User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Discuss GLB Issues With Catch22 > NOT A BUG - CLOSED > We probably would've lost anyhow...but
Page:
 
Yukon Don
offline
Link
 
...the simulator needs to follow the gameplan when auto-adjust is off. At least through the first quarter or two.

We had 70% RUN / 30% PASS selected and here is the pbp text of our first 4 drives

15:00 Kickoff by Kickin DaBalls, 57 yd, fielded by NowYouSeeme NowYouDont (33.5 yd return) [tackle: Resplendent Darkness] Replay
14:49 1st & 10 OWN 47 Steve Bono pass to Harvey Fierstein over the middle [deflected by Green Mango] (incomplete) Replay
14:47 2nd & 10 OWN 47 Wendell Tyler rush to the right (1 yd gain) [tackle: Phat Pat Williams] Replay
14:21 3rd & 9 OWN 48 Steve Bono pass to Harvey Fierstein up the right side [deflected by Green Mango] (incomplete) Replay

*****************************************
11:33 4th & 4.5 OPP 38.5 Punt by Footsy McPunter, 29 yd, fielded by Taste The Rainbow (8.5 yd return) [tackle: Cover Riffic] Replay
11:27 1st & 10 OWN 18.5 Steve Bono pitch to Wendell Tyler to the left (4.5 yd gain) [tackle: Otis Overcash] Replay
10:47 2nd & 5.5 OWN 22.5 Steve Bono pass to Harvey Fierstein, hurried by Tasty Manwich, over the middle (incomplete) Replay
10:45 3rd & 5.5 OWN 22.5 Steve Bono pass to Corey Leyman up the right side (9.5 yd gain) [diving tackle: Purely Epic] Replay
10:00 1st & 10 OWN 32 Steve Bono pitch to Wendell Tyler to the left (5 yd gain) [tackle: Imaknok Ursoxoff] Replay
9:21 2nd & 5 OWN 37 Wendell Tyler rush up the middle (3 yd gain) [tackle: John " The Diesel" Eversleigh] Replay
8:43 3rd & 2 OWN 40.5 Steve Bono pitch to Wendell Tyler to the right (no gain) [diving tackle: John " The Diesel" Eversleigh] Replay

****************************************************

6:19 4th & 11.5 OWN 47 Punt by Footsy McPunter, 22 yd, fielded by Taste The Rainbow (4.5 yd return) [tackle: Cover Riffic] Replay
6:15 1st & 10 OWN 35.5 Steve Bono pitch to Wendell Tyler to the right (2 yd gain) [tackle: Otis Overcash] Replay
5:31 2nd & 8 OWN 37.5 Steve Bono pass to Wendell Tyler up the right side (dropped - incomplete) Replay
5:28 3rd & 8 OWN 37.5 Steve Bono pass to OchO Fckn CinCo over the middle (incomplete) Replay

***************************************************

2:52 Kickoff by Kickin DaBalls, 61 yd, fielded by Taste The Rainbow (31 yd return) [tackle: The Dock] Replay
2:41 1st & 10 OWN 40 Steve Bono pass to Dan "The Hand" Harden over the middle (incomplete) Replay
2:40 2nd & 10 OWN 40 Steve Bono pass to Harvey Fierstein over the middle [deflected by Phat Pat Williams] (incomplete) Replay
2:38 3rd & 10 OWN 40 Steve Bono pass to Corey Leyman, hurried by ImFried ChickenDontEatMe, up the right side [deflected by Otis Overcash] (incomplete) Replay

*****************************************************
Note the ONLY drive that resulted in a 1st down was also the only drive that came close to following our gameplan!!! The trend continued through the 2nd quarter, and by the 3rd & 4th quarter we were behind and I understand at that point why the SIM overrode the gameplan...
Last edited Jul 17, 2008 09:52:00
 
Link
 
Should all be fixed next year. Not much consolation now, but it'll be much better next year.
 
bigtisme
offline
Link
 
Well its not going to follow your plans every time.

I guess 5/5 is not good enough it should have went at least 4/6 if not 3/7.

But like VT said...some of that will be better next season.
 
Checkmate187
offline
Link
 
Here is the thing people don't seem to understand.

Your setting is 70 run, 30 pass.

In essence, the game rolls a 10 sided die. If it comes up 1-3, you will pass.

So, in fact, it is entirely possible you could still pass more than run if you get 'bad' rolls, not to mention the AI override in certain situations.
 
Yukon Don
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Vanilla Thunder
Should all be fixed next year. Not much consolation now, but it'll be much better next year.


