User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > Change Security settings to not be just IP
Melancholy
offline
Link
 
I carry a laptop to and from work, and while my IP is changing, my computer is not. I understand the desire to implement this change, but I feel that these days a lot more people use laptops and will be using the same computer with multiple IPs.

It'd be nice if instead of being connected to IP, the system just allowed a user to be logged in from one machine, and every login invalidated previous sessions. For instance, keep a session id per user that is encrypted in the user's cookie. then when a user logs in, increment the user's session id and any session that reports its session_id as lower than expected would be considered invalid.
 
Taylor36
offline
Link
 
Wha?
 
duckylove
offline
Link
 
is it realy that hard to re-logon when you get home?
 
Wanderer
offline
Link
 
More GLB security = GOOD THING.
 
Melancholy
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by duckylove
is it realy that hard to re-logon when you get home?


not at all, but if I leave myself logged on at home, I won't ever get logged out. If I use the same computer all the time, regardless of my ip, it seems reasonable to allow me to do it. and, as I described, the solution isn't all that difficult.

As for the more security thing, I really haven't asked them to reduce it, just to make it more intelligent.
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
That would work, but it doesn't really address the problem I'm trying to solve. It's much easier to spoof a session id in a cookie than it is to spoof your IP address. If I get ahold of your session id cookies I can log in as you until you log in again or your session id expires.
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
If I'm going to get rid of IP checking, we'll have to change to a session that expires after an hour or something like that.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Melancholy
I carry a laptop to and from work, and while my IP is changing, my computer is not. I understand the desire to implement this change, but I feel that these days a lot more people use laptops and will be using the same computer with multiple IPs.

It'd be nice if instead of being connected to IP, the system just allowed a user to be logged in from one machine, and every login invalidated previous sessions. For instance, keep a session id per user that is encrypted in the user's cookie. then when a user logs in, increment the user's session id and any session that reports its session_id as lower than expected would be considered invalid.


So if I stay logged in at home and try to use my comp at work it wont let me in????


Get firefox and use the remember password feature it has!

 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.