To figure out exactly what the offensive settings were, I set each down for each quarter to 100% default to one particular type of play, giving me 16 specific play types. This way I could find out what happens when I am SURE I ask for a short pass, long pass, inside rush, etc. aWhat did I find out?
Note: I have looked at where the receiver was where he caught the ball, or where he was when the ball was inc... not how long the pass was.
Short Pass yards: 6.5, 7, -2, -1, 8, 20(!), 3, 5, 5, 2, -1
Medium Pass yards: 6, 9.5, 11, 3, 2, 3, 11, 7, 3, 2, 6, 8.5
Long: Sack, 8, 9, 11.
The other interesting thing was looking at formations. The computer LOVES the shotgun. I wonder if it selects that based on distance to 1st? The number of wrs sent into the pattern doesn't seem to depend on how long the pattern is at all. We had 'short' passes dialed in with 4 going out into the pattern and long out of the I. It also doesn't pay a lot of attention to the settings... some but not much. The 20 yard pass when we requested a short for example, wasn't nice. All WRs were running Go routes... nobody COULD have been short except a HB.
Rushing. This was a bit disturbing:
Inside rushes - 'Inside' basically means "THOU SHALT RUSH FROM THE I" Every one was from the I formation. It does not mean the run will stay in the middle, but it will probably go to the A or B gaps.
Off Tackle rushes - Same thing as an Inside rush, but from an offset I.
Pitch/Sweep: Seems broken. We ran this 4 times and only once did we actually RUN. we passed 3 times, once with a 5 wide set. The time we ran, we ran up the middle. I triple checked my settings to make sure and I am positive I had this set right.
Outside Run: The misdirection setting. Every time we ran this we lined up in the offset I, and did a sort of option where the QB ran with the RB for a little bit before pitching it, OR the QB ran one direction, the HB the other with a pitch to the HB going the opposite direction. VERY slow to develop. Disaster almost every time. Worthless against a decent opponent IMO.
Random Run: A smattering of pitches and inside rushes. What you'd expect.
Goal Line: I experimented with the goal line O in non-goal line situations to see if the D would adjust. It did. Good to know in situations where we will want to go for it on 4th and inches.
All in all, I'm not impressed with the advanced settings and think they will only really be helpful in specific situations. Folks wanting to gameplan the entire field are going to be disappointed I think.
I suggest everybody throws away a preseason game to find out for themselves... and it'd be awful nice if you'd post the results here so we can figure out what it is we're dealing with. I'd sure like to start winning and losing games based on my ability to diagnose what my team should do, rather than deal with whatever randomness the computer throws my way.
Note: I have looked at where the receiver was where he caught the ball, or where he was when the ball was inc... not how long the pass was.
Short Pass yards: 6.5, 7, -2, -1, 8, 20(!), 3, 5, 5, 2, -1
Medium Pass yards: 6, 9.5, 11, 3, 2, 3, 11, 7, 3, 2, 6, 8.5
Long: Sack, 8, 9, 11.
The other interesting thing was looking at formations. The computer LOVES the shotgun. I wonder if it selects that based on distance to 1st? The number of wrs sent into the pattern doesn't seem to depend on how long the pattern is at all. We had 'short' passes dialed in with 4 going out into the pattern and long out of the I. It also doesn't pay a lot of attention to the settings... some but not much. The 20 yard pass when we requested a short for example, wasn't nice. All WRs were running Go routes... nobody COULD have been short except a HB.
Rushing. This was a bit disturbing:
Inside rushes - 'Inside' basically means "THOU SHALT RUSH FROM THE I" Every one was from the I formation. It does not mean the run will stay in the middle, but it will probably go to the A or B gaps.
Off Tackle rushes - Same thing as an Inside rush, but from an offset I.
Pitch/Sweep: Seems broken. We ran this 4 times and only once did we actually RUN. we passed 3 times, once with a 5 wide set. The time we ran, we ran up the middle. I triple checked my settings to make sure and I am positive I had this set right.
Outside Run: The misdirection setting. Every time we ran this we lined up in the offset I, and did a sort of option where the QB ran with the RB for a little bit before pitching it, OR the QB ran one direction, the HB the other with a pitch to the HB going the opposite direction. VERY slow to develop. Disaster almost every time. Worthless against a decent opponent IMO.
Random Run: A smattering of pitches and inside rushes. What you'd expect.
Goal Line: I experimented with the goal line O in non-goal line situations to see if the D would adjust. It did. Good to know in situations where we will want to go for it on 4th and inches.
All in all, I'm not impressed with the advanced settings and think they will only really be helpful in specific situations. Folks wanting to gameplan the entire field are going to be disappointed I think.
I suggest everybody throws away a preseason game to find out for themselves... and it'd be awful nice if you'd post the results here so we can figure out what it is we're dealing with. I'd sure like to start winning and losing games based on my ability to diagnose what my team should do, rather than deal with whatever randomness the computer throws my way.
Last edited Jul 29, 2008 18:57:39






