It really isn't...especially when we average 5 yards per carry on our outside runs (which inside/outside was set at 2/98)

It just stings to lose so big...I don't doubt the 8-0 (regular season) Walruses would've beat us...but we have a basic formula that worked every game this season...if we got our HB 30 carries...we won. That simple. So settling for 18 carries and 30% of them going up the middle is bothersome.

So we got bad rolls on:
1) run vs. pass
2) outside vs. inside
3) if you really want to know our pass deep was 60% and medium was 35%...but we had a lot of short passes...(more bad rolls)

I understand that the "random" odds are just that, and weird things can happen. But to have the random die work against you that many times in a row seems a bit out of the normal "standard deviation" that you'd expect.

Heck I wouldn't mind if they had shut down the outside run, and just beat us...but we 'gameplanned' for a strategy that we thought would work. It did, when the SIM used it.

Alas, on to recruiting for next season.
 
Yukon Don
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by bigtisme
Well its not going to follow your plans every time.

I guess 5/5 is not good enough it should have went at least 4/6 if not 3/7.

But like VT said...some of that will be better next season.


It did go 4/6 on the one drive that netted a 1st down...I only pasted the 1st quarter drives...ironically 2nd quarter was about the same. Look at the other drives in the 1st quarter...none of them are even 50% run...more or less 70%.

Like I said though...it is over, time to work on next season.
Last edited Jul 17, 2008 10:25:00
 
Koncorde
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by rbedgood

14:49 1st & 10 OWN 47 Steve Bono pass to Harvey Fierstein over the middle [deflected by Green Mango] (incomplete) Replay


First play of the game, when you've selected a 2/3 rush approach. AI goes for pass, which its liable to do. You could argue it should run first, but you left it the opportunity to pass - so it did.

Originally posted by rbedgood
14:47 2nd & 10 OWN 47 Wendell Tyler rush to the right (1 yd gain) [tackle: Phat Pat Williams] Replay
14:21 3rd & 9 OWN 48 Steve Bono pass to Harvey Fierstein up the right side [deflected by Green Mango] (incomplete) Replay


No the CPU did what it thought was best after the failed pass - try a run. Which was stuffed for 1 yard. 3rd and 9...what to you think the AI is going to do?

Originally posted by rbedgood
11:27 1st & 10 OWN 18.5 Steve Bono pitch to Wendell Tyler to the left (4.5 yd gain) [tackle: Otis Overcash] Replay


Starts again. 2/3 is a rush, so you rush on first down.

Originally posted by rbedgood
10:47 2nd & 5.5 OWN 22.5 Steve Bono pass to Harvey Fierstein, hurried by Tasty Manwich, over the middle (incomplete) Replay


Pass on second.

Originally posted by rbedgood
10:45 3rd & 5.5 OWN 22.5 Steve Bono pass to Corey Leyman up the right side (9.5 yd gain) [diving tackle: Purely Epic] Replay


So 3rd and 5.5...well of course its going to pass.

Originally posted by rbedgood
10:00 1st & 10 OWN 32 Steve Bono pitch to Wendell Tyler to the left (5 yd gain) [tackle: Imaknok Ursoxoff] Replay
9:21 2nd & 5 OWN 37 Wendell Tyler rush up the middle (3 yd gain) [tackle: John " The Diesel" Eversleigh] Replay
8:43 3rd & 2 OWN 40.5 Steve Bono pitch to Wendell Tyler to the right (no gain) [diving tackle: John " The Diesel" Eversleigh] Replay


And then when the AI decides to run you can't make 3rd down.

Originally posted by rbedgood
6:15 1st & 10 OWN 35.5 Steve Bono pitch to Wendell Tyler to the right (2 yd gain) [tackle: Otis Overcash] Replay


Runs on first down leaving you with 2nd and 8. Given your rushing average is at 3 at this point, I'm not surprised it opted to pass given there's no guarrantee you run is going to get anywhere close.

Originally posted by rbedgood
5:31 2nd & 8 OWN 37.5 Steve Bono pass to Wendell Tyler up the right side (dropped - incomplete) Replay
5:28 3rd & 8 OWN 37.5 Steve Bono pass to OchO Fckn CinCo over the middle (incomplete) Replay


Unlucky. After your WR drops it, you have to go again with the pass as its 3rd and 8 so its going to pass.

The real reason your team failed to run was because you couldn't set the run up with your passing game. Similarly you couldn't support the pass with your run when it needed to.
 
