User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > Give standard XP for playoff players
Page:
 
Rage Kinard
offline
Link
 
Since players in playoffs have to train on normal and relaxed to keep energy up, while a player not in playoffs can slowly build energy on intense training as long as cash is available, it puts playoff players at a very slight disadvantage.

How about awarding a small amount of XP for players in playoffs. Maybe 50 XP for starters and 25 XP for backups. Or 50 XP if player is in more than 30 plays, 25 XP if player is in less than 30 plays.
 
StuckN85
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Rage Kinard
Since players in playoffs have to train on normal and relaxed to keep energy up, while a player not in playoffs can slowly build energy on intense training as long as cash is available, it puts playoff players at a very slight disadvantage.


Good question. Why are playoff players penalized?

Edit: Missing quote braces
Last edited Apr 14, 2008 02:34:08
 
FairForever
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by StuckN85
Originally posted by Rage Kinard

Since players in playoffs have to train on normal and relaxed to keep energy up, while a player not in playoffs can slowly build energy on intense training as long as cash is available, it puts playoff players at a very slight disadvantage.


Good question. Why are playoff players penalized?


Dude, intense training is overrated. Over 8 days (considering the team makes it to the championship game), you lose one whole stat point by training on relaxed rather than intense. Whoop de doo. You also get to pay thousands more in training fees. I don't see what the fuss is about.
 
seanman
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by FairForever

Dude, intense training is overrated. Over 8 days (considering the team makes it to the championship game), you lose one whole stat point by training on relaxed rather than intense. Whoop de doo. You also get to pay thousands more in training fees. I don't see what the fuss is about.
I agree, most people don't have the money to train on intense anyway, not for the whole offseason at least
Last edited Apr 14, 2008 02:40:35
 
Rage Kinard
offline
Link
 
you get paid while playoffs are going on, even if your player is not on a playoff team.

I have 2 players, 1 in the playoffs, 1 not. Both are still getting paid. The one not in the playoffs is still getting paid, and it is more than cost of training on intense. It won't be by end of season, but he will have enough cash to train on intense over offseason as long as it doesn't go beyond 5 days.


I know it isn't that much of an advantage, but it is a slight one. At least the player has the choice. I don't see how 50 XP per game is that big a deal. It is only 400 total if a player makes it all the way to championship.

Players don't get any other bonus for playing in championship either. No FP, no extra cash. There should be some small bonus.
 
Link
 
How can you think its not a big deal..Its plain and simple..Teams that make the playoffs, all those players get an XP advantage and the the teams in the playoffs dont need an advantage.

I agree there should be some small bonus but XP should never be concidred for aplyoff teams.Thats just unfair..
 
Link
 
I think it's really dumb to not get XP in the playoffs...
 
k2skier
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by GothamKnight33
I think it's really dumb to not get XP in the playoffs...


why should the successful/rich get richer, or why would one want to create a larger separation in talent/xp levels?

just doesn't make sense if one wants this to be competitive for the long run...
Last edited Apr 14, 2008 12:27:24
 
Pumchavas28
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by seanman
Originally posted by FairForever


Dude, intense training is overrated. Over 8 days (considering the team makes it to the championship game), you lose one whole stat point by training on relaxed rather than intense. Whoop de doo. You also get to pay thousands more in training fees. I don't see what the fuss is about.
I agree, most people don't have the money to train on intense anyway, not for the whole offseason at least


And then those idiots go and hammer their Owners for more cash so they can continue training on INtense...

Me, I train on Normal & Relaxed... nothing else... I don't even look at Intense anymore... Just not worth it..
 
Keith Wheeler
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by k2skier
Originally posted by GothamKnight33

I think it's really dumb to not get XP in the playoffs...


why should the successful/rich get richer, or why would one want to create a larger separation in talent/xp levels?

just doesn't make sense if one wants this to be competitive for the long run...


man this is one of the weakest arguements someone can come up with... oh the rich will only get richer. How about finding a solution rather than going for the "my self-esteem will take a hit" approach. I know the NFL has the draft, maybe there could be a system where the FA are put into a draft so those that made it to the playoffs can get some benefit rather tham having the soccer mom approach of " every kid gets a snack and a ribbon for showing up."
 
ripgressor
offline
Link
 
Great reply Keith, LOL
 
naki
offline
Link
 
You forget that the teams that will benefit most will also move up to a tougher league. It seems like the best teams will end up playing in the top leagues. After that at some point it may become to expensive to pay players when they get too good. Maybe a salary cap would help. XP for playoffs seems fair, even if it is at half the normal rate.
 
Malachorn
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by k2skier
just doesn't make sense if one wants this to be competitive for the long run...


Yeah, but k2skier wins because he's shown he's actually able to think about consequence and probability of future events.
 
Malachorn
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by naki
You forget that the teams that will benefit most will also move up to a tougher league.


No, the top teams have to be considered the most here if we're talking about the consequence and result from giving regular playoff XP.

The top teams will still be the pro league. Even more, there's a possibility of a champion not being able to be brought down from the championship league.

The teams that are trying to make it up to the pro league? Not as much of an issue here. The issue has to be the few top teams in all the pro leagues that will make it almost impossible for anyone else to ever "crack" them and their impervious shell of extra levels gained from playoffs.
 
MEPT72
offline
Link
 
Instead of rich getting richer how about rewarding those who did well enough to make the playoffs?
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.