User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Discuss GLB Issues With Catch22 > NOT A BUG - CLOSED > Why was my WR subbing in at Running Back?
Page:
 
drifter
offline
Link
 
http://goallineblitz.com/game/game.pl?game_id=78775

Depth chart did not have him listed at HB yet he got a number of plays as the backup RB, while the regular backup did not see any rushes.
 
drifter
offline
Link
 
Bump. Any one else seeing this?
 
iv82much
offline
Link
 
If a WR gets an end around or pitch back it counts as a rush. Thats the only explanation there would be if it wasn't a bug. I had a bug too, the cpu switched out my PR and KR to come crappy cpu wr's.
 
Ken1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by drifter
Bump. Any one else seeing this?


I had a FS sub in at CB, when he wasn't on the DC for any CB slot. Sort of similar.
 
drifter
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by iv82much
If a WR gets an end around or pitch back it counts as a rush. Thats the only explanation there would be if it wasn't a bug. I had a bug too, the cpu switched out my PR and KR to come crappy cpu wr's.


Nope. I have yet to see an end around in this game. These were plays out of the backfield.
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Goal line offense with not enough TE's?
 
iv82much
offline
Link
 
This new code is a mess. Very time consuming to fix. It will be interesting to see if they delay the season, continue with messed up code, or switch back to the old buggy code.
 
iv82much
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Goal line offense with not enough TE's?



That makes sense, possibly some smart AI to make sure if that happens the WR won't get a handoff in that formation. It can be hard to carry 3 TEs, the 3rd one might not get enough playing time.
 
Ken1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by iv82much
This new code is a mess. Very time consuming to fix. It will be interesting to see if they delay the season, continue with messed up code, or switch back to the old buggy code.


Even as it exists now, the current code is better than last season's. I mean, finally, some TD drives! There'll be somewhere near a realistic number of them once completion chances are increased (and in one way or another they will be).

And half the preseason debugging time still remains.
 
chrome
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Goal line offense with not enough TE's?

That's most likely the reason, and it needs to be changed Bort. There's absolutely no reason why starters should be pulled out of position to fill in at the #2 and #3 slots at some other position. And its nothing to do with new code, the Goal Line formation's depth chart has been screwed up since whenever it was first implemented.

This play cost my team a TD today. http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=78391&pbp_id=317674

I only roster 1 TE and 1 FB (no injuries = no reason for backups), so needing 2 TEs, the AI moved my #1 FB and #1 HB out to the edges. This made a hole at FB, so it moved my #2 HB to FB. That left a hole at HB, so it put in my FS, who promptly fumbled the ball with his 14 Carrying skill.

I can deal with the issue easily enough by excluding the Goal Line from my offensive AI (something I planned on doing anyways), but I shouldn't have to. A starter should never be taken out of his position to go play somewhere else when there's a back up available to do the job.

FREX - There's no reason why the lineup for my play couldn't have been:

TE #1 = TE
TE #2 = HB #2
TE #2 = FS (or whoever)
HB = HB
FB = FB
Last edited Jul 30, 2008 18:05:27
 
travathian
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by
I only roster 1 TE and 1 FB (no injuries = no reason for backups),


Well now, I guess there is a reason for depth. And stop calling them backups.
 
Robbnva
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by chrome
Originally posted by Bort

Goal line offense with not enough TE's?

That's most likely the reason, and it needs to be changed Bort. There's absolutely no reason why starters should be pulled out of position to fill in at the #2 and #3 slots at some other position. And its nothing to do with new code, the Goal Line formation's depth chart has been screwed up since whenever it was first implemented.

This play cost my team a TD today. http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=78391&pbp_id=317674

I only roster 1 TE and 1 FB (no injuries = no reason for backups), so needing 2 TEs, the AI moved my #1 FB and #1 HB out to the edges. This made a hole at FB, so it moved my #2 HB to FB. That left a hole at HB, so it put in my FS, who promptly fumbled the ball with his 14 Carrying skill.

I can deal with the issue easily enough by excluding the Goal Line from my offensive AI (something I planned on doing anyways), but I shouldn't have to. A starter should never be taken out of his position to go play somewhere else when there's a back up available to do the job.

FREX - There's no reason why the lineup for my play couldn't have been:

TE #1 = TE
TE #2 = HB #2
TE #2 = FS (or whoever)
HB = HB
FB = FB


well there are 3 TE formations and you are only carrying 1 TE so the cpu has to put someone in the place. Don't blame the AI because you decided to carry 1 TE.
 
Robbnva
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by travathian
Originally posted by

I only roster 1 TE and 1 FB (no injuries = no reason for backups),


Well now, I guess there is a reason for depth. And stop calling them backups.


if you have 2 TEs or 2 FBs the 1st one is the starter and the 2nd is the backup, what else should he be calling them
 
chrome
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by travathian
Well now, I guess there is a reason for depth. And stop calling them backups.

Not really. I'm never going to run another 2 or 3 TE set and there's no 2 FB formations.

And even with backups at those positions Goal Line formation still steals players from out of their starting position. TE's #1 and #2 play where they should, then the starting FB gets jacked to TE3 where he's a complete waste of space on a run up the middle. (the only play I've ever seen run out of the goal line formation) That leaves the backup FB lead blocking for me. Wouldn't it make a whole lot more sense to have your best lead blocker leading the way for you?

Originally posted by Robbnva
well there are 3 TE formations and you are only carrying 1 TE so the cpu has to put someone in the place. Don't blame the AI because you decided to carry 1 TE.

I'm not saying it doesn't have to fill the TE2 and 3 spots. I'm saying it shouldn't be taking a team's starting players to do it. Especially when there are better suited, more obvious player available (linemen).
Last edited Jul 30, 2008 18:20:17
 
Robbnva
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Ken1
Originally posted by iv82much

This new code is a mess. Very time consuming to fix. It will be interesting to see if they delay the season, continue with messed up code, or switch back to the old buggy code.


Even as it exists now, the current code is better than last season's. I mean, finally, some TD drives! There'll be somewhere near a realistic number of them once completion chances are increased (and in one way or another they will be).

And half the preseason debugging time still remains.


+1

As I predicted 90% of the people will not be able to understand or master the advanced tactics. Even the people who know what they are doing are making simple mistakes. If you guys are not liking the results go back to the basic settings until you have time to figure it out. We were given about half of season 3 (20 or so days) to learn as much about the input and output screens. yes there are a few bugs that have to be worked out and Bort has basically corrected all that have been posted
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.