North Shore Sharks and Mississipi Rebels? wtf...I was hoping to draw a couple of quality teams to test out the new AI..instead I get to play a few friendlies against the local high school teams...
totally serious...the Sharks aren't TOO bad..they are only 5 levels behind our players..if they all boost maybe the scrimmage will have some value. The Rebels are a totally gutted CPU team..I'm not gonna learn anything from that game.
IMO this league has been totally watered down this season...I count 11 squads who are either in a rebuilding stage or just straight out don't have the personell to compete on this level. We should have been able to pick our own scrimmages...
How is it that you can't learn anything from a scrimmage against anyone? The games are designed to help you learn the advanced offensive and defensive AI. What matters is whether or not the plays are called the way you want them to be called - not whether or not the play is successful or not.
Sure - maybe you won't get put in many 4th down situations by a CPU team. The Sharks game will get you that. If you didn't want to outlevel the Sharks so badly, your team shouldn't have insta-boosted today?
Originally posted by RunningMn9 How is it that you can't learn anything from a scrimmage against anyone? The games are designed to help you learn the advanced offensive and defensive AI. What matters is whether or not the plays are called the way you want them to be called - not whether or not the play is successful or not.
Sure - maybe you won't get put in many 4th down situations by a CPU team. The Sharks game will get you that. If you didn't want to outlevel the Sharks so badly, your team shouldn't have insta-boosted today?
Are we gonna argue about this? lol
Ok..I don't learn very much about a scrimmage against a gutted team because every offense play I'm going to run is going to work...I'm going to be up 255-0, every offensive possesion will go 3-4 plays then a TD. Every defense I run is going to stop them. I have built a complete defensive and offensive AI..I didn't take what was there and tweak it..I deleted everything and built it from the ground up. I need to know if it's effective and if not what needs fixing...having the offensive and defensive plays seem overly effective because we are playing a gutted team teaches me nothing. I won't be in third and long...I won't need to go into my red zone offense...you get the picture.
The sharks team...yeah, they will be a better test...but I was hoping to pull at least an equivalent team to scrimmage against so that I could know where we were truly at with our squad.
As far as the insta-boost...with the new AI I need all of the players being their true selves...so I understand if my AI is working. I am going to be rolling with these players, all boosted..for the next 40 days, having them perform an exhibition of my AI Schemes at 3 levels below what they will be when the season starts is useless info too.
The Pain, The Wolves, The Gold and the Bisons are getting a great preseason round robbining each other, so I understand why you are cool...and I get the Sharks and Rebels? WTF...
I don't think you understand what the preseason games are for. And regardless of WHY you boosted before the preseason games - you can't complain that everyone else is smart enough to wait.
And it doesn't matter who we drew for the preseason games. I'm not approaching them to see whether my AI works because it's irrelevant whether or not my AI works. As long as the plays are called according to the way I want them to be called (and I already know that they might now because of the random number generator) - that's what they are for.
If it was 3rd and 7 on the opponents 23 yard line - was an appropriate play called or not? If so - great. If not - booo. Whether the play was a success or not is irrelevant. I'm not trying to beat the Werewolves or the Gold, so it's not going to help them that much that they are playing against me.
Scrimmage games aren't for much, but to build more money for your team anyways. I mean we drew Columbus AGAIN! we played them last season in the scrimmage after the conference finals. Personally I could care less who we play, because we aren't going to do the same thing in a regular game then we did in the scrimmage.
They don't count against you, and personally as long as we make it to the playoffs I don't care what our record is. Not looking forward to playing your team this year RunningMn9, but will be a hell of a season once again as the AA#2 is getting tougher every season.
We are speaking two different languages my friend.
You are saying that the Preseason games are to make sure you didn't screw anything up in your AI - Like Punting on 2nd and 6, or sending everybody on long routes 1st and goal from the 1.
Like I said, I didn't just tweak settings...I deleted everything and built offensive and defensive schemes based on NFL playbooks. I need to know if they will work in the GLB sim..and yeah, along the way if we are passing to the FB every down cuz I screwed up a setting, I can fix that too..but the important thing is to TEST OUT the AI...not test my ability not to screw up basic tactical settings.
I was just making a point..and no, it's not smart to wait to boost until after the preseason games..it serves absolutely no purpose. If you are going to purchase a Corvette, do you test drive a malibu first to make sure you know how to turn and hit the brakes?
I know how to turn son..I need to know how this corvette rides before I roll off the lot..
