We have multiple players on the depth chart at each position WR1, WR2, etc. but our first string WRs played every play at WR1 & WR2. We have two QBs that are the same level, so they have been splitting time. Today, the "first stringer" played every play.
Forum > Discuss GLB Issues With Catch22 > NOT A BUG - CLOSED > In-game energy turned off for scrimmages?
czman
offline
offline
A lot of teams did not put together long drives in these games so if your energy settings are low your players might not have subbed often enough. My team subbed correctly but we ran a high sub rate.
Juan Fiddy
offline
offline
Your charts are wrong.
If you put any player(s) into the 1-5 DC, then the sim will ignore the base depth chart and use only the listed player(s) at that slot. So, because you only put one player each in the 1-5 slots then those players played their respective positions exclusively without subbing.
If you are going to use the 1-5 you need put depth into each slot, with possible exception to 4-5 due to the fact those plays don't get called as often.
You can also leave any 1-5 slot BLANK, and then it will populate with standard rotation based off the basic depth chart for the position.
If you put any player(s) into the 1-5 DC, then the sim will ignore the base depth chart and use only the listed player(s) at that slot. So, because you only put one player each in the 1-5 slots then those players played their respective positions exclusively without subbing.
If you are going to use the 1-5 you need put depth into each slot, with possible exception to 4-5 due to the fact those plays don't get called as often.
You can also leave any 1-5 slot BLANK, and then it will populate with standard rotation based off the basic depth chart for the position.
Arles
offline
offline
I posted this on the GLB forum. The worst issue seemed to be my 28 stamina LT getting all 64 snaps with a 85-90 sub rate. Also, it seems that the sub rates aren't saving for the generic WR and CB lines. So, if you didn't stagger your WR1, WR2, WR3 spots with multiple players, I *think* it was using your defaults for WR (which is often 45-65).
----
Anyone have an issue with few backups playing in the scrimmage? I can't see energy, so I can't really tell if it's just a high stamina thing. Still, here's Lost City's boxscore:
http://goallineblitz.com/game/game.pl?game_id=81407
Issue 1:
I checked the tactics and it looks like it doesn't allow me to set sub ins and outs for generic WR or CB (not WR1 or CB1). I put it a number (ie, 70-80) and it goes back to blank after saving. So, I'm guessing that goes to the default. Seems like we need to put multiple guys on the WR1, WR2, .. and CB1, CB2 to combat this. As it was, my starting WRs played 62 of the 64 plays. My starting corners played all 78 plays.
Issue 2: Offensive sub rates not related to WR
My HB played 52 of our 64 plays with sub rate set to 70-82. My TE played 61 of our 64 plays with sub rate set to 70-82.
My starting RT tackle and Center played all 64 plays with sub rate set to 70-82.
**Worrisome one: My LT played all 64 plays with a sub rate set to 85-90. He only has 28 stamina, there's no way he should be above 85 after 50 plays.
issue 3: Defensive sub rates not related to CB
MLB played 73/78 defensive plays with mid 30s stamina and 70-80 settings. Last season, he would have been pulled by play 50 and it would have been more 55-23 (not 73-5) on plays with him and backup.
DE set to 65-75 with 37 stamina and had 53/78 plays. I get that DEs take more pounding, but it seems wierd that with a lower sub rate, the DE with more stamina plays in 20 fewer plays than the MLB.
Hypothesis:
First, it seems that the WR and CB rates don't save in tactics, so it uses your defaults. Solution seems to be to stagger the WR1, WR2, WR3 guys with multiple entries per spot OR raise your main defaults to what you want for WR and CB and set everyone else. This may be why the low completion %s are out there. Maybe the WRs are getting gassed.
Second, it seems like OL just aren't losing any energy (or the game thinks they are not). The fact that my LT with 28 stamina plays all 64 plays with an 85 sub out rate and my 37 stamina DE with 65 sub out rate plays just 53/78 seems odd to me. Maybe the OL is just punishing the DEs and staying fresher.
Maybe stamina/energy is less of an issue in scrimmages. I just would like to get a better idea of where to set my guys for the season as I have some 60-40 spots and having the starter (with low stamina) get 98% of the snaps with 85-90 seems odd.
----
Anyone have an issue with few backups playing in the scrimmage? I can't see energy, so I can't really tell if it's just a high stamina thing. Still, here's Lost City's boxscore:
http://goallineblitz.com/game/game.pl?game_id=81407
Issue 1:
I checked the tactics and it looks like it doesn't allow me to set sub ins and outs for generic WR or CB (not WR1 or CB1). I put it a number (ie, 70-80) and it goes back to blank after saving. So, I'm guessing that goes to the default. Seems like we need to put multiple guys on the WR1, WR2, .. and CB1, CB2 to combat this. As it was, my starting WRs played 62 of the 64 plays. My starting corners played all 78 plays.
Issue 2: Offensive sub rates not related to WR
My HB played 52 of our 64 plays with sub rate set to 70-82. My TE played 61 of our 64 plays with sub rate set to 70-82.
My starting RT tackle and Center played all 64 plays with sub rate set to 70-82.
**Worrisome one: My LT played all 64 plays with a sub rate set to 85-90. He only has 28 stamina, there's no way he should be above 85 after 50 plays.
issue 3: Defensive sub rates not related to CB
MLB played 73/78 defensive plays with mid 30s stamina and 70-80 settings. Last season, he would have been pulled by play 50 and it would have been more 55-23 (not 73-5) on plays with him and backup.
DE set to 65-75 with 37 stamina and had 53/78 plays. I get that DEs take more pounding, but it seems wierd that with a lower sub rate, the DE with more stamina plays in 20 fewer plays than the MLB.
