User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > Add a Moderator Code of Conduct
Rage Kinard
offline
Link
 
Please add your name if you believe GLB needs a moderator code of ethics.


Moderators in GLB are the most visible authority figures of the game. Since success in this game is centered around message board use, and they have authority over the message boards, it also makes them the most prominent authority figures of the game.

With authority, also comes responsibility and the expectations of a higher code of conduct. In society, police are expected to maintain a higher code of conduct whether in or out of uniform than the average citizen is held to. Teachers, religous leaders, military officers, and others who hold positions of authority over groups of people are also held to higher standards. The same should be true for moderators of not only games but any message board in general.

Because of this I propose that GLB adopt a moderator code of conduct. Those moderators who want to abide by it can maintain their position. Those who feel it is to restrictive can choose to give up their position as I am sure there are many people who would be willing to apply for the positions and abide by it.

The code should include but not be limited to

1. Moderators should maintain a civil and professional demeanor when responding to threads or posts. No matter how ridiculous a comment is, how many times a question has been asked, or how misguided the poster is in his comments or accusations, moderators should never answer in a sarcastic, mean spirited, or emotional manner.

2. Moderators should never be able to moderate a thread in which they are actively participating in a debate. If they are a participant and feel a thread is getting out of hand, they should notify another moderator not involved, and let that moderator judge whether or not intervention is needed.

3. Moderators should not use their name to advertise their teams or players. The act of being a moderator, inherently gives one a position of much higher visibility. It also causes many members of the community to beleive that they have extra knowledge about how the game works and how players should be created. Whether this opinion is valid or not, is of no consequence. The fact that the belief exists among a significant percentage of the community presents an opportunity for moderators to take advantage of their name.

Moderators can still recruit and they can still try to get their players on a team. Examples of appropriate threads:
USA PRO PLAYOFF CONTENDER needs a few good players
Level 4 player with custom equipment and will boost looking for new team

Examples of inappropriate threads:
MODERATOR A is looking for players
MODERATOR B has 3 players looking for a home

4. Moderators may not make propositions that the vast majority of customers could never find someone to agree to. It does not matter if there are a few non-moderators who could gain the same advantage, because moderators should be held to higher standard. If less than 5% of the community could expect to have a proposition met, then a moderator should not make it.

Example of an inappropriate proposition:
I have a level 3 DT with no custom, and I will not boost until the end of the season. I am an experienced active team player, and I will boost at the end of each season, but I will not share his build. I want a 1 year contract and a starting spot. However, I will help out the team in any way I can.

5. Moderators can not let owners with moderator players on the team use that as a recruiting tool. They must tell owners up front that this practice is not allowed, and they can lose forum priviledges for doing it. Once again, if people believe that moderators have special knowledge because of their position, it is an unfair recruiting tool whether it is true or not.

6. It is not enough for a moderator to abide by the letter of the law. Moderators must always try to act in a manner that upholds the spirit of the game. If a practice seems to be questionable, or in a grey area, they should get approval from development before engaging in that practice.
 
Tim Harper
offline
Link
 
Lots of underhand comments in this post directed towards specific moderators. I am sorry, but I am not for another flamefest for no reason. I will post your suggestion in the mod forum though.

Tim
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Tim Harper
Lots of underhand comments in this post directed towards specific moderators. I am sorry, but I am not for another flamefest for no reason. I will post your suggestion in the mod forum though.

Tim


Agreed, I will take a look.

Like I stated before, the admins have a scheduled meeting quite soon and we will discuss what we want to do to help the community trust our mod team. Anything like this needs to be black and white, clear cut, and not open for debate (such as rule #4 above).
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.