User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > XP Bonuses for Impact Plays made on the field - a must add
Page:
 
SAGA45
offline
Link
 
Any chance we'll soon see XP bonuses for actual impact plays made like: td's, ints, runs for +10 yds, recs for +20 yds, pancake blocks, forced fumbles, sacks, tackles for loss, fumble recoveries, pass-break-ups, FG's made, kick returns for +40 yds, KR for td's, etc.?

Seems like stamina carries FAR too much importance. If you're a backup player like a DL playing on a rotational basis or a 3rd-down RB, then it's far more critical for you to make the most of the snaps you get.

I'm saying keep the current XP system for snaps played but also add a Bonus XP system for impact plays. That way the stats aren't just stats and players are rewarded for actually helping the team win games regardless of their status on the depth chart and/or how many snaps they get in the game.

I think this would add more strategy and realism to player customization. It'd also deepen depth chart management for the Owners because their could be a backup making big plays and possibly leveling up faster than a starter who's making little to no impact on the team's success.

Thoughts?
Last edited Apr 12, 2008 08:03:19
 
Malachorn
offline
Link
 
I won't even read your suggestion and just ask the admins why this hasn't been implemented yet?

This is a MUST ADD!!!!!

Get on it, admins!!
 
Lazer Noble
offline
Link
 
Like a .5 XP for an impact play. You are right about limited snaps but highly efficient. Should be rewarded.
 
Urrymonster
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Malachorn
I won't even read your suggestion and just ask the admins why this hasn't been implemented yet?

This is a MUST ADD!!!!!

Get on it, admins!!


An entirely unneeded attitude there, it is a valid point and the title is just his opinion so you are more than capable of ignoring it.

On topic though it is something that needs to be addressed as it will bring out players who have decent builds and manage them properly. It should start to get owners looking at getting 'productive' players rather than filling the roster with as many high level players they can. At the end of the day it is entirely possible to completely mis-manage your stat points and have a highly ineffective player, yet they will reap the benefits as they are higher on the depth chart and thus receiving more snaps.

The problem is how to implement it. If the concept is exp is gained for playing time (rightly so). Impact plays would have to affect your actual abilities IMO. Lead the tackles every year and your tackling will increase, that kind of thing. But obviously that could get out of hand, so increases would have to be very slight. The reason I think it has to be this way because impact plays do not increase your experience playing the game. Often it is the scheme, sometimes a players ability, neither increase your experience playing the game though.
 
hiuhyoi
offline
Link
 
Before something like this is implemented lvl caps & salary caps need to be put on leagues so that the lower leagues don't just get farmed out by higher lvl teams bringing their starters down and racking up amazing stats.
 
SAGA45
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Urrymonster

Impact plays would have to affect your actual abilities IMO. Lead the tackles every year and your tackling will increase, that kind of thing. But obviously that could get out of hand, so increases would have to be very slight. The reason I think it has to be this way because impact plays do not increase your experience playing the game. Often it is the scheme, sometimes a players ability, neither increase your experience playing the game though.



But XP directly affect the player's ability to Level Up (the ability to add skill points) therefore, if a player is making Impact Plays, then his Level-up rate has to be impacted in some fashion and right now, other than Boosting, that can only be done through gaining XP.
Last edited Apr 12, 2008 09:08:41
 
Malachorn
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Urrymonster
Originally posted by Malachorn

I won't even read your suggestion and just ask the admins why this hasn't been implemented yet?

This is a MUST ADD!!!!!

Get on it, admins!!


An entirely unneeded attitude there, it is a valid point and the title is just his opinion so you are more than capable of ignoring it.



You can comment on whatever you like. I chose to comment on the title. I think the title was 'asking for it' and I was right. You commented on my comment. You could have chose to ignore it. Or... are you not capable?
 
DiMo28
offline
Link
 
I don't see this as a must add. Experience whether good or bad is still experience. It seems that this good/bad plays are already incorporated into the morale system.
 