No, you didn't delete everything and build offensive schemes based on NFL playbooks. Until the Advanced offensive AI allows me to choose formations and alter my depth chart based on formation and game situation, you can't build an offensive scheme based on an NFL playbook.
Defensively, you can do more - but even then - with the offense being unable to specify formation and specific players - an NFL playbook is going to be worthless. Moreso when there is no reason to suspect that the sim will sim things correctly the way they would work in the NFL.
I'm not your son. And in your analogy, you can't even be sure that you're buying a CAR, let alone a Corvette right now. I will be *shocked* if the advanced AI improves the game offensively or defensively. *SHOCKED*.
you can still learn a lot from it, watching the plays who covers where and how. Or on the offense who blocks what where the ball gets touched and where they go. That is by far the most important info to be gained out of this. once I know what players go where and how they act in the new AI that is all I need I could run against a lvl 1 team and it wouldn't matter. It shows you where the ball is touched and you figure out if you are weak or strong there vs another team.
Originally posted by RunningMn9 No, you didn't delete everything and build offensive schemes based on NFL playbooks. Until the Advanced offensive AI allows me to choose formations and alter my depth chart based on formation and game situation, you can't build an offensive scheme based on an NFL playbook.
Defensively, you can do more - but even then - with the offense being unable to specify formation and specific players - an NFL playbook is going to be worthless. Moreso when there is no reason to suspect that the sim will sim things correctly the way they would work in the NFL.
I'm not your son. And in your analogy, you can't even be sure that you're buying a CAR, let alone a Corvette right now. I will be *shocked* if the advanced AI improves the game offensively or defensively. *SHOCKED*.
No point in really arguing with you, but I will say that with the tools that have been given to you, you should be able to at least simulate the general tactics of a pro-style offense and defense. Admittedly, it's very rigid..no audibles, no motion, there are only so many given plays that we all have to work with...you can't always specify exactly who's in, because players sub out and in. But with some imagination you should be able to take the general philosophy of a professionally built Offense or Defense along with some of it's core plays and tendencies and be able to mirror that here.
If you plan to stick with the basic offensive and defensive tactics tools we've been using so far, that's cool..but I do think there are alot of stinker plays in there..and you could at least use the AI to weed those out. That's the bare minimum use for the AI.
I'd be more then happy to play the Pain in a couple of friendlies this year once that option is available, just so you can see what the IED is up to this year...
Originally posted by hellbound201 you can still learn a lot from it, watching the plays who covers where and how. Or on the offense who blocks what where the ball gets touched and where they go. That is by far the most important info to be gained out of this. once I know what players go where and how they act in the new AI that is all I need I could run against a lvl 1 team and it wouldn't matter. It shows you where the ball is touched and you figure out if you are weak or strong there vs another team.
I guess it is good for just seeing what's going on assignment and formation-wise and making sure you didn't make any input errors...but I was just hoping to see if mine actually "worked"...but you and runningmn are right in that respect, even against a gutted team, there is something to be learned I guess.
Originally posted by BP If you plan to stick with the basic offensive and defensive tactics tools we've been using so far, that's cool..but I do think there are alot of stinker plays in there..and you could at least use the AI to weed those out. That's the bare minimum use for the AI.
I'd be more then happy to play the Pain in a couple of friendlies this year once that option is available, just so you can see what the IED is up to this year...
I didn't say that I planned to stick with anything. I'm well aware of what the basic AI does well, and what it flubs, and I have my ideas on how to remove the flubs and maximize what it does well. Those ideas will be proven right or wrong in the sim I suppose.
Regardless, I'm not familiar with any NFL playbook or offensive philosophy that doesn't allow me to specify offensive formations, pass routes, etc. Until that's in this game, the most you can accomplish is a Basic AI that makes fewer mistakes than it currently makes.
You're deluding yourself if you think you're doing anything more.
And I have no desire to play the IED in a friendly matchup. If we play, it will be in the Championship game.
IMO this league has been totally watered down this season...I count 11 squads who are either in a rebuilding stage or just straight out don't have the personell to compete on this level. We should have been able to pick our own scrimmages...
Well, us gutted teams have to play someone. I'm sure a lot of us would prefer to not be in this league, too. I know my team took a vote on moving down so we could rebuild and most of us were in favor of it. Then we're told by support we have to stay here. So, we're building for next season now and pretty much understand this year isn't a playoff season and never was going to be after a total reboot of the franchise. I understand you'd like to face good teams but it's not really the fault of the people cleaning up the messes that this is what you're left to face. Play your backups in those games if you're so worried about crushing them 255-0. If your backups execute the game plans well then obviously your better players would do just as well, no?