User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > XP Penalties for Detrimental/Harmful Plays on the field - another must add
SAGA45
offline
Link
 
First, check out my previous suggestion thread on adding a XP Bonus System for Impact Plays made on the field: http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=63851

Now, allow me to also suggest an XP Penalty for Detrimental or Harmful Plays on the field like: ints thrown, sacks allowed, fumbles, dropped passes, penalties (i.e offsides, holding, facemask), etc.

This punishes players for poor and undisciplined play, balances the rewards from the XP Bonus System, and expands the depth of gameplay. Also, as was the case with the XP Bonus system, player customization and roster management are enhanced.

Lastly, if the XP Bonus and Penalty systems are added, then I'd suggest some sort of post-game or 'last game' XP Report in the player's profile:


DT Bubble Gutz

Snaps Played (+100)

Impact Plays (+40):
--3 sacks: +30
--1 forced fumble: +10

Harmful Plays(-10):
--1 offsides: -5
--1 facemask: -5
---------------------
Total XP earned: 130

Don't get caught up in the XP values illustrated here. This is just a rough example. But I think you guys get what I'm saying.

Thoughts?

Last edited Apr 12, 2008 09:20:09
 
Rick James18
offline
Link
 
I agree with both.
 
DiMo28
offline
Link
 
You learn just as much from mistakes (maybe more) as you do with good plays. Experience entails all, not just the good.
 
HustonJ
offline
Link
 
As a matter of fact, many of the greatest men in American history have been adamant that THEY learned more from mistakes and failures than they did from successes.

You know, people like Edison.

So, you have the XP modifiers BACKWARDS.

You learn less from having things work as planned and expected than you do from having things go wrong.

Now, a small morale boost from having things go perfectly according to plan might not be a bad idea.
 
SAGA45
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by HustonJ
you have the XP modifiers BACKWARDS.


Actually, I have them right.

It's simple...players are rewarded for impact plays and penalized for harmful plays. It's balanced.

Originally posted by HustonJ

You learn less from having things work as planned and expected than you do from having things go wrong


But we both know from watching football that players, no matter how experienced, still make the same mistakes...many of them fundamental. If they didn't there'd be absolutely no reason whatsoever for repetitious drills in practice. That's why IMO the XP Penalty/Bonus system, if implemented, would add a LOT more realism and depth to GBL.
Last edited Apr 12, 2008 12:35:33
 
oldskool
offline
Link
 
It's still unbalanced. New players are going to make tons of mistakes and cost themselves XP while lacking the physical abilities to realistically produce enough "Impact plays" to get the XP bonuses, while the 'old guard' will have it the other way round (that is, they have the skills to make a lot of impact plays and are experienced enough to not make a ton of boneheaded plays, greatly accelerating their own XPing).

It will slow down leveling of new players (bad, newbies want to level and be competitive, not be trapped at level 1 for a week because their player's a numbskull) and speed up leveling of old players (also bad, old players already have the advantage of experience & better stats over the new players, having them level even faster just makes it less likely for owners to sign/start a level 1 if they don't absolutely have to)
 
SAGA45
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by oldskool
It's still unbalanced. New players are going to make tons of mistakes and cost themselves XP while lacking the physical abilities to realistically produce enough "Impact plays" to get the XP bonuses, while the 'old guard' will have it the other way round (that is, they have the skills to make a lot of impact plays and are experienced enough to not make a ton of boneheaded plays, greatly accelerating their own XPing


Great points, oldskool.

Heres what the devs could do in that case:

The Lower the level: Higher reward for big plays, lower penalty for Harmful plays
The Higher the Level: Lower the reward for big plays, higher the penalty for Harmful plays.

Last edited Apr 12, 2008 13:07:33
 
ThaOutlaw
offline
Link
 
This would also help lower level players catch up. But thered need to be a discipline stat that would cut down on harmful plays.
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.