HustonJ
offline
Link
 
As I noted in your penalty for failures thread, you've got the concept backwards.

XP represents the player LEARNING something. You learn far less from success than you do form failure.

Success feels better, and might deserve a minor morale boost, but it certainly does NOT teach you anything more about how to play the game.
 
Urrymonster
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Malachorn
Originally posted by Urrymonster

Originally posted by Malachorn


I won't even read your suggestion and just ask the admins why this hasn't been implemented yet?

This is a MUST ADD!!!!!

Get on it, admins!!


An entirely unneeded attitude there, it is a valid point and the title is just his opinion so you are more than capable of ignoring it.



You can comment on whatever you like. I chose to comment on the title. I think the title was 'asking for it' and I was right. You commented on my comment. You could have chose to ignore it. Or... are you not capable?


And thus begins the never ending cycle of marking smart comments. In his initial post he did not demand anything or tell the admins to do anything. If you stopped and read, you would have realised that he was being general and making a suggestion. I do not understand the necessity to 'bite back' or make unneeded comments to people and so I dont really understand why your responded in the manor you did, to him or myself. Have no worries I will now ignore every post you now make based on the example you have shown me. I will judge your petty posts much like you judged the wording on his title.
 
SAGA45
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by HustonJ
As I noted in your penalty for failures thread, you've got the concept backwards.


And, as I responsed in the other thread, I have the concept right.

It's simple...players are rewarded for impact plays and penalized for harmful plays. It's balanced.

Originally posted by HustonJ

XP represents the player LEARNING something. You learn far less from success than you do form failure.


But we both know from watching football that players, no matter how experienced, still make the same mistakes...many of them fundamental. If they didn't there'd be absolutely no reason whatsoever for repetitious drills in practice. That's why IMO the XP Penalty/Bonus system, if implemented, would add a LOT more realism and depth to GBL.

 
Infallable
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SAGA45
Originally posted by HustonJ

As I noted in your penalty for failures thread, you've got the concept backwards.


And, as I responsed in the other thread, I have the concept right.

It's simple...players are rewarded for impact plays and penalized for harmful plays. It's balanced.

Originally posted by HustonJ


XP represents the player LEARNING something. You learn far less from success than you do form failure.


But we both know from watching football that players, no matter how experienced, still make the same mistakes...many of them fundamental. If they didn't there'd be absolutely no reason whatsoever for repetitious drills in practice. That's why IMO the XP Penalty/Bonus system, if implemented, would add a LOT more realism and depth to GBL.



And we both know from watching football players, you don't get better by making good plays, you make better plays by becoming better.
Last edited Apr 12, 2008 13:11:48
 
methomps
offline
Link
 
Players learn just as much from failure as they do from success. A QB who throws a pick may learn a lot from that play, whereas a QB who chucks it to a wide-open WR might not learn all that much.
 
SAGA45
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Infallable
And we both know from watching football players, you don't get better by making good plays, you make better plays by becoming better.


If that were true, there'd be no such thing as a "Break-out" game/season or players regressing. In the GBL, your primary means of getting better are through gaining XP and leveling up (or Boosting with Flex Points)thus the means by which this game measures overall player progression. That's why impact plays should be rewarded and harmful plays penalized through XP - player progression/regression.
 
Infallable
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SAGA45
Originally posted by Infallable

And we both know from watching football players, you don't get better by making good plays, you make better plays by becoming better.


If that were true, there'd be no such thing as a "Break-out" game/season or players regressing. In the GBL, your primary means of getting better are through gaining XP and leveling up (or Boosting with Flex Points)thus the means by which this game measures overall player progression. That's why impact plays should be rewarded and harmful plays penalized through XP - player progression/regression.


That makes no sense at all.

A "breakout" season is when a player finally improves to the point where he's productive. Also, most "breakout" seasons are not repeated the following season, which indicates that the player doesn't not get "better" as a result.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.