User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Discuss GLB Issues With Catch22 > NOT A BUG - CLOSED > Punt Return weirdness in the playoffs
Yellow
offline
Link
 
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?pbp_id=1113893

Cost us field position and ultimately a field goal, because our Punt Returner just watches the ball fly over his head. This happened 3 times in this game.

What gives?
 
ShamsTron
offline
Link
 
I would guess that your PR believes it will go out for a touch back but his vision has failed him.
 
Tier
offline
Link
 
no bounce either?
 
morbo
offline
Link
 
Yea sure but what after that? He just stands there, stare at the ball while every other player run past him towards that ball? Must be a bug, I have seen a ton of these.
 
Yellow
offline
Link
 
Yeah even if he believes it will go out for a touchback, why the hell would he just stand there and not move at all. He just stood frozen for the whole play. You'd think that in a playoff game where field position is super important, he would at the very least block one of the gunners to try to give the ball a better chance to go into the endzone for a touchback.

This shit is terrible in the playoffs.
 
ShamsTron
offline
Link
 
If I remember correctly this has happend on kickoffs as well on the regular season.
 
bigtisme
offline
Link
 
I think at most levels of football it is an "unwritten rule" to NOT field a punt inside your own 10.
 
Beerski
offline
Link
 
Exactly, if the punt lands inside the 10, the players from the receiving team should stay away from it. This is a normal play.
 
Yellow
offline
Link
 
Yes, under normal circumstances a punt returner should allow a ball to go over his head and bounce into the endzone for a touchback, if he is standing at the 10 or 15.

It is not normal, however, for the punt returner to not move at all during the entire play. He could be blocking or something to at least try to prevent the punt team from downing the football.

And seriously, this is the playoffs. Would Devin Hester allow that to happen on a punt in a tight game during the playoffs when you need all the field position you can get?
 
partylwc
offline
Link
 
LOL HAHA
 
Galkuris
offline
Link
 
I highly doubt your return man is anywhere near Devin Hester level. 99% of returners would let that go.
 
VikesRule
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Yellow
Yes, under normal circumstances a punt returner should allow a ball to go over his head and bounce into the endzone for a touchback, if he is standing at the 10 or 15.

It is not normal, however, for the punt returner to not move at all during the entire play. He could be blocking or something to at least try to prevent the punt team from downing the football.

And seriously, this is the playoffs. Would Devin Hester allow that to happen on a punt in a tight game during the playoffs when you need all the field position you can get?


Yes he definitely would, especially if his coach tells him to. In a playoff game a mistake on a punt return (like a fumble or him losing massive yardage) would be disastrous for a team.

That's why you don't take any chances and you gotta believe that if a punt is going inside the 10, there is a much higher chance that it goes into the endzone for a touchback then there is for you to field the ball and get a good gain. If you were to fumble the ball then you are basically giving the other team free points with it being so close to their goalline.

That said, I think the programming is bugged, but in this case it is causing the returner to act like he should in real life. You are correct in thinking that a returner would go block someone or at least try to deceive the coverage team into thinking he was going to catch it before letting it go, but that kind of stuff is probably too advanced for the game right now (especially in giving returners the ability to judge whether or not to let the ball go or if they should return it).
 
whoshotjr
offline
Link
 
Be thankful your guy doesn't catch them. My guy had his 1st fumble of the year fielding a ball @ the 5.

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?pbp_id=1129412

Glad I put a few extra points in strength, confidence, and carrying


 
Big_Sexxy_II
offline
Link
 
You guys are forgetting one important fact. Your Level. The game goes beyond level 90, so if you're only a level 10 returner (which is fairly decent right now), you're still playing around the Midget League level.

Your vision is likely to be low (it's hard pretending to be dumbe sometimes, huh?) Even if you have a 30 vision, that's still pretty terrible (in the long run.) It might be high for your level, but a very smart 5th grader is still just a 5th grader. That's about where we're at right now.
 
RMiller517
offline
Link
 
Thread locked by moderator.
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.