Yukon Don
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Koncorde


The real reason your team failed to run was because you couldn't set the run up with your passing game. Similarly you couldn't support the pass with your run when it needed to.


Except the plays that we asked for (RUN OUTSIDE) averaged 5 yards per carry. The SIM just didn't call them. I understand this is over, and it can't be undone...I also understand that with the advanced AI we should have some better control.

I love the game, and also understand (before someone else says it)...this is BETA.

I'm not going crazy like others and asking for anything...but the randomizer certainly strayed much farther from our gameplan than I'd expect, considering the 'auto-adjust' was off.

Appreciate your analysis though.
 
wombat killer
offline
Link
 
You have to throw the third and long passes our of the equation.
 
Koncorde
offline
Link
 
Your "pitch" plays to the outside averaged 5 for the game, but out of the 80 yards gained 19 and 14 were on single plays making your "down" average 3.5.

The issue really is that in the situation you were in at certain times in the game it was dictated that you needed to pass, which overrode your decision making. The reason for that is:
A - you averaged only 2.6 yards per carry in the first quarter. 3 downs of 2.6 yards isn't a first down.
B - in the second quarter you averaged 4 yards per carry, and as a result ran the ball 10 times to passing 4 (which is actually more than 70% run) but unfortunately were tackled for a loss, and lost a fumble.
C - in the 3rd quarter (by which point you're down by 17pts or so) your team goes 50/50. Not helped by a tackle for loss, and your starter being pulled from the game.
D - in the 4th quarter you're down by more than 3TD's and throwing to stay in the game.

So basically you ran reasonably well - but when your team needed to pass, you couldn't do it effectively enough. Really that 30% "passing" was your bane because you couldn't complete effectively. This meant you were chasing the game and therefore passing more...which you couldn't do.

Really, if you know you can't pass the ball - why even give it the option to pass 1/3 attempts?
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Koncorde


Really, if you know you can't pass the ball - why even give it the option to pass 1/3 attempts?


I agree we should have had it at more like 90/10 run/pass. that way we might actually get 70/30 and that is why this is posted in the bugs thread. Because we asked for 70/30 and the first 4 drives were almost 30/70, once were down by 3 TDs in the 4th, I realize the game will change the settings that is why we are just talking about the first 4 drives, when it should be following our settings.
 
dkgojackets
offline
Link
 
If he gets it exactly 70/30 then this thread is titled "why do we always run the ball on third and long?"
 
Koncorde
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by dkgojackets
If he gets it exactly 70/30 then this thread is titled "why do we always run the ball on third and long?"


Exactomundo

Originally posted by bedgood42
Originally posted by Koncorde



Really, if you know you can't pass the ball - why even give it the option to pass 1/3 attempts?


I agree we should have had it at more like 90/10 run/pass. that way we might actually get 70/30 and that is why this is posted in the bugs thread. Because we asked for 70/30 and the first 4 drives were almost 30/70, once were down by 3 TDs in the 4th, I realize the game will change the settings that is why we are just talking about the first 4 drives, when it should be following our settings.


No, because you see 90/10 means you would probably run on 1st down and gain 2.5 yards. On 2nd down you'd run and make 2.5 yards...meaning you'd need 5 yards on the next run. So the AI will say "we'll pass!" because there's a better chance of making 5 through the air.

Then on your next set of downs it might say "right, we'll run first" and get 5 yards. Then say "we'll run again" and get 2.5. And then say "run again" and get 0...

And then on your third drive it might say "lets pass first and gain 0 yards" so it chooses to run next and gains 0 yards....so what do you think it'll do on 3rd down? Pass.

Then again it might have succeeded with the first pass for 2 yards. Ran with the next effort for 4 yards and decided 4 is a bit of a stretch - so passed again.

All are different scenarious that could have occured on any single down that you had in the game that the percentages cannot take into consideration every single time.
 
Yukon Don
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by dkgojackets
If he gets it exactly 70/30 then this thread is titled "why do we always run the ball on third and long?"


Ummm...since our HB is by far our best weapon we'd rather run on 3rd and 5, than pass. Hoping to fix that in the offseason, but of our 10 longest plays from scrimmage ALL 10 this season were running plays. We only had 2-3 passes over 30 yards. 3rd and long we had better odds running anyhow.

...and as the title states I wasn't arguing the game result, more that the playcalling was frustrating.
Last edited Jul 17, 2008 13:39:14
 
bigtisme
offline
Link
 
Yea anytime over 3rd and 3.5 it always passes in the current AI. But advanced offense will clear that up anyway.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.