfan
offline
Link
 
I liked how you did it last season, but it sounds like we better go with option #5.
 
Jmac0585
offline
Link
 
I was partial to #6 myself.
 
conanfan
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Jmac0585
I was partial to #6 myself.


yeah it's kind of a given isn't it?
 
Baustin
offline
Link
 
My only issue with the way it was done is, after about 2 hours and 1000 mouse clicks, I realized I was halfway through the offense, and really didn't have the time to devote to completing an informed ballot.

That was just looking at the nominees. Until the League and Team Leaders pages have positions listed, it is a huge time sink.

I'm online a lot, but 4-6 hours and 3 pages of notes later kind of sucks the fun out of it.

I'm all for anything that makes it a 1-2 hour process, at the most. A thread with nominees, including relevant stats, to me, would be ideal. I realize that would be a huge job for you, Jmac, but if it's left up to me to do all the research, it's not getting done.

I think anything that makes for less effort on the part of the majority, will generate more voting.
 
blazzinken
offline
Link
 
Jmac, i want to say that i think you have done a great job the last two seasons with the All-League voting. There is always someone who thinks they will be snubbed, for example: if everyone that thought they should win the Heisman actually won that award, then there would be alot more then 72 winners of the award.

That might not be a good example but just wanted to say that i think you have done a great job and put a lot of time and effort into something for other people and they don't even appreciate it.

I like the way it was done last season. But its going to be pretty time consuming anyway you do it, i think.
 
und2004
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by conanfan
Originally posted by Jmac0585

I was partial to #6 myself.


yeah it's kind of a given isn't it?


So glad hes on my team... makes me as DC look good.
 
Jmac0585
offline
Link
 
That is why I suggested we make up an equation. Then we take the numbers, run them and
you have your winners. On the positions that are singles (QB, C, FB, etc) you'd have
two or three nominees, instead of five. Obviously using math doesn't take into account
the Corner who blankets a receiver to the point the ball is never thrown there, but
there are sacrifices to be made if it's to be quick and easy.

SO what I'd suggest is we look at the positions and do something like:
QB - what are the most important stats to consider? Passer rating, TDs, Yards, Comp, IN, Comp%, rushing yards... Each of these is given a value, you tabulate the values, and boom a number that you compare with one or two other guys. The question becomes how do you tie numbers to the stats. To me, QB rating is key, then TDs, yards, comp%/Comp... etc.
I will come up with some numbers, and let you guys decide if they are accurate enough to give a fair representation of a player's season.
 
conanfan
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Jmac0585
That is why I suggested we make up an equation. Then we take the numbers, run them and
you have your winners. On the positions that are singles (QB, C, FB, etc) you'd have
two or three nominees, instead of five. Obviously using math doesn't take into account
the Corner who blankets a receiver to the point the ball is never thrown there, but
there are sacrifices to be made if it's to be quick and easy.

SO what I'd suggest is we look at the positions and do something like:
QB - what are the most important stats to consider? Passer rating, TDs, Yards, Comp, IN, Comp%, rushing yards... Each of these is given a value, you tabulate the values, and boom a number that you compare with one or two other guys. The question becomes how do you tie numbers to the stats. To me, QB rating is key, then TDs, yards, comp%/Comp... etc.
I will come up with some numbers, and let you guys decide if they are accurate enough to give a fair representation of a player's season.


Thanks Jmac!

On the "blanket corner" concern: does the sim even do that? It seems like the targets are consistently at the best WR on the team regardless of who is covering him. ??

The only stats I worry about are for the O-line. Pancakes is a lame way to determine the best linemen in the game. Any sign of an individual "sacks given up" stat out there? Or rushing yards per side?


 
Baustin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort

Definitely looks to be a case of always passing to the most open guy. The CB in the OP's post is playing way off the receiver and leaving him open over and over. Maybe there needs to be more randomness in pass selection? Right now the QB will just look for the most open guy and send it his way.
 
panachevitz
offline
Link
 
I'm just going to take the easy way and vote for option 6.
 
cptafw163
offline
Link
 
The pancake thing for o-lineman is lame because the best O-linemen are going to be from teams that run a lot. How many times have you seen someone pancaked when the o-lineman was pass blocking.

How bout the person who gave up the least sacks against Howlett?
 
Baustin
offline
Link
 
The RG from the Mormons is already looking like an early nominee.
 
blazerblade
offline
Link
 
I like option 5 nominate like 10 people pick 7 for a commite each year... this would promote more people to post on our forum .
 
irishpimp815
offline
Link
 
well i'm hoping for a repeat of last years results
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.