Hypothesis:
First, it seems that the WR and CB rates don't save in tactics, so it uses your defaults. Solution seems to be to stagger the WR1, WR2, WR3 guys with multiple entries per spot OR raise your main defaults to what you want for WR and CB and set everyone else. This may be why the low completion %s are out there. Maybe the WRs are getting gassed.
Second, it seems like OL just aren't losing any energy (or the game thinks they are not). The fact that my LT with 28 stamina plays all 64 plays with an 85 sub out rate and my 37 stamina DE with 65 sub out rate plays just 53/78 seems odd to me. Maybe the OL is just punishing the DEs and staying fresher.
Maybe stamina/energy is less of an issue in scrimmages. I just would like to get a better idea of where to set my guys for the season as I have some 60-40 spots and having the starter (with low stamina) get 98% of the snaps with 85-90 seems odd.
Juan Fiddy
offline
offline
Same issue, your charts are wrong. 1-5 need to be populated with backups or left blank. If you have only one player in any 1-5 slot the sim will disregard the basic depth by design.
Carpy
offline
offline
The WR issue, I agree that is rectifiable with learning of the new depth chart arrangements.
QB, O-Line and RB were entirely different to the rotation we say last season.
Not a huge issue, because hopefully with adjusting the sub settings you can manage to get the outcome you want, but it is tough when you recruit back-ups with the promise of decent playing time and they check the result to see their guy got 11 plays (or in the case of the back-up QB - zero)
QB, O-Line and RB were entirely different to the rotation we say last season.
Not a huge issue, because hopefully with adjusting the sub settings you can manage to get the outcome you want, but it is tough when you recruit back-ups with the promise of decent playing time and they check the result to see their guy got 11 plays (or in the case of the back-up QB - zero)
Grimmer
offline
offline
czman - While that may be the case, that means the in-game energy is very minimal compared to what it used to be. The longest drives we had were 10 plays and/or 4 minutes or so. You would think that at some point in there someone would get tired. I'm worried that if I up the replacement level, they'll "fix" it so that people actually get tired some during the game and then I'll have backups in most of the time.
Juan - If you read my original post, you'll see that I stated we DO HAVE multiple players at each position (WR1, WR2, etc.) on the depth chart and the 2nd player in the WR1 slot did not take a snap at the WR1 slot. That is the reason I mentioned the same thing happening to our QBs... the first played the entire game and the backup sat the bench.
Originally posted by Arles
I just would like to get a better idea of where to set my guys for the season as I have some 60-40 spots and having the starter (with low stamina) get 98% of the snaps with 85-90 seems odd.
That's exactly my concern for our QB position.
Juan - If you read my original post, you'll see that I stated we DO HAVE multiple players at each position (WR1, WR2, etc.) on the depth chart and the 2nd player in the WR1 slot did not take a snap at the WR1 slot. That is the reason I mentioned the same thing happening to our QBs... the first played the entire game and the backup sat the bench.
Originally posted by Arles
I just would like to get a better idea of where to set my guys for the season as I have some 60-40 spots and having the starter (with low stamina) get 98% of the snaps with 85-90 seems odd.
That's exactly my concern for our QB position.
Juan Fiddy
offline
offline
For the QB, we had the same situation where our backup got only 9 snaps, but the play calling was similarly run heavy.
I can't say I'm seeing anything too out of the ordinary for the line based on STA, but on the other hand we absolutely owned the clock and I would have assumed the rotation would have been a bit deeper.
I can't say I'm seeing anything too out of the ordinary for the line based on STA, but on the other hand we absolutely owned the clock and I would have assumed the rotation would have been a bit deeper.
Juan Fiddy
offline
offline
Originally posted by Grimmer
Juan - If you read my original post, you'll see that I stated we DO HAVE multiple players at each position (WR1, WR2, etc.) on the depth chart and the 2nd player in the WR1 slot did not take a snap at the WR1 slot. That is the reason I mentioned the same thing happening to our QBs... the first played the entire game and the backup sat the bench.
I was looking at Forbidden City, I assumed that was the team you were talking about.
Juan - If you read my original post, you'll see that I stated we DO HAVE multiple players at each position (WR1, WR2, etc.) on the depth chart and the 2nd player in the WR1 slot did not take a snap at the WR1 slot. That is the reason I mentioned the same thing happening to our QBs... the first played the entire game and the backup sat the bench.
I was looking at Forbidden City, I assumed that was the team you were talking about.
Grimmer
offline
offline
Scratch that (and apologies), now that I look again, apparently the backups at WR1, etc. were removed from the depth chart at some point since I looked last night. I'm not sure when this happened, but that explains the WRx positions to some extent. The QB position does still have 2 on the depth chart, though, and got all 70 plays.
Juan Fiddy
offline
offline
Our backup for the #1 WR slot, who also pulled 3rd in line at #3 and 4th in line on the basic chart with the #2 slot empty, got 41 snaps. He does play kick return, which accounted for 7 of those snaps.
Juan Fiddy
offline
offline
I am wondering if some energy changes have been made though, last season we would have seen alot more action from our backup QB, as is intended. And my line cycled a little shy of what I would have expected.
Arles
offline
offline
Again, my big concern is a LT with 28 stamina getting all 64 plays with a 85-90 setup for sub rate.
Last edited Jul 29, 2008 13:56:06
Gyuri1
offline
offline
In the same game as the one Arles mentioned (but the opposing team), we had our starting FS get 58 of the 63 defensive plays, though he was playing on "hard" intensity and we had an 80-85 sub percentage. Though he has relatively high stamina (36), our players in similar circumstances last season would rarely get more than 3/5s of the plays, let alone 87% as in this case.
You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.






























