User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
eric95403
offline
Link
 
Unless a certain situation arises in the 2nd quarter, I have my settings to punt on 4th down. Well, that didn't happen on these plays. I looked for something in my tactics that might have triggered them, but could find nothing.

1st Q: http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=79351&pbp_id=274755 (game still close)

4th Q: http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=79351&pbp_id=277474 (blow out, along w/ others)

4th Q: http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=79351&pbp_id=277658

4th Q: http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=79351&pbp_id=278925
 
seanjansen
offline
Link
 
I didn't punt on 4th down on this play.

3rd Q: http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=81767&pbp_id=372791 (Down by 7)

I had settings to go for it on 4th down if it were in between my Own 45 and the Opponent 35, if it were between 1 and 4 yards. (I also have a setting to go for it from almost anywhere with 4th and 0-1). I also checked to make sure my punt settings were correct and they were (Set up 100% output to punt if it were on down 4 to down 4 and between the ). No 3rd quarter specific strategies.

The only anamoly that I can think of is that under my go for it on 4th and 1-4 settings is that I had set it so that I would go for it from my Own 45 to the Opponent 35, and at the same time set special circumstance to be within 10 yards of FG range. I wouldn't think this would affect it since I had it set to be within 1 to 4 yards and in the play in question it was above 10.

My only thought was that the game overrode the 1-4 yard command since it was within 10 yards of FG range. Any comments?
 
dtrance
offline
Link
 
Same issue here. I have the default presets but with one input to go for it on 4th and short (1-2 yards) 50% of the time *IF* we are in FG range (52 yards). Problem is ... we went for it on 4th and 9 from our own 20 yard.
 
Ken1
offline
Link
 
It's almost definitely in the AI you set. Some inputs are set such that down doesn't matter, and if you have them ahead of your Punt input, they'll mess it up.
 
seanjansen
offline
Link
 
Are there inputs in which the yardage doesn't matter?
 
eric95403
offline
Link
 
The only tactic I set to not punt was in the 2nd Quarter, under 2 minutes, if I was at the 50 to opponents 35 and it was 4-between 1 and 4yrds to go. I didn't touch any other tactics regarding punting. I still have punting 100% of the time in all other situations. I was winning 51-7 in the 4th Q, and I wasn't down late to trigger than response. I looked at that too. Some of the plays I linked above are over 4yds to go. None in the 2nd Q. I don't know what triggered it in the 1st Q.
 
Ken1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by seanjansen
Are there inputs in which the yardage doesn't matter?


Yes, including default inputs.

Just put Punt ahead of everything that isn't meant to be considered before punting. If you don't want it on 4th down, whatever the tactic, put it lower the the punt tactic.

I set mine up for two teams, and the only time we punted that I didn't like was the fault of my own AI settings.
 
seanjansen
offline
Link
 
I did put punt ahead of everything that wasn't meant to considered before punting. I think the problem for me might have been that for one of the inputs I had it set as follows

Down: 4-4
Field Position: Own 45-Opponent 35
Yardage for 1st: 1-4
Special Circumstance: Near FG Range (10 YD).

Output: Go for it, essentially.

I have a feeling that it saw that we were near FG range and it ignored the yardage that we needed for a first. Other than that, I've looked over our AI settings many times and I can't figure it out.
 
Ken1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by seanjansen
I did put punt ahead of everything that wasn't meant to considered before punting. I think the problem for me might have been that for one of the inputs I had it set as follows

Down: 4-4
Field Position: Own 45-Opponent 35
Yardage for 1st: 1-4
Special Circumstance: Near FG Range (10 YD).

Output: Go for it, essentially.

I have a feeling that it saw that we were near FG range and it ignored the yardage that we needed for a first. Other than that, I've looked over our AI settings many times and I can't figure it out.


That would be a bug, then.
 
eric95403
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by seanjansen
I did put punt ahead of everything that wasn't meant to considered before punting. I think the problem for me might have been that for one of the inputs I had it set as follows

Down: 4-4
Field Position: Own 45-Opponent 35
Yardage for 1st: 1-4
Special Circumstance: Near FG Range (10 YD).

Output: Go for it, essentially.

I have a feeling that it saw that we were near FG range and it ignored the yardage that we needed for a first. Other than that, I've looked over our AI settings many times and I can't figure it out.


Mine was similar, except I only put it in the 2nd Q (60 seconds left), but had 0-4 yds to go, between opponents 50-35yd line. No special circumstances

The other 4th Down setting was placed near the bottom of my personal settings (for all quarters), but I had no other 4th down options set. I had 4th down, punt 100% of the time outside FG range. I placed this setting back up near the top for the next game to see if that'll make a difference.

I have no other special settings/tactics that should make me go for it on 4th down.

Oh well, we'll see what happens in the next game.
 
eric95403
offline
Link
 
I don't want to sound like a broken record here. But we went for it twice on 4th down again today w/o punting. I checked the settings again. We were handily winning in the 3rd and 4th quarter this game too.

3rd Q: http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=79354&pbp_id=695507
4th Q: http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=79354&pbp_id=696002

As previously stated, I only have created one tactic/output that will do this... 2nd Q, under 60 seconds left in the quarter, between the opponents 50/35 and it's 4 and 0/1. The other 4th down setting is punt 100% of the time on 4th down, in the all quarters section.

I'm happy we made both attempts, unlike last game. But still, the regular season starts. I have the other GM's rechecking our tactics, but I really don't see anything.
 
RMiller517
offline
Link
 
Thread locked by moderator.
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.