User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > What sense is it that the best teams only have 1 person on the depth chart.
Page:
 
ohmybriguy
offline
Link
 
For a game that is trying to attract people and new players, why is it that it that the teams are better off to not have good depth and rotations during a game. I cam to the conclusion that i had to cut almost 60% of my team, cause all the best teams only have 1 or 2 players at most for positions. It penalizes teams who sign young and new players or players who cannot find teams. Am i wrong in my thinking?

Just cant figure out why it would be better to only have 2 DE's play during a game when in the NFL they are always rotating players to get fresh legs.
 
scarletmbb
offline
Link
 
Yeah, I think that's why the admins are putting in an injury component into this game, which is going to indirectly penalize the teams that have short benches. Hopefully that will even things out. I have to keep reminding myself that this is a beta version, haha.
 
Coach Greedy
offline
Link
 
But from what I have read the injury's wont even keep them out of 1 single game, just reduce their stats for a while, This is weak and unrealistic. The best teams should have strength in depth and need it to win, but as you say the top teams only have a skeleton crew.

I understand why the developers are worried about keeping a player out injured for a period of time, but thats real life. Players should be able to pick up injury`s that mean they miss various amounts of game time, and if they don't get the injury treated, which will cost $ then the injury may well return.

Look how many QB`s went down this season in the NFL and back ups and veterans had to step in, and look at what an impact that had on the league. This way owners will need to sign 2 maybe 3 QB`s. So in the long run the developers get even more people playing at a competitive level.
 
ohmybriguy
offline
Link
 
I think something that might help is a fatigue setting. Where if you only have 1 qb on the roster, It would be like only having 1 qb throw every pass in practice. If you only have 1 HB, he would have to play everysingle play and wear themselves out during non game days. Injurys should only take a guy out a game or so. Or, if they get hurt lower there stats for a longer period of time.

Maybe a energy penalty for players playing a bunch of plays in a row. Simulating a long drive by an offense. (Would not apply to QB's, and Oline, since they hardly ever sub out in a real nfl game)
 
CONN CHRIS
offline
Link
 
Check these guys out:

http://goallineblitz.com/game/depth_chart.pl?team_id=10

It's just someone gaming the system. More power to them. The rules will change and they'll have to come up with a different plan.

The team that I am a part of is pretty deep at all positions. We all get playing time but not an un-realistic amount and we all have a heck of a lot of fun. We'll be fine when/if the one-deep depth chart issue is addressed and we're fine now.
 
ShamsTron
offline
Link
 
They must have to have their stamina jacked to be able to pull that off.
 
MrFreeze
offline
Link
 
I also think the only QB on the team should loose some confidence when his team is losing. He don`t have the backup QB(s) to talk things over ingame and after the game. And really should take the loss on his shoulders.
 
ohmybriguy
offline
Link
 
i'm right with ya Conn... but my point is, i had a ton of depth and good players all around and we couldn't win. The post was here to help contribute to the rules change... cause right now i just cut 60% of my team hopeing we can win half our games next year.
 
ohmybriguy
offline
Link
 
Thats a good idea MrFreeze... it should be like that with all the positions. Players get boosts from better backups sitting on the bench behind them to help with game plans or whatnot
 
MrFreeze
offline
Link
 
Yupp, and more/better effect from training too, when you have a healthy squad/roster. Need people to get some good practice(s).
 
scarletmbb
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by MrFreeze
I also think the only QB on the team should loose some confidence when his team is losing. He don`t have the backup QB(s) to talk things over ingame and after the game. And really should take the loss on his shoulders.


Yeah, I definitely agree that there should be some inherent benefit to having a back-up. Another thing they should do and it's been brought up is lowering the # of plays it takes to max out the experience. Right now it's at 90 plays, which just encourages a smaller team. If they cut it in half, the benefits of having less people will be purely monetary.
 
cajik
offline
Link
 
The other reason to have depth on your team is in case one of them goes inactive. Then you still have another guy who is similar level and you won't lose much.

Having the 1 deep depth chart also means they have to jack up their stamina otherwise at the end of the game they will not be effective.
 
ohmybriguy
offline
Link
 
yeah, i'm not sure how high their stamina is, but i've never seen a RB play every single down in a game IRL.
 
JeffHCross
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by ShamsTron
They must have to have their stamina jacked to be able to pull that off.
I don't think they have to. We played another team with few guys on the depth chart, and they seemed to actually get better as the game went on. It's almost like a low-energy but *better* player will still be better than a fully rested lower-level player.

Plus, the game has some really strange results from Depth Charts and Stamina.

Lvl 8 DT w/29 stamina. Two people on the depth chart. He plays 45 plays, and after the game has 71 energy.
Lvl 8 LB w/25 stamina. Only player at MLB on the depth chart. Plays 70 plays, and has 73 energy. And by far had the best stats on the defense.

That doesn't add up.
Last edited Apr 13, 2008 14:48:02
 
CONN CHRIS
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by ohmybriguy
yeah, i'm not sure how high their stamina is, but i've never seen a RB play every single down in a game IRL.



It can easily be solved by making a certain depth at each position mandatory for a line-up to be valid prior to game time.

Our team (OOTP Ballers in the Canadian AAA) is very deep but I would expect the mandatory depth to be somewhere between Dryden (in our league but set up just like the link to Detroit above) and us.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.