User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Discuss GLB Issues With Catch22 > NOT A BUG - CLOSED > Output Question - likely for Bort
Hank Stram
offline
Link
 
I just want to make sure about something...and probably only Bort could answer it.

The guide says the outputs for a given input need to equal 100%. That makes sense...unless the computer just checks the outputs in order.

For example, let's say you have three outputs...at 30%, 30%, and 40%. Does the computer definitely pick a random number 1-100 and assign it? Or does it check against the first one, check against the second one, and then check against the third one?

If the latter is the case, couldn't the computer fail on all three checks and then go back to a standard setting?

This just occurred to me as part of me wondered if my last output shouldn't really be 100%.

I might be tilting at windmills, but computers are fickle things.
 
Zoblefu
offline
Link
 
How would outputs fail?
 
dfitzo53
offline
Link
 
If you are right, it doesn't just affect your last output, it affects all but the first. A little basic probability tells us that.

Let's say we have three settings, at 40%, 40% and 20%. From here on out, I'll refer to percentages as decimals, so 40% = .4.

The chance of calling the first play, no matter how the sim works, is .4.

If you are right, the chance of calling the second play is less than .4, it's .4 of the chance of not calling the first play, which is .6. It's .4 x .6, or .24. (24%)

The chance of calling the third play then is only .2 of the chance of not calling either of the above plays, which is .36. .2 x .36 = .072, or 7.2%.

If you are right, the chance of any output after the first being called is drastically smaller than what the coordinator intends.
 
ShakeNBake
offline
Link
 
i don't think he's right but then again i couldn't say for sure either way
 
Sigmaforce
offline
Link
 
It has to be run on a random number type system, I'd say. Like:

30% Play A, 70% Play B.
Random number generates a number between 1-100
1-30 (or whatever) = play A runs
31-100 = play B runs

I mean, its possible that the system may be set up the way you state currently, but I can't imagine that is the way Bort intended it. I haven't really seen much evidence that would lead me to suggest its not like the situation I described above
 
Zoblefu
offline
Link
 
oh... think its just a random number 1-100 and assigns it from how I understand.
 
Hank Stram
offline
Link
 
I honestly believe I'm wrong, too...but since there are huge AI questions, it bears asking.
 
RMiller517
offline
Link
 
Thread locked by moderator.
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.